Some Fallout Enclave/Alien Musings (not NV related)

Recommended Videos

Video Gone

New member
Feb 7, 2009
563
0
0
The Catalyst said:
NO NO NO!!! I don't care if you're 100% right!! I don't want this to be the truth... ...try to understand... ...I'm a Metal Gear fan, and when Guns of the Patriots came out... ...(shudder)... ...we don't need a complex plot. FUCK!!!
A Metal Gear fan who doesn't want a complex plot?
SONS OF LIBERTY.
That is all. (I'm a Metal Gear fan too, so don't blast me for "Not getting it" or any of that. Who the hell is "we", anyway?)
OT: I really like that theory... ...I would quite like this to be true... ...I'm making fun of The Catalyst's post with this spacing...
Anyway, are you serious? The Enclave didn't organise this all by themselves! There's something more. What about the la li lu la le?
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
maybe because the US was winning?
Except, of course, that it wasn't. Just as the US finally got the upper hand in China, things began breaking down at home and many units (including power armor) were relocated to keep riots in check. The Chinese were similarly falling apart at home, but mainly in terms of keeping control of nations they'd annexed. This means we weren't just fighting in China and Alaska, and we have no idea just how many nations were annexed.

take a look at the t-51b and combat armor MK II (not the shitty one from fallout 3). those armors put the chinese armors to shame to the point practically every battle resulted in chinese loss.
Actually, there's no such claim. According to the same timeline you referred me to at the bottom of this article, power armor was first introduced to try pushing the Chinese out of Alaska in 3067 --- the year after China invaded. Despite being "incredibly effective against Chinese infantry", it was not until a decade later that Anchorage was retaken. While the T-51b finally tipped the scales, that's all it did.

Power armor wasn't, by itself, a war-winner, despite the fact that China never came close to developing similar weapons. Instead:

"2074: Contrary to their claims of seeking only to retake Alaska from the Reds, American Power Armor units, infantry, and mechanized divisions are deployed to China, but they become bogged down on the mainland, putting a further drain on American resources and supply lines."

The reality is that the US faced the same problem the Japanese did during WWII: a technologically-superior yet numerically-inferior force, spread thinly over a vast area, and therefore unable to control more than various pockets of it at any given time. This was also the US experience in Vietnam, and the German WWII experience in Russia. Hence the US military's decision to go ahead with the FEV project to try and create super-soldiers. They also genetically engineered animals to unleash upon the Chinese, such as with "Codename Cloacina" (i.e., Mole Rats), and of course Deathclaws.

The existing troop levels, even with power armor, were clearly not believed to be sufficient to win the war.

the enclave only numbered in the thousands, and most of them died at the oil rig. the only enclave bases that -this- particular branch of enclave have is nevarro, and that only had a 30 person garrison at most.
Except, of course, that you cannot fit thousands of people on an oil rig. Not even if you packed them in phone booths. This was a converted drilling platform, not a city on stilts.

Nor was Navarro even an Enclave base until around 2242...the bombs having dropped in 2077. It was still being converted when the Vault Dweller hit it. So no, it was never one of "the" major Enclave bases.

The actual canon on the Enclave (from the Fallout 3 GOTY Guide) is they relocated to Raven Rock after the Rig's destruction not because it was the only remaining base left, but because it was the only remaining Enclave base with a functioning ZAX supercomputer. Adams Air Force Base was taken over after the Enclave went to Raven Rock.

Sorry, but unless you're going to insist that the entire Enclave stayed on the Oil Rig for about 150 years, they've got bases and have been doing things somewhere else. I seriously doubt they were bunking in stacks forty high.

this idea that they have a whole world under stasis is nothing but fiction.
In case you hadn't noticed, the whole game is fiction. -:)

The fact is, all 122 Vaults were built with Enclave involvement. They had the "go codes", and oversaw the continuance of the Vault experiments after the bombs dropped. They've been around for two hundred years, and you insist that they never did anything more than overstuff an oil rig until it blew up under them?

the truth is the thousands that the enclave once had, that was their way of repopulating the world.
That wouldn't begin to cut it for a variety of reasons: one, a gene pool of mere "thousands" wouldn't be large enough to avoid stagnation. At a minimum, these few would have to be augmented with gene banks. Two, if those gene banks were on the Oil Rig, then when it went boom that killed any chance of repopulation right there. Why would the Enclave keep on trying to implement a program it had no chance of succeeding with?

Three, if these people ARE supposed to be the repopulation stock, they'd be impossible to risk in any sort of battle line for exactly the reason that if they die, so does "pure humanity". Given that the Enclave certainly had the technology to build robots to do their dirty work (not to mention Deathclaws), they'd've had precious little reason to put the seeds of the next generations into the fire.

here, have the timeline of the resource wars if you dont believe me:
http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/Resource_Wars
Read it (not that I haven't in years past), and it just doesn't back you up. Sorry.

