Yeah I didn't quite catch onto that theme, but I'm glad I see it now thanks to Baby Tea's analysis of it. I found the whole thing quite amazing and at the end.... I felt like I was in shock... truly terrified about the whole thing.Baby Tea said:I'm glad I'm not the only one who saw that theme!Dastardly said:Snip 2.0Baby Tea said:Snip 1.0
Great points on the parents wanting a baby, and the kid wanting a new robot, and the similarities betwixt the two.
It really is quite a scathing commentary when you really look at that theme closely.
That, I think, is what truly made it creepy for me.
Not what Blinky did. But what he was the product of. Or, rather, what he was the mirror of.
The perfect, cold, mechanical mirror of that family.
Again: great piece.
Honestly that was my first thought, it's such a well know piece of science fiction at this point that I practically see it as a plot hole; No one would build a household robot with the ability to kill.DTWolfwood said:Why isn't he programmed with Asimov's laws?!?! oh of all the humanity why?! XD
note to self: install paradox-absorbing crumple zones on all robots so they don't crash and wake up misinterpreting commands.
Agreed, another plot hole that I tripped head over heals into was the fact that the robot moves slow as hell. How did he manage to catch and kill the dad, the mom and the dog before any of them could run away? How did the robot fashion the boy into little balls with his big ass hands? Not to mention the meat would have been rough as shit if it wasn't ground up/tenderized. Then the parents would have known for sure there was a problem.SomeBritishDude said:Honestly that was my first thought, it's such a well know piece of science fiction at this point that I practically see it as a plot hole; No one would build a household robot with the ability to kill.
Also the kid cammanded him to kill people...where was the cammand to turn him into meat balls exactly? It really felt like something that was forced in there.
I enjoyed it, the direction was good and the robots really look like something that we'll possibley see in households 20 or so years down the line, but it had some problems.
Ah, but the thing is, those very laws would impair functionality, and that's something the human race will never do. "It can't kill? Well what if there is an intruder in the home? Does it just stand back and smile as they die?"j-e-f-f-e-r-s said:Very well done. I actually felt pretty sick at the end. Which I suppose was the intended response. Very clever story as well, and there's some good analysis of what happened going on here.
However, as someone who's read quite a few of the works of Isaac Asimov: If engineers program robots with the Three Laws of Robotics hard-wired into them, then none of this would happen. Seriously, in some of his essays Asimov examined how if robots are programmed correctly, things like this are impossible. Robots are tools, like anything else. I believe he said something along the lines of "You wouldn't read a story about hammers rising up and destroying humanity." I don't mean to rant, I just find it quite funny how Isaac Asimov deconstructed the very genre he created over fifty years ago, yet we're still terrified by the thought of robots turning on their masters.
1. The Meatball command came from the mom, "If you make another mess like that I"ll have Blinky clean and cook YOU for supper"Shiftysnowdog said:Agreed, another plot hole that I tripped head over heals into was the fact that the robot moves slow as hell. How did he manage to catch and kill the dad, the mom and the dog before any of them could run away? How did the robot fashion the boy into little balls with his big ass hands? Not to mention the meat would have been rough as shit if it wasn't ground up/tenderized. Then the parents would have known for sure there was a problem.SomeBritishDude said:Honestly that was my first thought, it's such a well know piece of science fiction at this point that I practically see it as a plot hole; No one would build a household robot with the ability to kill.
Also the kid cammanded him to kill people...where was the cammand to turn him into meat balls exactly? It really felt like something that was forced in there.
I enjoyed it, the direction was good and the robots really look like something that we'll possibley see in households 20 or so years down the line, but it had some problems.
Le Sigh*
Is this short good just because it has a decent looking rendered robot?
Honestly the most disturbing thing about this was "No problem". Other than that it was like watching a highway pileup consisting of Irobot, Where the wild things are, and The south park episode Chilli Con Carnival. Not a lick of creativity here folks.
To everyone saying the meatballs scene was a bit retarded; this.Dastardly said:Logan, you missed a crucial plot point!Logan Westbrook said:Permalink
He didn't kill because he remembered Alex's instructions--he remembered the mother's instructions. "If you make another mess like this... I'll have Blinky clean and cook you for dinner!" And then, he throws the glass, makes a mess, and Blinky "does as he was told."