09philj said:
In retrospect it's easy to point out that almost all the 3D Sonic games kind of suck, but at the time people thought they were good, especially Sonic Adventure 2. Also Sonic always has to be compared to Mario, and the worst main series Mario title since Super Mario 64 is generally considered to be either Super Mario Sunshine or New Super Mario Bros. 2, and neither of them is considered a bad game, just a lacklustre *Mario* game.
It's easy to do a lot of stuff. Doesn't make the claim true.
I mean, if we're looking at 3D mainline games only, that leaves us with Adventure, Adventure 2, Heroes, Sonic 06, Unleashed, Colours, Generations, Lost World, and Forces. Having played Adventure, Adventure 2, Heroes, 06, Colours, and Generations to completion (or in the case of 06, to the point where I feel I can still appraise it), I can't say any of them "suck" except 06. Heroes is certainly flawed, and none of the others are perfect, but "suck?" No. Not really.
Now of course, that's just one claim against another, but while there's certainly individual Sonic games that are lacklustre, there isn't some arbitrary designation that all the 3D ones are bad. Least not for me.