Strain42 said:
I probably should have specified better. I mean a person who CHOOSES to do that at the end of the day.
Yeah, I know.
But let me explain where I'm coming from on this.
Emo wasn't yet a thing when I was in high school, so instead we had people who were generally labelled as "goths" (most of whom really weren't goth at all, they were just alternative but the difference was lost on most of us at that age). Anyway, it was a community where a lot of people probably played up that they had "issues". Almost everyone self-harmed and a couple staged very public suicide attempts. A lot of the music we listened to was pretty angsty and miserable. We wore lots of dark colors. We wrote poetry. It was pretty cliched.
The thing is, I know that if I ever tracked down my high school friends 90% of them would be just fine now, they'd be normal well-adjusted adults who will have completely moved on and all their so-called problems will have turned out to be nothing. But at the time they were fucked. We were all fucked. High school is not an emotionally healthy environment for any human being, least of all someone who is as confused and hormonal as the average teen. True, most of us grow out of that, and as adults with a bit more perspective we realize how incredibly silly it was to get so hung up on our "problems" in high school, but at the time was real pain.
I myself became clinically depressed during high school, but you couldn't have picked me out from the other whiny goth kids at first. It's only once we all got out of that environment that the difference became apparent. For my friends, the environment had been the only thing keeping them down, and as soon as they were out of it they transformed into the normal, well adjusted human beings they'd always wanted to be.. the reason I was depressed wasn't that my problems were worse than theirs, it's that when the time came I stayed locked away in tiny, insignificant high-school level worries.
The point I'm trying to make is that it's not as easy as separating the clinically depressed from the fakers. I never met any fakers, I met people who were making drama out of tiny things but never anyone who was just straight up faking it.
See, depression itself isn't just chemicals, if it was then cognitive behavioral therapy wouldn't work, it's much more about how a person thinks. If you're a sensitive person in an environment which is beating you down all the time, it can make you genuinely depressed, there's not some special level above that. I've had clinical depression, and I've never felt some special brand of sadness which is truer and deeper than anyone else's sadness. It sucked, I lost years and years of my life to it, but it wasn't anything special. It was just pain like any other, like you'd feel if you lost your job or your relationship ended or someone died or if you were trapped in a school you hated.
Incidentally, on the "goths don't listen to emotive/depressing/maudlin music":
You have to be pretty trad not to like
anything remotely miserable.