Serial Killer Round 70: Soviet Submarine Slaughter!

[Fat Hippo]

Thank god I'd have been embarrassed if I fell for it

Yeah, me too. I actually had suspicions about you for a pretty long time, but was pretty convinced by the end that you weren't a bad'un.

To be fair to Frappe that kind of thing is what he was supposed to be doing as the doppelganger *sigh*

True, but the problem was that people were listening to it.

To be honest, for a lot of the game I was annoyed at you guys being right. In a just world, the killer would've been Jux or something.

Yeah, that's kind of a good point, though things would probably have gone very differently after the original accusation of Roy, if he had in fact not been the killer, or at least the lawyer. As it was, the things that happened served to deepen the suspicions of enough players, and we got lucky with Jux as the Arbiter.

 

[EvilRoy]

To be honest, for a lot of the game I was annoyed at you guys being right. In a just world, the killer would've been Jux or something.

I will second this. For half the game I was thinking "Man, if Twintix was the killer instead of me these guys would be so fucked". I ended up having to swing emotional because keeping arguments half finished and in and out kept people from drawing hard conclusions as the voting demonstrated. Unfortunately Jux has a heart of ice, or is at least readily influenced by James, so that didn't last as long as I wanted.

It was a shame as well that Gritch died so early, I was kind of hoping it would be someone else. That way I could have kept working the "Gritch is the realz killer influencing all of you sheeple" angle. Also it was bad that Gritch died because MY GOD I wanted to gloat. Sweet jesus it was hard to keep from doing that.

 

[gritch]

To be honest, for a lot of the game I was annoyed at you guys being right. In a just world, the killer would've been Jux or something.

I will second this. For half the game I was thinking "Man, if Twintix was the killer instead of me these guys would be so fucked". I ended up having to swing emotional because keeping arguments half finished and in and out kept people from drawing hard conclusions as the voting demonstrated. Unfortunately Jux has a heart of ice, or is at least readily influenced by James, so that didn't last as long as I wanted.

It was a shame as well that Gritch died so early, I was kind of hoping it would be someone else. That way I could have kept working the "Gritch is the realz killer influencing all of you sheeple" angle. Also it was bad that Gritch died because MY GOD I wanted to gloat. Sweet jesus it was hard to keep from doing that.

It was you and altnameJag that voted for me that round, right? I honestly thought I deconstructed that "sheeple" angle pretty thoroughly. I doubt anyone was going to go for that. Still curious if you two didn't vote for me it means you managed to convince somebody somehow.

 

[Fat Hippo]

It was you and altnameJag that voted for me that round, right? I honestly thought I deconstructed that "sheeple" angle pretty thoroughly. I doubt anyone was going to go for that. Still curious if you two didn't vote for me it means you managed to convince somebody somehow.

I had also assumed that you were the ones who voted for gritch? But apparently you actually didn't want him to die early, so that wasn't the case? That would just have been a super weird coincidence.

 

[EvilRoy]

It was you and altnameJag that voted for me that round, right? I honestly thought I deconstructed that "sheeple" angle pretty thoroughly. I doubt anyone was going to go for that. Still curious if you two didn't vote for me it means you managed to convince somebody somehow.

I had also assumed that you were the ones who voted for gritch? But apparently you actually didn't want him to die early, so that wasn't the case? That would just have been a super weird coincidence.

Well I voted for Gritch because I had to - all the effort spent being all "Oh man what if its really him blah blah" would be wasted if he got 0 votes because people would realize I was bullshitting. I don't actually know if Jag voted for him.

Thing was, it was a little bit of a combination of me being certain I was dead, hindsight about wanting a hard surface to argue on, and not believing for a second that one or two votes would actually be enough to kill a dude. It was right there that I realized nobody believed you, AND nobody believed me, so I started the whole "Welp, I was wrong, ignore me" thing. That's also what spawned the "I survived at the start because nobody voted for me because nobody went in for your BS" argument that I trotted out whenever people were arguing me down too well. It also gave me the opportunity to go on the defensive and stop accusing after having effectively 'accidentally' killed two guys for poor reasons.

 

[TheMysteriousGX]

Yeah, I voted for gritch too, but c'mon, 6 way tie? Not evidence of anything.

 

[Fat Hippo]

Yeah, I voted for gritch too, but c'mon, 6 way tie? Not evidence of anything.

Hah, damn, I was right about more stuff than I actually fully believed by the end of the game. Not gonna lie, that gives me some satisfaction.

 

[snekadid]

Ok super sleuths, while we wait on the next game, how about you figure out who killed Armadox >

 

[Fat Hippo]

Ok super sleuths, while we wait on the next game, how about you figure out who killed Armadox >

Er....are you trying to indicate it wasn't the killer and his crew? (plus 2 more randos)

 

[snekadid]

Well, assuming the killer crew all voted for him + aero, that's 4 votes. Assuming you're all telling the truth and voted for Roy, that's 4 votes. So the question is, who killed armadox?

 

[FPLOON]

Well, assuming the killer crew all voted for him + aero, that's 4 votes. Assuming you're all telling the truth and voted for Roy, that's 4 votes. So the question is, who killed armadox?

Caramel Frappe... because he [Armadox] knew too much...

 

[snekadid]

Well, assuming the killer crew all voted for him + aero, that's 4 votes. Assuming you're all telling the truth and voted for Roy, that's 4 votes. So the question is, who killed armadox?

Caramel Frappe... because he [Armadox] knew too much...

Frappe as the dopple was one of the killers crew so he cant possibly of been the fifth vote that killed poor poor armadox

 

[FPLOON]

Well, assuming the killer crew all voted for him + aero, that's 4 votes. Assuming you're all telling the truth and voted for Roy, that's 4 votes. So the question is, who killed armadox?

Caramel Frappe... because he [Armadox] knew too much...

Frappe as the dopple was one of the killers crew so he cant possibly of been the fifth vote that killed poor poor armadox

That's like saying "Caesar was still stabbed multiple times, but Brutus wasn't the main stabber"...

 

[snekadid]

No its not, cause poor armadox would have lived if not for the last guy. Its the final vote, the guy that pulled the switch on the chair and ended his life. if your not confident you can figure it out tho, id understand.

 

[FPLOON]

Wait... There's more than one "Brutus" in this situation?

 

[gritch]

It was Jux wasn't it? Jux is the Brutus here. Torn between Roy or Armadox for who to kill. After Armadox was executed that suspicion was removed. Would explain why it took Jux so long to act with their Arbiter ability.

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

It was Jux wasn't it? Jux is the Brutus here. Torn between Roy or Armadox for who to kill. After Armadox was executed that suspicion was removed. Would explain why it took Jux so long to act with their Arbiter ability.

When he PMed me telling me he was gonna kill Roy he told me he voted for me actually

 

[gritch]

When he PMed me telling me he was gonna kill Roy he told me he voted for me actually

Damn. That would've been juicy. Our savior killing an innocent before saving us all. Thought that might be why GMKittyComrade was teasing us so much about it too.

Oh well I suppose it doesn't really matter.

 

[snekadid]

Keep going, > I'm not allowed to tell you about who voted for who, but I like who killed armadox.

 

[Fat Hippo]

Keep going, > I'm not allowed to tell you about who voted for who, but I like who killed armadox.

What are you talking about? Once the round is over you can tell people everything you like. Previous GM's have sometimes linked to entire spreadsheets showing who voted for whom in every single round.