Serial Killer Round 70: Soviet Submarine Slaughter!

[TheMysteriousGX]

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

 

[Dying_Jester]

@Secondhand Revenant: I must admit, i'm impressed with you of all people. Despite the odds, you kept going for Roy without ever giving up. Even in doubt or others trying to kill everyone else off (Roy vs Armadox cycle) ... you were convincing. Heck you got Lux to take out Roy- and if not for that, we would of overpowered you Commies in votes. So congrats to being the sole reason apart from Lux being the finishing blow- to win the Round. You're a hero

Thanks! Though I think it was getting suicidal by the end considering how many seemed to want to kill me by the end and how little progress we appeared to make.

Hippo was an ardent kill Roy supporter too I think. As were some of the poor dead people...

Also DCJF was the first to yell for the arbiter. I only echoed XD

I didn't want you dead. Felt like I was the only one who wanted Frappe dead, though.
Well, except for our good last minute traitor. A hero to everyone, showing that he'd go to either side of the room, well past the line drawn down the middle to get Frappe taken down.

 

[crimson5pheonix]

snip

Me Dema and Hippo shared right at the end. But you tried to tell me and Dema to kill kingofkumquats when he was already dead I believe.

Tbh I didn't trust you and was waiting to see if the killer stabbed you which is what I would assume he'd do if you didn't join him and we didn't look like we were going to kill you. If you lived I was gonna take the PM public.

That would have been okay. Then I'd just have pointed out who I didn't tell you to kill. Unfortunately, it would only have bought us the lawyer.

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

See, I was under the impression that lawyer powers only told you IF someone had a role, not what role they had. Your PM threw me off, so I started acting more directly than I normally do.

@NewGM: I'm down to clown.

 

[crimson5pheonix]

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

To be fair, I had been voting on you since round one. I figured you were the killer before the game started. I was CLOSE, but not quite right.

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

Yah but if he revealed he was the arbiter when he died people may give him a lot more credibility.

The post execution vote count is pretty rough. On the other hand it gives a lot of us stuff to actually talk about and use.

I'm guessing it was unexpected for you guys that it would suddenly appear? It caught me off guard and I figured it probably caught the evil team off guard. Because otherwise you can always split your vote a bit. And if the doppelganger is going to be immediately aware I think something to split the evil side vote a bit isn't too bad.

@Secondhand Revenant: I must admit, i'm impressed with you of all people. Despite the odds, you kept going for Roy without ever giving up. Even in doubt or others trying to kill everyone else off (Roy vs Armadox cycle) ... you were convincing. Heck you got Lux to take out Roy- and if not for that, we would of overpowered you Commies in votes. So congrats to being the sole reason apart from Lux being the finishing blow- to win the Round. You're a hero

Thanks! Though I think it was getting suicidal by the end considering how many seemed to want to kill me by the end and how little progress we appeared to make.

Hippo was an ardent kill Roy supporter too I think. As were some of the poor dead people...

Also DCJF was the first to yell for the arbiter. I only echoed XD

I didn't want you dead. Felt like I was the only one who wanted Frappe dead, though.
Well, except for our good last minute traitor. A hero to everyone, showing that he'd go to either side of the room, well past the line drawn down the middle to get Frappe taken down.

Was talking about the 3 votes on me. I assumed the evil team hit armadox. With 3 innocents against me plus that... I figured I was possibly screwed. Then again if I died people might take my anti EvilRoy position more seriously.

I was ready to off Frappe to break their voting power if we couldn't kill Roy. I just wanted our vote to be united.

 

[Godzillarich(aka tf2godz)]

(fired both @CaramelFrappe and @altnameJag out of the sub like a missile)

Good work comrades! we saved Russia

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

snip

Me Dema and Hippo shared right at the end. But you tried to tell me and Dema to kill kingofkumquats when he was already dead I believe.

Tbh I didn't trust you and was waiting to see if the killer stabbed you which is what I would assume he'd do if you didn't join him and we didn't look like we were going to kill you. If you lived I was gonna take the PM public.

That would have been okay. Then I'd just have pointed out who I didn't tell you to kill. Unfortunately, it would only have bought us the lawyer.

I'd have used it as more ammo in my (correct) theory that the first round the killer and lawyer voted together and altname admitted to trying to kill DCJF.

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

See, I was under the impression that lawyer powers only told you IF someone had a role, not what role they had. Your PM threw me off, so I started acting more directly than I normally do.

@NewGM: I'm down to clown.

I thought the same.

And I'm also up for another game. I think this round went a bit mad but was fun.

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

To be fair, I had been voting on you since round one. I figured you were the killer before the game started. I was CLOSE, but not quite right.

I kept wavering between figuring you were the lawyer or a trickster that wanted me dead.

