The last block of video games (I buy games in blocks and they have to of had a price drop) were Alan Wake, Just Cause 2, and Red Dead Redemption. I was really excited about Alan Wake and couldn't wait to play it. I only bought RDR because it was such a low price and I had a gift card. It was the perfect storm because I hate Rockstar and had zero desire to play RDR, which I perceived to be GTA in the old west (I really hate GTA and am not sure why that series is sweated so hard). Also, I was going to get BioShock 2 instead of it, but wanted to replay BioShock before I got it. That and the price difference (seriously, RDR was $22).
That being said, I think you can figure it out from there. I did not like Alan Wake. Didn't hate it, just wasn't huge on it. It felt tedious and very boring at parts. The characters were rather annoying except the assistant sheriff lady. Not to mention, Alan Wake has the stamina of an eighty year old Amy Winehouse (just noticed, same initials).
RDR was fantastic, however. Blew me away, and it's now one of my favorite games of all time. I was truly shocked by that game.
In case you're wondering, I recently started Just Cause 2. This game has been hyped, especially by many on this site, so naturally I bit into the apple that I hadn't even thought to grab. I walked into indifferent, yet optimistic. I'm about five hours in and have yet to see what all the fuss is about. So far, disappointing.