PS: the vaults were supposed to serve as test moon bases.
Nope. This has recently been discussed on the Fallout Wiki, and it has been acknowledged that the entire "Vaults as space colonization projects" idea was something that never made it into the games or the actual canon.

Instead, it was cut material --- in the same way that "The Burrows" were cut material. There are no anthropomorphic raccoon tribes running around the Fallout universe, and the Vaults were not meant to test anyone for anything relating to space at all.

To the contrary, the Fallout Wiki makes clear that exactly TWO rockets were ever built capable of getting beyond lunar orbit. Both were built to be the first manned missions to Mars. Neither were ever completed for that function. Exactly one of these --- NOT built to take more than a handful of astronauts to Mars, to start with --- was partially retrofitted as an escape vehicle by the Enclave and then abandoned.

Meanwhile, it's expressly stated that ALL of America's space resources were committed to prepping orbital weapons platforms and converting all available moon-rockets to ICBMs.

And even that much comes from "Van Buren", which isn't even solid canon in itself. At the most liberal possible level of interpretation, there could never have been any serious program aimed at colonizing another planet.
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
The Warden said:
Before I found out about the aliens, I always thought the people behind the Vaults were stupid or incredibly twisted.
Pretty sure those are still entirely applicable descriptions. -:D
 

Not G. Ivingname

New member
Nov 18, 2009
6,368
0
0
Calbeck said:
It all sounds plausable (or as reasonable as anything in the 50's future apoclitic world can be any ways). You seam to be forgetting that the Brother Hood of Steel also has found alien artifacts as well (why you can find the alien Power cells in the Brotherhood break off's base in Fallout 3). If the Brotherhood knows about the aliens, who knows what the secret goverment of the world knows or has done?
 

Not G. Ivingname

New member
Nov 18, 2009
6,368
0
0
Calbeck said:
Also, look at Audio Log 17 from Zeta:

(Alien Babble)
Our defenses consist of 3 battalions of light infantry, 34
pieces of field artillery, 108 armored vehicles and 42
aerial vehicles.
(Alien Babble)
We have 38 ICBM's always on alert and ready to fire when
the word is passed down from the White House.
(Alien Babble)
The codes to activate the launch sequences are...are...
uhhngh...no...I can't let you...uggh...get out of my mind!
(Alien Babble)
Agggh! The c-codes...are...ugh....no...I can't betray...AGH!
My head! I can't...won't...AGGGGH! agggh...
(Taken from Fallout wiki)

Maybe they didn't need to mother ships cannons after all?
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
you seem to forget that this branch of the enclave wanted to use FEV to purge the area, and then they move in.
Well except for the kind of obvious fact that Vault 87 was all about using FEV on the Vault Dwellers there to continue mutation studies. And the Vault experiments were set up and monitored by the Enclave.

they never really go onto the mainland and put themselves under the line up fire.
Except when they do so throughout Fallout 2 and 3. Horrigan, Navarro, the Vault 13 raid, the crashed Vertibird, etc etc etc...

the ONLY reason the enclave are in fallout 3
Sorry, can't argue against the game's content and still stay in canon. At that point, you're further off the rails than I am. -:)

you also forget that there IS another enclave but they are not associated with the east coast remnants nor do they follow their commands.
If "Van Buren" had ever been published, there would be. "Van Buren" content remains in the same boat as all the rest of the non-published stuff. You want Midwest Enclave? Fine, I get Raccoon Furries. Let's see who cracks first. -:D

you seem hell bent on this theory that will never work.
Well, if you could actually show how it wouldn't work, that would be one thing.

the salt caves containing a world population? the only "stasis" pods i know of was at the EPA on the west coast, and even then the EPA was cut due to time constraints.
Yep, and cut material isn't canon. But then again, I've been arguing for alien/human cooperation of at least some limited sort, and the entire Enclave plan was rigged for observing centuries-long experiments. Stasis pods'd make that a much more viable plan. Plus you just got done saying a world could be repopulated with just a few thousand people.

Frankly, it could ALSO be done with just a set of cloning vats and a sufficiently wide sampling of DNA, which I also punted out there as a possibility. That much, we know humanity could do on its own circa 2077 anyways.
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
Not G. Ivingname said:
Also, look at Audio Log 17 from Zeta:
Maybe they didn't need to mother ships cannons after all?
True, but in FO2 President Richardson insists that the Chinese fired first, with everything they had, and that the US barely got their birds off the ground in time to retaliate. There wasn't any particular reason for him to have been lying about that, either...
 

