Scariest Game Ever Made

Recommended Videos

SL33TBL1ND

Elite Member
Nov 9, 2008
6,467
0
41
Thaius said:
Let me be the first to say the Fatal Frame series. Besides having a great atmosphere and just good design all around, the psychological terror induced by needing to go from third to first person in order to fight your already horrifying enemy is absolute brilliance.
Or Project 0 as it is called in Australia, this and Silent Hill. Scariest shit ever.
 

wgreer25

Good news everyone!
Jun 9, 2008
764
0
0
Demon Souls? Maybe at how horrific the controls were.

Alien Vs. Predator 2 for PC was surprisingly good for the scares (the sound really did in that game).

The obvious Silent Hill 2, of coarse. And I will mirror other in saying the Crimson Butterfly series.

I would say Dead Space, but Dead space was only scary for the first 4 or 5 chapters. Don't get me wrong, I loved the game. Played it through about 4 times. But in order to be horror (IMO) you have to have fear of death, and there was just too much ammo in dead space. There weren't that many times (later in the game) that I had real fear of death.

Now saying all that, I am VERY impressed with Alan Wake. The story telling is just amazing, the story itself is really good (I'm in episode 4 now, great plot twist there). And the combat is great as well. It is a very neat concept in that you do have guns, but they are completely useless until you have hit the targets with light, and they will be charging you while you are doing it. So basically, in every encounter in the game, the enemies will be able to get right up on you, so the fear of death is there in almost every encounter (and I have died at least a dozen times).

Another cool item is that Alan doesn't feel like a macho space marine, he feels like a clumsy writer... as he should. His dodge move looks so hap-hazzard an uncontrolled, it really adds to the character. Add to that (like Dead Space) the game is beautiful with great sound. And the story and some other gameplay elements help add to the horror. Like the manuscript pages, some/most of them are forshadowing and telling you what will come in the near future (awesome story element as well). This sounds like it would spoil what is about to happen, but instead it has made me anxious and looking over my shoulder on more than one occasion. Like, minor spoiler...
Like the page that tells you of your first encounter with a chainsaw wielding lumberjack... it took forever to actually get to the guy and I had been looking over my shoulder for the past hour or so expecting him.

Add to this there are chapters/scenes where you have limited resources. (i.e. a flashlight and a couple of flash-bangs). Or a flashlight with 4 batteries and 12 rounds in a revolver. In other moments it does seem that you have an abundance of batteries/flares, but that doesn't really lessen the horror aspect because you have to keep using the focused flashlight and flares to get the guys off you, so you are constantly changing batteries and reloading while there are 3-4 taken about to slice and dice you about 2 feet away... it can be intense. Add to that that Alan can only take about 3 hit before he is toast.

So best horror game in the past couple of years... Alan Wake, by far.
 

traineesword

New member
Jan 24, 2010
410
0
0
Hubilub said:
Silent Hill: Shattered Memories, while not the scariest, was really fucking horrifying.

What stands out in my mind is when you piece by piece discover the fate of a newly moved in cheerleader on the team who got drugged, raped by the entire football team, then left out in the snow, dead.
i was thinking just that XD the game itself, the main storyline, is not whats scary. its to do with the mobile messages. and i don't mean taking the pictures or when the light starts to flicker (annoyingly its usually when i am trying to listen to another message ¬_¬). The actual messages themselves and the stories they tell/suggest. many of them are pretty disturbing for our middle-class comfortable selves.
The game itself though is very unscary. you know how you were led by that black-shadow that resembled Harry Mason's young daughter. you'd see the shadow, then hear a scream and watch her run off in the direction you should follow her. would have been much scarier if the game ensured that we were actually able to see her most the time! half the time i just heard a scream and was confused at what was so scary about the wall that made Harry shriek.

Silent Hill 2 must be pretty scary. i never actually played it, but i watched some cutscenes in the dark, started at about 9:30, finished at 11:00 and took me another 10 minutes to calm down before i could move to go to the toilet. i want that game.

hmm, a few people are putting down games i would consider "jumpy" as opposed to scary. Sure, i am guarenteed to jump, but i don't leave the game shuddering and looking around in fear. infact, i even renamed a particular game J.U.M.P because i found its title heavily misleading.
 

V TheSystem V

New member
Sep 11, 2009
996
0
0
Resident Evil Remake. Scared the shit out of me. As did Resident Evil 0, but I got further through that.

Dead Space had a lot of tension, but I didn't find it scary, just jumpy. Very disturbing in some parts though, bring on Dead Space 2!
 

kurupt87

Fuhuhzucking hellcocks I'm good
Mar 17, 2010
1,438
0
0
System Shock 2 for me, only game that ever made me ask, "Can't I just stay here?*sob*"
 

Akalistos

New member
Apr 23, 2010
1,440
0
0
Quiet Stranger said:
Hubilub said:
Silent Hill: Shattered Memories, while not the scariest, was really fucking horrifying. [horrifyingly boring.]

What stands out in my mind is when you piece by piece discover the fate of a newly moved in cheerleader on the team who got drugged, raped by the entire football team, then left out in the snow, dead. [I own it and i didn't care about her. They should have made a point of using it for puzzle. After all, silent hill is know to make you do weird puzzle base on horrible event.]
You're right, that WHOLE game is horrifying (cause it sucked ass) to this day I think the scariest game is the first Silent Hill, they need to do a proper remake (which would just be updated graphics) actually you know what? They don't need one, it's just that good.

