Stopping the Oil Leak - Ideas

Recommended Videos

GoodApprentice

New member
Apr 27, 2010
122
0
0
The head of BP is holding the world ransom and will only stop the oil leak if we pay him ONE MILLION DOLLARS! Mwha...mwhaha...mwhahahahaha!
 

AWAR

New member
Nov 15, 2009
1,911
0
0
Frungy said:
AWAR said:
uuh.. I think they have already clogged it u and now they are waiting for the pressure to decrease (how?) to seal it up completely.
The balloon idea is quite retarded, given the massive pressure of the leak.
You have any idea what pressure a carbon fibre or kevlar balloon can take? Plus, if you paused to thing about it properly instead of firing off your assumption that I'm an idiot you'd realise that the pressure equations are completely different than trying to plug a garden hose. The natural oil is escaping from an underground pocket. As it escapes the pocked it sucking water to replace the escaping oil. This is because nature abhors a vacuum. Slip a balloon to the side of the oil leak and allow the natural flow to drag it in, then inflate it in the flow, thus slowing and eventually totally cutting off the inflow of water and the outflow of oil. Pressure isn't such a huge issue since instead of dealing with a liquid in motion if you slow the flow you'll be dealing with static pressure. Naturally this wouldn't be one balloon, but rather several and wouldn't be the instant fix most people are aiming for, but it's a far more reliable solution and has one big advantage over what they're trying right now... which is that it would work.

You may now apologise.
Why should I apologise? I never called you an idiot. I wasn't even referring to your specific post.
What I meant was that inserting a balloon is not a solution. You might close up a hole but there are several others and there may be even more cracking up at this moment. Also who knows how strong the structure really is; fiddling with such massive pressure may break the whole damn pipe in half.
 

child of lileth

The Norway Italian
Jun 10, 2009
2,248
0
0
I'm not sure what idea I'd have. I just think it's hilarious "robots with diamond saws", was a last resort. How do you not use those first thing when you have them?

Anyway, I'd say maybe just try to put a wall against the hole, to try to at least cut down on the rate it's leaking for a bit. Then maybe just cut a hole in the shape of something specially made to fit perfectly to seal it, and then use something to make the seal more secure. I don't know. I'm not good with aquatics.
 

ssgt splatter

New member
Oct 8, 2008
3,276
0
0
Let's try the Russians idea; set off a massive explosion and try to make the oil well collapse on itself...whether or not it's a nuclear explosion is up to you.
 

swolf

New member
May 3, 2010
1,189
0
0
All right, I thought this would've already been done but, why not use a catheter? Yeah, the same technology that they use for urine tubes. Insert the tube and then have the end open up inside, this would plug the hole and redirect the oil to where you want it to go (in the human body this opens up in the bladder). Seriously, why won't that work? I would like to form a group sponsored by my fellow escapists to send a robot down and do this. We will split the profits!!! Also, for what is already spilled, just do like the Gold Rush. People come down, collect it up, and bring it to BP to be bought, filtered, processed, and then sold. Who's with me? Let's take over and make some $$$!!!
 

swolf

New member
May 3, 2010
1,189
0
0
ssgt splatter said:
Let's try the Russians idea; set off a massive explosion and try to make the oil well collapse on itself...whether or not it's a nuclear explosion is up to you.
Um, I wonder if Russia actually came up with that idea or if it was just confusion over somebody explaining the "Contingency" level of CODMW2?
 

nezroy

New member
Oct 3, 2008
113
0
0
I say we take off and nuke the entire site from orbit. It's the only way to be sure.
 

ssgt splatter

New member
Oct 8, 2008
3,276
0
0
swolf said:
ssgt splatter said:
Let's try the Russians idea; set off a massive explosion and try to make the oil well collapse on itself...whether or not it's a nuclear explosion is up to you.
Um, I wonder if Russia actually came up with that idea or if it was just confusion over somebody explaining the "Contingency" level of CODMW2?
Maybe, but I swear at some point Russia actually suggested this "plan" to us. I think it was in the first week or so of the rig going off when they gave it to us.