Not G. Ivingname

New member
Nov 18, 2009
6,368
0
0
Calbeck said:
Not G. Ivingname said:
Also, look at Audio Log 17 from Zeta:
Maybe they didn't need to mother ships cannons after all?
True, but in FO2 President Richardson insists that the Chinese fired first, with everything they had, and that the US barely got their birds off the ground in time to retaliate. There wasn't any particular reason for him to have been lying about that, either...
Good point... but why would the aliens need the codes otherwise? Maybe the president was lied to or is lieing just to cover up any kind of guilt for the war or hide alien connections? Maybe the aliens secretly launched one at China and they retaliated? Who knows. I was not trying to derail your theory, just trying to support it even if it changes one minor part of the entire arguement.
 

Bluesclues

New member
Dec 18, 2009
300
0
0
The Catalyst said:
NO NO NO!!! I don't care if you're 100% right!! I don't want this to be the truth... ...try to understand... ...I'm a Metal Gear fan, and when Guns of the Patriots came out... ...(shudder)... ...we don't need a complex plot. FUCK!!!

Sorry to disappoint you, but Fallout already has a complex plot.

OT: interesting theory, would be even more interesting to see if any of it could be true o:
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
Not G. Ivingname said:
Good point... but why would the aliens need the codes otherwise? Maybe the president was lied to or is lieing just to cover up any kind of guilt for the war or hide alien connections? Maybe the aliens secretly launched one at China and they retaliated? Who knows. I was not trying to derail your theory, just trying to support it even if it changes one minor part of the entire arguement.
No no, I get it, and thanks, I'm just looking at how it would fit in overall. And actually I was thinking about the idea that Richardson had been the victim of pro-US propaganda himself (he was actually the descendant of the wartime President, so he wasn't personally there). I think the idea of the aliens using codes to do their own one-shot (or limited strike) might make sense too.
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
van buren is still canon as it was incorporated into fallout 3 and new vegas itself.
*sigh*

Elements of "Van Buren" were incorporated. Those specific elements are now canon. No one ever said "oh yeah, the whole thing is canon now". I have no idea where you got the notion it was otherwise...certainly not from the Fallout Wiki, which goes to pains pointing how just how much of "Van Buren" is NOT canon.

the enclave's entire attitude is to make the important people survive.
And the important people won't survive without sufficient breeding stock. They die, their children die, and that's it, otherwise. So no, they're not idiots.

nor would they get DNA of non-executives
Except that they have, in many past experiments.

stasis tubes are also not possible
Except that stasis tubes are canon...

as they planned to view the vaults over generations on the oil rig.
Before you go any further with this insistence that the Oil Rig was the only significant Enclave base before it blew up: http://fallout.wikia.com/wiki/PoseidoNet

The bases listed on PoseidoNet in Fallout 2 were "Control Station Enclave" (probably the Oil Rig), "ENCLAVE Vault-Research Control", "Navarro Refinery", "Iron Mountain", "NORAD", "SAC", "Cheyenne Mountain" and "Poseidon Atomic Powerplant #5".

All of these were different sites. Ergo, "Enclave Vault-Research Control" was not on the Rig.

fun fact: stasis tubes were in fallout 2 but guess what? its CUT CONTENT
And also Fallout 3, as alien tech. Which is what I've been talking about. No, it's not "cut content" anymore.

bethesda never stated what is canon and what is not.
Except of course by publishing Fallout 3. Publication, sorry to say, is the definition of what's canon, unless explicitly stated otherwise by the copyright owner. That's the universal standard regardless of whether it's Fallout, Star Trek, or George Lucas saying Han shot first (which is why I hate George Lucas, but it's still HIS sandbox).

fallout 3 IS canon but they never said anything about the DLC
The DLC is part of the published game, kiddo. Sorry. Deal with it.

EDIT: NV is canon, and is said to have included the van buren lore
Some canon lore. Reality is, we know nothing about it except what's been leaked or trailered or screenshot. And all of that is actually subject to change right up until the point of publication. There has not, however, been a single statement or suggestion that ALL of "Van Buren" is canon, no matter how much you'd like it to be so.

You'll have to wait to find out, just like the rest of us, and in the meantime, you don't get to demand that it invalidates someone else's speculations.

such as a very faint enclave presence in the midwest.
Actually, it's been specifically stated that the Enclave Eyebot from the trailer is from the D.C. Wasteland. Also made clear in the trailer by the "Roosevelt Academy" sticker. And the developers have openly stated that yes, it will be in the game.

Unless you have another source to point to for a "Midwest Enclave" appearance, there's been no confirmation or suggestion they will appear in New Vegas at all.
 

