Take your favorite game - and RIP IT TO SHREDS!

Recommended Videos

lacktheknack

Je suis joined jewels.
Jan 19, 2009
19,316
0
0
Basically, this is a fanboy test. Simply take your favorite game, and tear it a new one by nit picking every single niggling little thing you don't like about it. Be worse then Yahtzee here, people!

Make sure you count each nitpick separately. If you want to do more then one game (encouraged!), take the average number of flaws as your final number.

Finally, when you're done, open the spoiler below and rank yourself! 0: Raving Fanboy
1-3: Fanboy
4-8: Reasonable
9-12: High Standards
13-20: Unpleaseable
>20: (insert obligatory Yahtzee reference here)

Ready? GO KILL YOUR FAVORITE GAME!

<spoiler=Example><spoiler=Mirror's Edge>1. Although the free running is excellent, it takes several runs to do it smoothly.
2. The wall-grip mechanic is not excessively great.
3. The combat is NOT the focus and should be considered emergency only, so no complaints about guns. The melee, however, is too ineffective.
4. The last room FORCES combat. GAH.
5. The game is too short.
6. The boat doors take too long to open.
7. The story is uninspired at best, outright asinine at worst.
8. The frame rate collapses in the first level air ducts.
9. The camera moves a bit too slow, and I can never adjust the sensitivity to where I want it.

<spoiler=Far Cry 2>Although I'm not far in the game, here's what I have so far.
1. The stealth actually works very well - AT NIGHT - but it's hilariously bad during the daytime. That stealth suit looks really expensive, too, because...
2. Diamonds are quite difficult to find. They're spaced out a little bit too far.
3. The car can be fixed indefinitely. Not impressive.
4. The respawning checkpoints. Give me a break, people!
5. The soldiers fire at you, even if you're working for them.
6. Buddies like getting gunned down.
7. The malaria mechanic doesn't work as well as one could hope.
8. All of the voice acting is WAAAAYY too fast.

<spoiler=Results>Average: 8.5

I am: Borderline reasonable.
 

MiracleOfSound

Fight like a Krogan
Jan 3, 2009
17,776
0
0
Fallout 3:

1. Lots of bugs
2. Not a whole lot of quest content compared to other Beth games
3. Awkward animations
4. I can't fast travel to indoor locations
5. Giant Radscorpions

Um, I loved everything else about it.
 

Aqualung

New member
Mar 11, 2009
2,946
0
0
Dear Uncharted,

Your plot isn't very original, is it? ...But that's okay. I understand. It's hard making new treasure-hunting plots when there are only so many ideas available. It's okay.

Oh? Your romance with Elena in Uncharted 2 was a bit awkward and probably thrown in for fans, and could have been executed better instead of tossed into the ending? ...Oh well. At least they're happy together.

I'm not very good at this.
 

Kenko

New member
Jul 25, 2010
1,098
0
0
Mount & Blade : Warbands.

1.Multiplayer is rubbish, all you have to do to win is buy a 2h weapon and spam to win.

2.Alot small bugs messing up the singleplayer campaign quests at times.

3.Outdated graphics and wierd animations.

4.Lame random map generator at times wich can really mess up the game.

5.Too little things to do if you dont join one of the factions.

6. And spears are fricking useless, they never do any damage in multiplayer and are waaaay to slow wich makes them the most pointless weapon in the game.

7.Sloppy dialogues in Singleplayer with plenty of spelling errors and grammatical screw ups.
 

GoWithDAFro

New member
Feb 18, 2010
479
0
0
Kingdom Hearts.

Stupid Camera
Unskippable cutscenes
Have to kill all enemies in area before opening treasure chests
Have to let go of analog stick to change commands unless you're good with right analog stick

Anything else in the game that might be acknowledged as a flaw genuinely doesn't bother me. So I guess I'm barely reasonable.
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
Dear Modern Warfare 2:

1. You die to fast in multiplayer
2. Noobtubing
3. Camping
4. Fucking Akimbo Glocks
5. Where are the new Spec Ops missions?
6. Why is connecting to your parner in Spec Ops so damn hard?
7. Do something with the cheaters, dammit.
8. The plot is convoluted and really hard to follow
9. So, Russia declares war because they found a body of an American terorrist after an airport terrorist attack? That's all it takes to declare a war now?
10. Favela missions are really annoying

All I can think of.

