Suicide

[cuddly_tomato]

You are giving up the greatest gift ever given to you...

Say this to a person whose life is so bad he wants to commit suicide and he wants to do it even more.

But look at it this way,

You are giving up the greatest gift ever given to you, for what?

If every waking hour of that life is pure pain then you might not see it as a gift at all.

Both of you guys are right to a point, But here is something that you missed, Killing yourself is the most selfish thing you can do. Be it for physical pain or mental pain, you are doing it for your own ends, and not caring of anyone else but yourself. I knew people that have ended there life, one for a dumb reason, one for a really dumb reason. At first I hated them, because they were so freaking dumb, but I got on with my life.

(For someone who is going to use this against me, i beat you to it)

If you end your life, so that others may live that's a whole different can of worms.

So how much more selfish is it of you to want them to continue living just because you think it's so all-fire important that they do so?

Complaining that suicide is selfish is idiotic because wanting someone to live for your own reasons is just as selfish, if not more so.

Wow, you are a a dumb ass.

I said I was fine with someone killing themselves, I'm just giving another point to comment on. Do I have to right to say who lives or dies? No. Did I EVER say that? No. Then you sir, need to read and think before you type.

But what I really think, that is MY opinion, I think that someone who kill them self is weak. That my opinion does it make it right or wrong, no its a opinion. I can judge people upon the acts? Yeah, I can. Is there anything you can do about it? No, there isn't.

You might want to rethink that. First off, saying that suicide is the result of weakness is pretty far off the mark. Suicide can be the result of a prolonged struggle with a serious disease. Would you call a cancer sufferer weak for instance?

Secondly, I think you missed his point somewhat. He is saying simply that if it is selfish for one person to commit suicide because others would live in pain as a result of that action, the identical logic would dictate it is also selfish to ask another to live in pain because you want to avoid that pain.

 

[Hevoo]

You are giving up the greatest gift ever given to you...

Say this to a person whose life is so bad he wants to commit suicide and he wants to do it even more.

But look at it this way,

You are giving up the greatest gift ever given to you, for what?

If every waking hour of that life is pure pain then you might not see it as a gift at all.

Both of you guys are right to a point, But here is something that you missed, Killing yourself is the most selfish thing you can do. Be it for physical pain or mental pain, you are doing it for your own ends, and not caring of anyone else but yourself. I knew people that have ended there life, one for a dumb reason, one for a really dumb reason. At first I hated them, because they were so freaking dumb, but I got on with my life.

(For someone who is going to use this against me, i beat you to it)

If you end your life, so that others may live that's a whole different can of worms.

So how much more selfish is it of you to want them to continue living just because you think it's so all-fire important that they do so?

Complaining that suicide is selfish is idiotic because wanting someone to live for your own reasons is just as selfish, if not more so.

Wow, you are a a dumb ass.

I said I was fine with someone killing themselves, I'm just giving another point to comment on. Do I have to right to say who lives or dies? No. Did I EVER say that? No. Then you sir, need to read and think before you type.

But what I really think, that is MY opinion, I think that someone who kill them self is weak. That my opinion does it make it right or wrong, no its a opinion. I can judge people upon the acts? Yeah, I can. Is there anything you can do about it? No, there isn't.

You might want to rethink that. First off, saying that suicide is the result of weakness is pretty far off the mark. Suicide can be the result of a prolonged struggle with a serious disease. Would you call a cancer sufferer weak for instance?

Secondly, I think you missed his point somewhat. He is saying simply that if it is selfish for one person to commit suicide because others would live in pain as a result of that action, the identical logic would dictate it is also selfish to ask another to live in pain because you want to avoid that pain.

First, he misread what I said.

Second, its my opinion, there for its not right or wrong its an opinion.

I understand what he said, but he misread statements.

 

[Spartan Bannana]

These days, there's much talk of suicide, and while I personally think of it as a terrible thing and decision, I consider it to be a person's right. They should be allowed to take their own life if they really want to. However, many people see fit to stop other people from committing suicide, and I think that this is a form of oppression. So what do all of you think, is suicide a right? Should people be allowed to commit suicide unobstructed?

we know why your avatar is that...I guess

I'm not contemplating suicide at all

 

[Hevoo]

Second, its my opinion, there for its not right or wrong its an opinion.