 

[crimson5pheonix]

(fired both @CaramelFrappe and @altnameJag out of the sub like a missile)

Good work comrades! we saved Russia

 

[crimson5pheonix]

snip

Me Dema and Hippo shared right at the end. But you tried to tell me and Dema to kill kingofkumquats when he was already dead I believe.

Tbh I didn't trust you and was waiting to see if the killer stabbed you which is what I would assume he'd do if you didn't join him and we didn't look like we were going to kill you. If you lived I was gonna take the PM public.

That would have been okay. Then I'd just have pointed out who I didn't tell you to kill. Unfortunately, it would only have bought us the lawyer.

I'd have used it as more ammo in my (correct) theory that the first round the killer and lawyer voted together and altname admitted to trying to kill DCJF.

Altname probably wasn't going to live much longer.

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

See, I was under the impression that lawyer powers only told you IF someone had a role, not what role they had. Your PM threw me off, so I started acting more directly than I normally do.

@NewGM: I'm down to clown.

I thought the same.

And I'm also up for another game. I think this round went a bit mad but was fun.

Heh, sorry for saving Roy >.>

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

To be fair, I had been voting on you since round one. I figured you were the killer before the game started. I was CLOSE, but not quite right.

I kept wavering between figuring you were the lawyer or a trickster that wanted me dead.

You were wrong, you weren't even in my top 5.

 

[TheMysteriousGX]

I'm guessing it was unexpected for you guys that it would suddenly appear? It caught me off guard and I figured it probably caught the evil team off guard. Because otherwise you can always split your vote a bit. And if the doppelganger is going to be immediately aware I think something to split the evil side vote a bit isn't too bad.

Yeah, that was a bit sudden. You make a good point though. A three vote bloc right off the bat's a decent advantage.

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

@Baby-Oil Fappe: Ghosts be OP, yo.


@Secondhand Revenant: You did good, comrade. If only our other comrades were as competent as you. *Glares at the people who did not vote for Roy*

The hard part was there wasn't much discussion to convince people and disuade them of other votes.

Though I'm not sure my performance was good for me if I get picked to be killer. That may get people to expect me to always be this loud and if I'm killer and can't that may be a problem...

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

snip

Me Dema and Hippo shared right at the end. But you tried to tell me and Dema to kill kingofkumquats when he was already dead I believe.

Tbh I didn't trust you and was waiting to see if the killer stabbed you which is what I would assume he'd do if you didn't join him and we didn't look like we were going to kill you. If you lived I was gonna take the PM public.

That would have been okay. Then I'd just have pointed out who I didn't tell you to kill. Unfortunately, it would only have bought us the lawyer.

I'd have used it as more ammo in my (correct) theory that the first round the killer and lawyer voted together and altname admitted to trying to kill DCJF.

Altname probably wasn't going to live much longer.

Roy had a terrifying 4 or 5 vote bloc though. At the very least Dema joined him and it sounds like there may have been another.

If it's Hippo I'm gonna crucify myself for not seeing that Dema AND you dragged me into a group to pump me for info and kill me...

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

See, I was under the impression that lawyer powers only told you IF someone had a role, not what role they had. Your PM threw me off, so I started acting more directly than I normally do.

@NewGM: I'm down to clown.

I thought the same.

And I'm also up for another game. I think this round went a bit mad but was fun.

Heh, sorry for saving Roy >.>

It worked out in the end. Jux died for your sins is all. *sniffle*

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

To be fair, I had been voting on you since round one. I figured you were the killer before the game started. I was CLOSE, but not quite right.

I kept wavering between figuring you were the lawyer or a trickster that wanted me dead.

You were wrong, you weren't even in my top 5.

Well damn. That PM got me too suspicious. And the votes against me that last round too.

 

[crimson5pheonix]

snip

Me Dema and Hippo shared right at the end. But you tried to tell me and Dema to kill kingofkumquats when he was already dead I believe.

Tbh I didn't trust you and was waiting to see if the killer stabbed you which is what I would assume he'd do if you didn't join him and we didn't look like we were going to kill you. If you lived I was gonna take the PM public.

That would have been okay. Then I'd just have pointed out who I didn't tell you to kill. Unfortunately, it would only have bought us the lawyer.

I'd have used it as more ammo in my (correct) theory that the first round the killer and lawyer voted together and altname admitted to trying to kill DCJF.

Altname probably wasn't going to live much longer.

Roy had a terrifying 4 or 5 vote bloc though. At the very least Dema joined him and it sounds like there may have been another.

If it's Hippo I'm gonna crucify myself for not seeing that Dema AND you dragged me into a group to pump me for info and kill me...

