Should The Simpsons be Cancelled?

Recommended Videos

Toasted Nuts

New member
Feb 17, 2010
124
0
0
People who see this thread will have 1 of 3 reactions:

1. No its the best show ever and shouldnt be cancelled!!

2. Yes its run its course and isn't good anymore

3. I really dont care i stopped watching like 10 years ago.

Im sure most people will have reaction number 3, as a lot of people stopped watching the show years ago and perhaps catch the occassional episode on TV but dont watch it Religiously, and as such dont care 1 way or the other if its cancelled.

But as someone who has pretty much seen every single episode, (thats not to say im an obsessed fan who knows everything about the show or collects anything) i feel that the show has finally slumped to such a low quality that i cant see how it can pull in high enough ratings to be kept on.

While watching the current season number 21, i dont think there has been a single episode i really enjoyed, i generally sit through an episode for the sake of it now, i find myself not really laughing and not particualarly enjoying the storyline either.

When the Simpsons first started it drew in so many viewers and became what it is today because of its high quality, for the first 9 seasons it was brilliant and then after season 9 there was a more noticable change in the dynamic of the episode style which has of course been discussed before this. The dynamic changing to a more whacky "just make Homer do some funny crap" style which though not like the first 9 seasons, watched now is still very funny.

The last 2 season however 20 and 21, seem to have drifted away from this style as well, Homer is very much not at the forfront as much as he was during seasons 10-19, He's still there... but not in the way we had became accustomed and the show suffers from it in my opinion, to such a point that im not really sure what kind of style there going for.

Producers have been asked how they have kept the show going for so long, one of them saying "Lower your quality standards. Once you've done that you can go on forever." Which to be honest... doesnt really work. If they theoretically set their standards at 100% for the first couple of seasons and then by season 4 lower it to 95% or 90% of the original quality by season 21 by continually "lowering" their standards they will end up producing something that is about 40%, 35% the quality of the original couple of seasons, most people wont enjoy something thats so much worse than the original quality they were used too.

The simpsons however is so powerful in terms of brand and importance to fox that you know i probably dont see it getting cancelled anytime soon. But with the decline in viewer numbers im sure it may have more chance of getting cancelled. I Live in the UK so looking at viewer numbers, i can see that an episode of this current season only drew in 5.11 million viewers "episode - Million Dollar Maybe", now im not sure what other shows are like in the US with this time slot in terms of viewers but i assume this isnt great.

The quality of the episodes are at such a low point now that i think its probably run its course, but im sure many will disagree/not care.

Cheers for reading.
 

Ironic Pirate

New member
May 21, 2009
5,544
0
0
I think it's okay, better than American Idol, certainly. Also, for the future, you can add polls to your threads. Poll threads generally get more responses, because people like the little colors next to the name, I think.

Cheers, and don't go in the basement. It's where we keep the... never mind.
 

Quiet Stranger

New member
Feb 4, 2006
4,409
0
0
people are going to ***** and complain that the last "good" season was 10 and I'm here to say "lawl, haha noobs" seriously though ALL Simpsons is good
 

SomeBritishDude

New member
Nov 1, 2007
5,081
0
0
It still has it's moments. But yeah Golden age of the Simpsons ended a long, long time ago.

I wouldn't be especially sad if the Simpsons came to an end. I suppose there would be this whole "the end of an era" feeling to it but since I haven't even watched a quarter of the episodes I'm quite happy with repeats.

Julianking93 said:
Wrong, I have the 4th option of "I never liked it to begin with"
...I'm assuming your some sort of invertebrate, possibly a jelly fish or tape worm correct? I know of very few life forms that didn't enjoy the Simpsons at one point.
 

HyenaThePirate

New member
Jan 8, 2009
1,412
0
0
The question isn't SHOULD it be cancelled.. it is "Why HASN'T this been cancelled yet?!"

I mean.. has anyone really watched it since like season 4??
I don't know a single person who watches the simpsons, not a coworker, not a fellow student, not people in line at the DMV..