Welllllll.... Your opinion is objectively true in the sense than x is your opinion, so it's true that your opinion is x. No deductive right or wrongs there, true.

But, oh for sake of example, if you held the opinion that the earth is flat your opinion is provably wrong.

Of course, you could start going epistemological about it and questioning what constitutes fact, but that would require a lot more text regarding inductive logic and a lot more playing with yourself.

Don't mistake this as a take on your stated opinion regarding suicide. Like you said, those are your own: case closed. This is just an obvervation on the nature of opinions, which IMHO, you're a bit off

Very well put, I have to say. ( I mean that)

But I really don't want to continue this topic anymore, and you can find that reason in one of my earlier posts. We will agree to disagree or whatever, I just don't really like this topic.

 

[Twentyfists]

I'm a Lutheran, and, apparently, suicide is not looked highly upon in Lutheranism. I think that this is a complex issue. On one side, the Christians feel that it brings harm to God's temple (the body) and causes pain to people who know them. However, the argument that suicide is a way out for people who live in pain is very true. I think that, if the suicide was prevented, steps should be taken to help the person who committed suicide.

 

[theklng]

if people want to commit suicide, then it's their choice. i know that most people will not have thought it through thoroughly before acting upon it, but it is still their choice. no law or other judgment should forbid this.

personally i've had times where i've contemplated suicide, but i've always talked myself out of it; the reason always being that i actually owe something to the world.

 

[mike1921]

If suicide is made legal isnt that the best assasination tool ever? You can push people to do things they dont want so would that make it legal to push somebody to suicide?
Pretty complex problem.

Give me a few differences between that and:

If sex is made legal isnt that the best rape tool ever? You can push people to do things they dont want so would that make it legal to push somebody to sex?
Pretty complex problem.

If you can't, you shall mount an arguement against all sex.

 

[chronobreak]

Here's a little song and video I did about suicide: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IObykt39Xsc

Should describe my opinion perfectly.

 

[floppylobster]

Most people who consider suicide change their minds later so those people trying to stop them are probably doing them a favour. They're still going to die so they're not really missing out on anything. If someone wants to kill themselves they'll find a way. It's not hard. If someone's able to stop them it's usually because they have had some doubt and have put themselves in a situation where someone can stop them.

You can leave at anytime, so you might as well stick around as long as you can. One thing is for sure, you can't come back.

 

[facaldo]

committing suicide is a cowardly act.
only those who are emotionally weak and those who do not trust in themselves take such an extreme step.
one must face the difficulties..n take up the challenges.
running away from solution has never been the solution.
i condemn this act.

 

[LewsTherin]

You shouldn't. Work through your problems, if they are of the kind that can be (not being terminal illness, etc.).

 

[hem dazon 90]

EDIT : move along move along

 

[jasoncyrus]

Ah yes, another scorching hot topic. Whats with all the potential explosive topics these days?

Suicide depends entirely on situation and if you can get yourself out of it. Terminal Illness etc, I'm all for it, hell I'll HELP.

Depression however, they can down right get over it in various ways so those people are simply pansies.

those are two far ends of the spectrum. If your life has quite frankly crumbled round your ears, hundreds of thousands in debt, spouse took everything, family and friends hate you, in jail etc etc. that could be cause for doing it since you've made a right sodding mess of your life have'nt you?

 

[hypothetical fact]

Suicide should be legalised and assisted; these people are only drains on society and their goal will ensure their own as well as the tax payer's happiness. Sure it will hurt families but as long as you are over 18 their responsibility for you is over and should respect whatever decision you make for your life. Them forcing you to live in pain and depression just so they can stay happy makes them far more selfish.

 

[Sylocat]

It's their life, they can end it if they want.

Sometimes, however, I do think that if it's going to be assisted, there should be some sort of procedure where you are recommended to a decent counselor beforehand. Or just asked to read this [http://www.cracked.com/article_15658_ten-minute-suicide-guide.html].

On the other hand, if they want to go out, they either have a reason or they're not very stable, and either way I'm not sure I should interfere even that much.

 

[Twilight_guy]

I'm catholic.
Canned response: No, its wrong.