Also does anyone know the game I'm trying to think of? It seemed pretty scary, I saw a trailer for it on it's website (it hasn't come out yet) It's a PC game and you're this guy in some kind of dark castle. You hear this scream and as you go to check it out you see this monster in the room with blood all over the floor. You have no weapons at all so you gotta hide in things and not die, anyways the monster chases after you but you go into a room and hide in a wardrobe
Do you mean another Haunting Ground [http://www.dreamdawn.com/sh/info.php?name=Clock%20Tower:%20The%20First%20Fear]. It the same thing, only you can call a dog to get aways from the Mouse and Man giant reject that after your boobies (both game, you play as a female character.)That and traps you can lay down for the doofus.
 

Akalistos

New member
Apr 23, 2010
1,440
0
0
riottrio said:
Silent Hill 2 must be pretty scary. i never actually played it, but i watched some cutscenes in the dark, started at about 9:30, finished at 11:00 and took me another 10 minutes to calm down before i could move to go to the toilet. i want that game.
You are right, that the best horror game out there. I own it and sometime feel scare of going back. That didn't help that i was halfway through the game when i needed to reformat my computer. It still there, but i didn't beat that game... sadly.
riottrio said:
Hmm, a few people are putting down games i would consider "jumpy" as opposed to scary. Sure, i am guaranteed to jump, but i don't leave the game shuddering and looking around in fear. In fact, i even renamed a particular game J.U.M.P because i found its title heavily misleading.
You got to understand new gamers... they don't feel the need to go back and play classic like old or Retro gamers. They are happy with what on the store shelf, without knowing that there were better stuff out there. Dead Space is one of them. But, can you really blame them when all they played are Doom 3 or Bioshock. Wait no, Bioshock isn't considered horror, even by the makers.
 

The Austin

New member
Jul 20, 2009
3,368
0
0
Dr. Awesome Face said:
The Austin said:
Limzz said:
The Austin said:
I've said it before, and I'll say it again.
Dead Space.

To me, it was a perfect combination of action and horror.

[sub] Okay, maybe a little heavy on the horror. [/sub]
I didn't find dead space to really be horror. Sure, it startled you occasionally but that's not scary. I was startled when a june bug was in my shoe. Not quite horror.

I'm gonna go with System Shock 2 on this one.

Yea, I guess your right, I just guess I'll just-

[HEADING=1] OMG! NECROMORPH! [/HEADING]



See? Pretty damn scary, huh? :D
yeah that is pretty scary (and an ugly ************ at that) but you don't ever see a necromorph look like that up close in the game. I only really found the first levels of Dead Space scary. Running down the dark halls with the first necromorph running behind you trying to cut you up. Freaked me out! But after the first two levels were over, I had adapted and wasn't really getting scared at all......Until I got cocky and tried my hand at impossible difficulty. That is a true "Shit just got real" moment.
True that. To me, the shit was always real.

Although while playing Dead Space, I did go through what I call the "Bad-ass zone". It's the feeling you get after all of the scares have stopped affecting you, and you just become desensitized from anything the Necromorphs throw at you.

So I can understand why the game would be less scary than others.
 

iFail69

New member
Nov 17, 2009
578
0
0
Original Silent Hill game.

If you can see past the pixels, it's actually pretty tense and jumpy at points
 

spuddaemon

New member
Nov 9, 2009
111
0
0
The Austin said:
I've said it before, and I'll say it again.
Dead Space.

To me, it was a perfect combination of action and horror.

[sub] Okay, maybe a little heavy on the horror. [/sub]
Agreed... the sounds of metal pipes falling and rolling around, chains & water drops, and of course the sudden appearance of dead babies with tentacles... *ugh*
 

lozfoe444

New member
Aug 26, 2009
189
0
0
The atmosphere of Portal really got to me. It wasn't really scary, but I couldn't look behind my back for a while.
 

sageoftruth

New member
Jan 29, 2010
3,417
0
0
My friend's girlfriend's ear-piercing scream when she played Resistance: Fall of Man and ran into... anything. Thank God she never tried any of the above.
 

swolf

New member
May 3, 2010
1,189
0
0
snowman6251 said:
What do you think is the scariest game ever made?

My vote goes to Demon's Souls. On my first playthrough in particular this game was horrifying. Knowing that something is trying to get me around every corner and knowing the huge price that comes with letting it get me quickly created an environment of extreme paranoia and caution within my bedroom. I tiptoed one step forward, two steps back, with my shield up, through the whole game. Levels that can be done in 15 minutes took me upwards of two hours because of my overly cautious approach.

In the end it was effective because I died on only a handful of occasions (mostly thanks to Flamelurker and Old King Allant) but my first trip through Demon's Souls legendarily hostile world was a terrifying one. Also The Tower of Latria still scares the crap out of me despite the fact that I know the layout by heart now.

Anyway what do you think is the scariest game ever made?
The original Silent Hill trilogy (okay...include 4:The Room), I also thought Condemned had more than just jump scares as opposed to what others have said. I mean, the Tibbits scene in the locker was creepy and I was forced to wonder if this was "real" or a hallucination. I also kinda wondered if there actually was a SKX instead of maybe this guy being psycho himself and hunting down his other personality or something. Also, I enjoyed that, even though you were able to obtain firearms in the game, they were very limited in ammo and, once they ran out, you were stuck using it as a club which is practically the most useless weapon in the game. One I thought deserves an honorable mention (but I don't really consider horror, it was more of an action game with a horror theme but had a good lead-in with it's "prison is hell" video) "The Suffering"