The Simpsons has been on life support for what feels like the majority of my life time.
I think at this point the only episode I will ever tune in for is the FINAL one.
 

effilctar

New member
Jul 24, 2009
1,495
0
0
*Sigh* Just because you think a show has gotten stale does not mean that everyone thinks it has gotten stale. watching the Simpsons every day at 5:30PM on the BBC was part of my childhood. There are children these days who have a Simpson's routine, and due to the older episodes not being up to the visual standards of modern shows, and for the sake of entertaining old fans, new episodes must be made.

Some of the greatest jokes were from the older episodes, though I must say that some of the minor characters have gotten far more hilarious recently, especially Ralph and Milhouse. Though I do hate Lisa. When you're trying to relax and just lose yourself for 30 minutes, she's the voice nagging about real life problems and GOD I want to punch her.
 

Toasted Nuts

New member
Feb 17, 2010
124
0
0
Hmm yer i probably should have put it as a poll, but hey its my first thread so live and learn i suppose. We get American Idol over here on one of the channels, it is pretty bad, just like our version The X Factor another Simon Cowell creation...

hmm... your right Julianking93 i probably should have put that as an option, naive of me to think no one didnt like the simpsons :(
 

Kuchinawa212

New member
Apr 23, 2009
5,408
0
0
I never really watched it, but yeah it go for all I care. See how whiny people get over a cartoon XD
 

BlumiereBleck

New member
Dec 11, 2008
5,402
0
0
no. a big fat long noooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
 

Davrel

New member
Jan 31, 2010
504
0
0
I take option 3 - I watch it if I happen to be watching TV (which is rare in itself) and it comes on (which is even rarer considering I only get British terrestrial TV.)
 

GodKlown

New member
Dec 16, 2009
514
0
0
At this point in The Simpsons timeline, I can't imagine there are a lot of new plot ideas left that would really make any sense. The first nine years didn't feature the dual-plot ideas that seemed the staple of the years after, having to circle around two separate instances in the story just to move it along for the 19 or 20 minutes of the length of the episode.
I've watched the show since the start on Tracy Ulman. It took them nineteen years before a movie deal, and I think that should have been the finale of the whole series. But apparently enough people tune in each week, and although Fox has tried, they can't seem to develop a new show strong enough to take over that spot in the schedule. For me, I'd be glad to see it finally retire instead of pulling itself along as it is.
 

Rednog

New member
Nov 3, 2008
3,567
0
0
I'm curious as how its still on the air, I remember hearing that it was going to be the last season for several years a while back and somehow it keeps going. I'll watch it occasionally but I really don't care for it, there are much better shows out there that monopolize my time.
 

Toasted Nuts

New member
Feb 17, 2010
124
0
0
effilctar said:
*Sigh* Just because you think a show has gotten stale does not mean that everyone thinks it has gotten stale. watching the Simpsons every day at 5:30PM on the BBC was part of my childhood.
I know i dont think everyone thinks its gone stale, hence the question should it be cancelled? where people who dont think it has will say its fine. And yer that was also my childhood watching the simpsons on the BBC. But the new episodes just arent great, no hilarious moments, and no great quotable moments.

And yer Lisa is anouying probably why i didnt like the latest episode as she was the focal point :|
 

SomeBritishDude

New member
Nov 1, 2007
5,081
0
0
I suppose one of the main problems with the Simpsons is so many cartoons of that style have grown and evolved from it that it just doesn't have that originality anymore.

South Park has shock value, Family Guy has randomness down, Futurama is clever comedy. What does the Simpsons have that really sets it appart anymore?

That and they just seem to have run out of decent ideas. I've seen many new episodes which just seem to be rehashes of old ones.
 

Dahni

Lemon Meringue Tie
Aug 18, 2009
922
0
0
i lost interest in it yeeeears ago.
i only watch it if its the only half decent thing on the tv at that particular moment in time.
they'd be better off just doing re-runs of the best episodes.
 

GameOverGoblin

New member
Feb 3, 2010
212
0
0
I choose option #2... sort of.

I do think it should end, but I still think its good. I just think that it should end now instead of ending really badly.