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

See, I was under the impression that lawyer powers only told you IF someone had a role, not what role they had. Your PM threw me off, so I started acting more directly than I normally do.

@NewGM: I'm down to clown.

I thought the same.

And I'm also up for another game. I think this round went a bit mad but was fun.

Heh, sorry for saving Roy >.>

It worked out in the end. Jux died for your sins is all. *sniffle*

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

To be fair, I had been voting on you since round one. I figured you were the killer before the game started. I was CLOSE, but not quite right.

I kept wavering between figuring you were the lawyer or a trickster that wanted me dead.

You were wrong, you weren't even in my top 5.

Well damn. That PM got me too suspicious. And the votes against me that last round too.

The hint should have probably been that I sent PM's to several people. At least I didn't PM the killer or the lawyer. Though I did tell frappe to vote for roy >.>

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

@Baby-Oil Fappe: Ghosts be OP, yo.


@Secondhand Revenant: You did good, comrade. If only our other comrades were as competent as you. *Glares at the people who did not vote for Roy*

The hard part was there wasn't much discussion to convince people and disuade them of other votes.

Though I'm not sure my performance was good for me if I get picked to be killer. That may get people to expect me to always be this loud and if I'm killer and can't that may be a problem...

In past rounds, we used to PM each in a sort-of mini-alliance to unify our votes. Not sure why we stopped doing that.

The key to being a good killer is acting in character: As long as you act how you always acted, then chances of people eliminating you become a bit slimmer.

Well PMing seems a bit riskier unless you have a large enough group that's all fully informed to avoid betrayals within.

See, I tend to not play a good character for the killer I think. Yelling about Roy the whole time seems fairly suicidal if I'm wrong and if I'm the killer I'd have been bound to he wrong. I may need to temper it a bit in future rounds so that people don't expect behavior from me that's detrimental to being the killer

 

[Demagogue]

@Dying_Jester: More like someone who jumped ship just to be on the winning side- only to shoot himself in the foot.
But oh well, I am happy to gown down this American vessel and i'm taking Demagogue with me. *smirk*

You know that's the sort of response I've come to expect from you Frappe. I guess you're just a poor sport no matter side someone is on.

Someone let me know when the next round starts. Im done reading this bullshit.

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

snip

Me Dema and Hippo shared right at the end. But you tried to tell me and Dema to kill kingofkumquats when he was already dead I believe.

Tbh I didn't trust you and was waiting to see if the killer stabbed you which is what I would assume he'd do if you didn't join him and we didn't look like we were going to kill you. If you lived I was gonna take the PM public.

That would have been okay. Then I'd just have pointed out who I didn't tell you to kill. Unfortunately, it would only have bought us the lawyer.

I'd have used it as more ammo in my (correct) theory that the first round the killer and lawyer voted together and altname admitted to trying to kill DCJF.

Altname probably wasn't going to live much longer.

Roy had a terrifying 4 or 5 vote bloc though. At the very least Dema joined him and it sounds like there may have been another.

If it's Hippo I'm gonna crucify myself for not seeing that Dema AND you dragged me into a group to pump me for info and kill me...

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

See, I was under the impression that lawyer powers only told you IF someone had a role, not what role they had. Your PM threw me off, so I started acting more directly than I normally do.

@NewGM: I'm down to clown.

I thought the same.

And I'm also up for another game. I think this round went a bit mad but was fun.

Heh, sorry for saving Roy >.>

It worked out in the end. Jux died for your sins is all. *sniffle*

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

To be fair, I had been voting on you since round one. I figured you were the killer before the game started. I was CLOSE, but not quite right.

I kept wavering between figuring you were the lawyer or a trickster that wanted me dead.

You were wrong, you weren't even in my top 5.

Well damn. That PM got me too suspicious. And the votes against me that last round too.

The hint should have probably been that I sent PM's to several people. At least I didn't PM the killer or the lawyer. Though I did tell frappe to vote for roy >.>

Sending it out to multiple people just made you look *more* suspicious to me. Though less like you were after me specjfically except Hippo showed me his and you asked him to vote for me XD

 

[crimson5pheonix]

snip

Me Dema and Hippo shared right at the end. But you tried to tell me and Dema to kill kingofkumquats when he was already dead I believe.

Tbh I didn't trust you and was waiting to see if the killer stabbed you which is what I would assume he'd do if you didn't join him and we didn't look like we were going to kill you. If you lived I was gonna take the PM public.

That would have been okay. Then I'd just have pointed out who I didn't tell you to kill. Unfortunately, it would only have bought us the lawyer.

I'd have used it as more ammo in my (correct) theory that the first round the killer and lawyer voted together and altname admitted to trying to kill DCJF.

Altname probably wasn't going to live much longer.

