True, although most of the people on the internet had the same reaction as you on that video.BRex21 said:It is an issue because the difference in most of these studies amounts to a 40-60 split, while it was being used to justify men having virtually no access to shelters and the legal discrimination in the United States Violence Against Women Act which changed the definitions of domestic abuse from something between intimate partners to something that a man does to a woman.oppp7 said:So women abuse more but it's more severe when women get abused? Not really sure if that helps your argument that much but ok.BRex21 said:Okay from a previous post on domestic violence:oppp7 said:Sources? (I used Wikipedia)
http://www.patientedu.org/aspx/HealthELibrary/HealthETopic.aspx?cid=M0907d
and here is a press release with pie charts
http://pn.psychiatryonline.org/content/42/15/31.2.full
Here is a list of a few hundred studies breaking down the numbers, you can look up individual ones if you like, but the researchers broke it down and said that almost all studies showed women were at least as aggressive if not more so.
http://www.csulb.edu/~mfiebert/assault.htm
and here is a different study finding women more often the aggressors
http://ajph.aphapublications.org/cgi/reprint/97/5/941
If you're still not convinced i suggest you read some of Erin Pizzey's work, a woman who founded some of the first women's shelters and who found that many of the women there were just as violent as the men they left. She was kicked out of her feminist organizations and subjected to death threats for saying this.
Yet rulings like this: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:_FyA4HAXVGIJ:www.law.berkeley.edu/files/BlumhorstAmicusBrief.doc+nomas+files+amicus+brief+blumhorst&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us
pop up all over the states and the western world stating that since violence against men is a non issue womens shelters don't need to follow the law and admit men all the while ignoring that they aren't willing to spend any additional money for new shelter based on budget shortfalls.
I grabbed this link from one of my other forums, it contains the clip from the talk where they say an abused man deserved to have his penis cut off for trying to leave his wife. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wP4VeMJp9pE&feature=player_embedded
Here is a case file where a boy was, by the legal definition, raped http://www.lawlink.com/research/caselevel3/74059 naturally he is the only one who will face the possibility of jail time. I have more cases I can grab if you like.
Good job on the sources though (not sarcasm).
People are out there working very hard to illegitimize violence that happens to men while demonizing anyone who so much as hits back. We create this narrative and decide that the real world needs to fit this narrative and scream bloody murder when it doesn't. We see the battered woman and assume that the man is evil while we see a battered man and we assume he is cheating and shout "you go girl" to his abuser.
Lets take this for example, its a little off topic, but recent:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TpL9jJkROps
Notice how the cashier "violently attacked two unruly customers" of course they hold off on the fact that one woman jumped over the counter to assault him while the other tried to rob the till. This isn't attacking, this is hitting back. I understand the idea that he went overboard, but his life could very well have been at risk because of this, one of the girls could have had a knife or a weapon and it was a split second decision fuelled by adrenaline, that happened to get a little out of hand. Can you imagine if those women were men? we would be cheering for this, the criminals would have gotten what they deserve? if the cashier were a woman we would laugh even harder. Please notice that the women got charged with misdemeanours while the man got charged with a felony. Because self defence gone too far is worse than out and out assault and battery. This is nothing, there is serious talk about eliminating womens prisons in Britain, no matter what a woman does, she would not be able to go to jail.