So, dear Heavy Rain:
1-5. Plotholes.
6. Glitches. Fix them.
7. Nobody needs Move support.
8. But we really do need new Heavy Rain Chronicles


Aqualung said:
Oh? Your romance with Elena in Uncharted 2 was a bit awkward and probably thrown in for fans, and could have been executed better instead of tossed into the ending? ...Oh well. At least they're happy together.
Would disagree, seeing how Elena Fisher is one of my favorite female characters in gaming, but, oh well.

Soo, I'm reasonable. Wouldn't say that. It's just that MW2 is really easy to rip on for its multiplayer.
 

Alluminn

New member
May 7, 2008
16
0
0
Skies of Arcadia

1. Ridiculous encounter rate
2. Boss fights get pretty same-y
3. Fina's final special is INSANELY broken, in your favor
4. Ridiculous encounter rate
5. Those fucking Loopers
 

onikaze26

New member
Oct 9, 2009
48
0
0
deux ex:
-the main character jumped like a moron, among other failures of character animation
-trying to knock someone out took about a half hour
-poisoning someone resulted in you watching him say "oof" every second for five minutes
-makes a big deal of morality and the ability to knock people out instead of kill them, but gives you no reason to do the former
-multiple endings nice, but you can just save 5 minutes before the end and do all of them
-they somehow managed to pull of a sequel despite the tangled mess of multiple endings left after the first
 

Aqualung

New member
Mar 11, 2009
2,946
0
0
JourneyThroughHell said:
Aqualung said:
Oh? Your romance with Elena in Uncharted 2 was a bit awkward and probably thrown in for fans, and could have been executed better instead of tossed into the ending? ...Oh well. At least they're happy together.
Would disagree, seeing how Elena Fisher is one of my favorite female characters in gaming, but, oh well.
Oh, I think you misunderstood me. She's one of my favourite characters too, and I actually did want her and Nate to end up together by the end of the first Uncharted... I just don't think the execution of it at the end of Among Thieves was that great.
 

hazabaza1

Want Skyrim. Want. Do want.
Nov 26, 2008
9,612
0
0
Mass Effect 2
1) The mining was bad pre-patch. Mind you, they fixed it so I guess that counts as 1/2.
2) I would have liked a few more skills.
3) The dreaded "Bioware Look" haunts the game at times.
 

TerribleAssassin

New member
Apr 11, 2010
2,053
0
0
Dear Sonic Adventure:

1) Please sort out the really retarded control system you have going.
2) Please slap that homing system silly, why would I prefer to attack a beach bed but not that evil robot who's hungry for my testes?
3) Why does Tails have the urge to race everyone? Wouldn't it be better if you played the level at your own pace?
4) The Master Emerald shards are in the most retarded places, and the indicator doesn't help.
5) Amy, could have been re-fined gameplay some more, but it's annoying, especially Twinkle Park -_-
6) Gamma's story and gameplay was pretty good but pointless
considering he dies from that uber-Eggman robot
7) Big. Nuff said.
8)
Why is Super Sonic's story essentially 5 minuites of running around wondering what activates different cut-scenes, then about 3 minuites of a really easy boss battle, then a really REALLY hard boss battle?
9) The camera angles could do with a massive overhaul
10) What was the point of the Cream cameos in SA:DX?
11) And why was the different challange targets needed in Trial?
 

JourneyThroughHell

New member
Sep 21, 2009
5,010
0
0
Aqualung said:
JourneyThroughHell said:
Aqualung said:
Oh? Your romance with Elena in Uncharted 2 was a bit awkward and probably thrown in for fans, and could have been executed better instead of tossed into the ending? ...Oh well. At least they're happy together.
Would disagree, seeing how Elena Fisher is one of my favorite female characters in gaming, but, oh well.
Oh, I think you misunderstood me. She's one of my favourite characters too, and I actually did want her and Nate to end up together by the end of the first Uncharted... I just don't think the execution of it at the end of Among Thieves was that great.
Oh, right, yeah, I assumed without reading into your comment. My screw-up.