Roy had a terrifying 4 or 5 vote bloc though. At the very least Dema joined him and it sounds like there may have been another.

If it's Hippo I'm gonna crucify myself for not seeing that Dema AND you dragged me into a group to pump me for info and kill me...

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

See, I was under the impression that lawyer powers only told you IF someone had a role, not what role they had. Your PM threw me off, so I started acting more directly than I normally do.

@NewGM: I'm down to clown.

I thought the same.

And I'm also up for another game. I think this round went a bit mad but was fun.

Heh, sorry for saving Roy >.>

It worked out in the end. Jux died for your sins is all. *sniffle*

But I do want to know, how did you know I was the trickster specifically?

Lawyer powers. We were going to wait to get you until after Head and Jux, but we didn't get that far. Speaking of:

The reason why I didn't get Lux killed earlier was because the dude PMed me super early. Getting him killed after he PMed me would of been an automatic red flag that I ratted em out... so I let him live for the time being. However, I do not know why Roy didn't have him killed sooner because Lux was the reason we lost this game.

We figured, what with Jux telling you they were the arbiter, that we'd give them a round in between to try and trow them off your scent. If we offed Jux right away, signs would point to you, and if you got executed Headsprouter's list would've actually been relevant.

It was a gamble.

That depends on if Jux told anyone else, right?

I don't think he can tell us about the PM after he died, right?

No? Huh, I might've figured that wrong then. I thought that rule only applied to post death Spy answers.

I thought it was 'No evidence'. Not sure if that would count as such or if that means no screen caps

I figure without a screencap for something it's just chatting. No reason for anyone else to believe it, although not much reason not to believe it.

That said, and I'm not only saying this because it screwed my team, but I'm not enamored with the post execution vote count. Could make the spy superfluous. I mean, a good lot of you were on Roy so hard Frappe and I were actually trying to be more suspicious, to varying degrees of success, just to split the vote. I was tanking trickster fire.

To be fair, I had been voting on you since round one. I figured you were the killer before the game started. I was CLOSE, but not quite right.

I kept wavering between figuring you were the lawyer or a trickster that wanted me dead.

You were wrong, you weren't even in my top 5.

Well damn. That PM got me too suspicious. And the votes against me that last round too.

The hint should have probably been that I sent PM's to several people. At least I didn't PM the killer or the lawyer. Though I did tell frappe to vote for roy >.>

Sending it out to multiple people just made you look *more* suspicious to me. Though less like you were after me specjfically except Hippo showed me his and you asked him to vote for me XD

Heh, woops. Well, you were one of the six people who tied that round.

 

[EvilRoy]

AND THEN I LEFT TO BUY GROCERIES AND TWO SOLID PAGES OF POSTS SHOWED UP.

I'll read stuff in a bit after I've eaten...

The major immediate moral is that I'm not too busy to start once we have enough peoples, so we will do so when that happens.

Uhh, I'll read suggestions about the doppleganger, a couple of which I noticed were made but I haven't actually read yet. I seem to remember Dema was going to suggest an explody person as well, which I guess should be thrown about in the group and discussed by people there. I'll note stuff in the group in a bit.

HUNGRY NOW. MUST FEEED.

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

Well PMing seems a bit riskier unless you have a large enough group that's all fully informed to avoid betrayals within.

See, I tend to not play a good character for the killer I think. Yelling about Roy the whole time seems fairly suicidal if I'm wrong and if I'm the killer I'd have been bound to he wrong. I may need to temper it a bit in future rounds so that people don't expect behavior from me that's detrimental to being the killer

Oh, don't you worry. The voting groups in the past were quite large. Quite large, indeed. The only time it became an issue is when.... well, guess whom I am going to name drop. Come on, guess.

Sounds reasonable, but keen players tend to notice shifts behaviour. So don't temper it down toooooo much or else there's a risk that people might notice.

5 seems like the minimum now, so at least 2 aren't on the evil team. 8 would be best for punishing betrayals should the evils be on there

Nah see I mean temper it down while I'm innocent to create a more reasonable expectation for when I'm killer.

 

[Secondhand Revenant]

AND THEN I LEFT TO BUY GROCERIES AND TWO SOLID PAGES OF POSTS SHOWED UP.

I'll read stuff in a bit after I've eaten...

The major immediate moral is that I'm not too busy to start once we have enough peoples, so we will do so when that happens.

Uhh, I'll read suggestions about the doppleganger, a couple of which I noticed were made but I haven't actually read yet. I seem to remember Dema was going to suggest an explody person as well, which I guess should be thrown about in the group and discussed by people there. I'll note stuff in the group in a bit.

HUNGRY NOW. MUST FEEED.

Hooray!

Eat and don't explode.