The Catalyst

New member
Feb 14, 2010
91
0
0
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
NO NO NO!!! I don't care if you're 100% right!! I don't want this to be the truth... ...try to understand... ...I'm a Metal Gear fan, and when Guns of the Patriots came out... ...(shudder)... ...we don't need a complex plot. FUCK!!!

Sorry to disappoint you, but Fallout already has a complex plot.
It does? I've played all three of the buggers and there hasn't been anything too complex.
 

Bluesclues

New member
Dec 18, 2009
300
0
0
The Catalyst said:
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
NO NO NO!!! I don't care if you're 100% right!! I don't want this to be the truth... ...try to understand... ...I'm a Metal Gear fan, and when Guns of the Patriots came out... ...(shudder)... ...we don't need a complex plot. FUCK!!!

Sorry to disappoint you, but Fallout already has a complex plot.
It does? I've played all three of the buggers and there hasn't been anything too complex.

Actually complex is probably not the right word to use...more like convoluted :p
 

The Catalyst

New member
Feb 14, 2010
91
0
0
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
NO NO NO!!! I don't care if you're 100% right!! I don't want this to be the truth... ...try to understand... ...I'm a Metal Gear fan, and when Guns of the Patriots came out... ...(shudder)... ...we don't need a complex plot. FUCK!!!

Sorry to disappoint you, but Fallout already has a complex plot.
It does? I've played all three of the buggers and there hasn't been anything too complex.

Actually complex is probably not the right word to use...more like convoluted :p
Ah. Well, it is better than MGS4, you can't go twelve feet without tripping over a "retcon".
 

Bluesclues

New member
Dec 18, 2009
300
0
0
The Catalyst said:
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
NO NO NO!!! I don't care if you're 100% right!! I don't want this to be the truth... ...try to understand... ...I'm a Metal Gear fan, and when Guns of the Patriots came out... ...(shudder)... ...we don't need a complex plot. FUCK!!!

Sorry to disappoint you, but Fallout already has a complex plot.
It does? I've played all three of the buggers and there hasn't been anything too complex.

Actually complex is probably not the right word to use...more like convoluted :p
Ah. Well, it is better than MGS4, you can't go twelve feet without tripping over a "retcon".

Lol so I've heard. I've never picked the game up but all I hear is talk about how long the plot is xD
 

Calbeck

Bearer of Pointed Commentary
Jul 13, 2008
758
0
0
Ultratwinkie said:
1. the enclave anticipated that by having enough people stored away in enclave vaults.
Which vaults would these be, given that you've been arguing from the get-go that the ONLY Enclave bases were at the Oil Rig and Navarro...the latter of which was an incomplete Vertibird refueling base, and never built to house large numbers of anybody?

they dont care for the common man, any idea that they would for -their- survival is just retarded.
The common man does the common work. Unless you want to argue that the Enclave muckity-mucks were planning on herding their own brahmin?

they never mention a "Dna computer" like that is even possible.
Nor did anyone suggest we were talking about a "DNA computer". I have no idea where you got that. What I said was that they would/could store DNA to clone people with...meaning medical samples. Much more portable and storable than a few hundred thousand actual folks.

since when do humans, with their society destroyed, have all the tech the aliens do?
Given that the whole point of the thread was based on the idea of humans and aliens sharing tech and resources via the Enclave during the pre-War period...did you miss that part?

human stasis is flawed on long term levels.
Except of course that, per Mothership Zeta, it isn't.

4. poseidonet? sure it lists all these locations but how many are STAFFED? sure it says operational yet it doesn't say if they are staffed
Using meta-canon to try and disprove meta-canon is pretty obviously pointless. If they're "operational", and that's all the info there is, then they're operational. Which implies being staffed. If you want to disprove that, you're going to need something with a little solidity to it.

as far as the enclave say their bases go its the oil rig and nevarro at the point of fallout 2.
Except of course for the entries in FO2 which say they have other bases. Look, if you're going to just ignore the bits of canon you don't like, fine. Not much basis to continue trying to have a discussion though.

Have a good one.
 

The Catalyst

New member
Feb 14, 2010
91
0
0
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
Bluesclues said:
The Catalyst said:
NO NO NO!!! I don't care if you're 100% right!! I don't want this to be the truth... ...try to understand... ...I'm a Metal Gear fan, and when Guns of the Patriots came out... ...(shudder)... ...we don't need a complex plot. FUCK!!!

Sorry to disappoint you, but Fallout already has a complex plot.
It does? I've played all three of the buggers and there hasn't been anything too complex.

Actually complex is probably not the right word to use...more like convoluted :p
Ah. Well, it is better than MGS4, you can't go twelve feet without tripping over a "retcon".

Lol so I've heard. I've never picked the game up but all I hear is talk about how long the plot is xD
If you're a fan, it's still worth picking up, MGS4 has been given the title of "Good game, bad sequel".