Evil Top Hat said:
The UI isn't really that great, it's just not as bad as people say it is. Sure, sometimes the mouse cursor will stop working properly, menus will deselect for no reason and it takes a bit longer to access all the information you need, but these problems aren't so bad that they're gamebreaking, just minor annoyances. I even actually like the map system and skill tree menus.
What's more, I have only had a few crashes in about 21 hours of game time, and only 1 of them was a hard crash. It's a bit pathetic that bethesda are so bad at this that having only had a few crashes in less than a days play time could ever be a good thing, but it's an improvement at least. Certainly better than what I had to go through with Fallout 3...
I played every single TES game and really Skyrim so far manages to be more annoying than enjoyable, because every time i get into playing it all those little things start to pile up one after another.
It is that bad. Why?
First: No proper way to compare items.
Second: No proper sorting function.
Third: List is bad for PC. Grid is the way to go.
Fourth: Lack of information about items. (which weapon is 1 and which 2 handed, which armour is considered light and which heavy, etc. Some are obvious, but information never hurts, especially in a game that's considered a prime example of RPG)
Fifth: Painful to see what You actually have equipped.
Sixth: Perks UI is just one big mess to navigate. You pressed A/D one time too much? Welcome to completely random place in different perk tree.
Seventh: Map doesn't let me fully zoom out, the "fog" effect is pointless and only obscures vision.. It's a map. I haven't seen a map in my life that would cover itself with fog!
Eighth: No way to bind weapon sets for dual wielding. Try this Yourself. Equip a sword in 1 hand, axe in second hand, switch to spell, try to re-equip offhand weapon. Impossible without going to the Favourites menu and assigning hands manually. Now do this several times during combat. Not fun.
Ninth: Crafting. Oh crafting. Why no bulk crafting? Why suddenly the po up in crafting to confirm the craft requires mouse, while everything else can be done with keyboard?
Tenth: Why Journal is in Escape menu rather than in Tab menu ? Why suddenly put it along with game options? What's intuitive about that part? Oh right. Because console UIs are limited to 4 directions...
Eleventh: Esc doesn't close the Tab menu... Really. Esc is the default "close this crap" button everyone uses, everyone likes and no one ever complained about. Why change it?
As for crashes... I'm not even going to bother. If not memory leaks than random crash to desktop without any error or freezing on loading screens. And my PC is way above the specs this game is even able to utilize.
Don't get me wrong. i enjoy the gameplay itself, or rather would enjoy it, if i wouldn't have to constantly battle with the UI. Can't wait for Creation Kit so most of those things can be fixed right away and i can actually play through the game. Till then it will wait untouched.
EDIT: Because picture says thousand words [http://img3.imageshack.us/img3/5679/skyriminterface.jpg]