@Aero: Well, considering we were all working off of misinformation, two of our "suspects" had been popped off the list. Considering that in previous games, from my, albeit limited, experience, many people have forgotten who exactly is a suspect when the list gets buried past a few pages and a few have been killed off, it's generally nice to keep an updated list for everyone to keep track of. Trying to find out who the Killer is is a group effort, and making sure everyone knows who is suspect after we have received information from the Spy can be crucial. However, now it's come to light that we potentially cannot trust the Spy too much, considering how easy it was for you to spread misinformation amongst us and, effectively, doom us to failure due to your untimely demise before your gambit could be completed.
Had you not broken the rules by revealing post-mortum that in fact the Killer is not a Pub-Club member, we would have continued on with the only list we had been provided, thus flailing about and achieving nothing, potentially executing off people with roles (Which so far is the Killer, Lawyer, and our Arbiter). Perhaps the Arbiter might have executed someone themselves, only to find out that they'd executed someone innocent because they were fed bad info from our only source of info. I'd be pretty pissed if I were them.
At this point, the game has hit such a clusterfuck period that sheer dumb luck will be the only way for us to win.