Still, I really liked the execution of the romance in Uncharted 2, probably better than in every game I've played since... forever.
 

Undead Dragon King

Evil Spacefaring Mantis
Apr 25, 2008
1,149
0
0
hazabaza1 said:
Mass Effect 2
1) The mining was bad pre-patch. Mind you, they fixed it so I guess that counts as 1/2.
2) I would have liked a few more skills.
3) The dreaded "Bioware Look" haunts the game at times.
4) Is starting to rely too much on DLC
5) Some "continuations" of ME1 encounters were total crap (I'm looking at you, Conrad Werner)
6) Overall limited enemy variety: Mecenaries, Geth and Collectors
 

Enemy Of The State

New member
May 31, 2010
977
0
0
Red Dead Redemption:

-John won't stop walking into walls
-He dies if he gets in waist-deep in water... cold balls or something?
-THE BACK END OF A HORSE ALL THE TIME
 

Tanis

The Last Albino
Aug 30, 2010
5,264
0
0
Persona 3 - FES:
1) Hey an emo/scene kid as the lead...INNOVATION, NOT!

2) Amnesia has a plot device for the lead male, plus a family getting killed? REALLY?

3) It only took Atlus, what? Ten games to have a hit!

4) FES - Where an expansion pack with shitty 'dungeon battles only' is considered innovation.

5) Japanese black dude and chicks doing English rap and RnB, the hell son?

6) Rich girl happens to be tsundere...COME ON!

7) Girl with short hair and light skin has mysterious powers, and is soft spoken? Fuck me.

8) A FUCKING DOG that battles...because its master died...why?

9) Hey, here's a GREAT idea...lets make all the side-characters, that you can use in battle, AI controlled only! Thanks Atlus, way to fuck up half the damn battles!

10) OMG I can date the 'colored girl', who happens to be into track/sports? AMAZING!

11) Pre-render backgrounds...what is this? 1997?

12) When the Dating Sim and High School Sim is one of the best parts of a J-R-P-G...there's a fucking problem!

13) So, the main character could be the Messiah or Shinigami, and Satan lets the MC decide...in a totally homosexual way. Why to steal from NGE!

14) Rich girl's crazy father created the ENTIRE DAMN PLOT OF THE GAME....*Sigh*...I don't even...

15) 'The Joker' falls in love with 'A girl from the other side, who's kind of dark and mysterious but in the end has a good hearth'...who then dies?
FUCK-ING-A!

16) I get charged 40 bucks for a few pieces of armor, and, again, a stupid turn based dudgeon crawler...What are you, EA?

17) So, a turn based JRPG that has you collecting monsters because some pointy nosed midget whats you to discover your true self...via a card game.
I know of seen this from somewhere.

18) Robot Girl who wants to be human and falls in love with the MC, whom she cursed when he was a baby. There's someone very much wrong with this.

19) Dear Atlus - Thank you for releasing this game, minus FES, on the PSP, with half the content removed...but still a full price. This makes me feel all warm and fuzzy inside, or maybe that's the torch I'm lighting.

20) The Dying Man - Seriously, totally, utterly, obvious. What is this? Clannad?

21) Again, AI controlled units...FUCK YOU IN THE NECK!
 

The Admiral

New member
Jul 23, 2008
116
0
0
Duck Hunt
1. I hate that freaking dog!!!!!!
2. You have to buy the light gun
3. Only have 3 bullets. What gun only has three shots?
4. I hate that freaking dog.
5. Two ducks at a time gets crazy hard at the faster speed.
6. Why can't I shoot the dog? I still have three shots in my weird @$$ gun.
7. Repetitive music.
8. Dumb AI.
9. Out dated graphics
10. You do not understand how much I hate that dog.
11. Light gun is inaccurate.
12. No sequel?
13. Multiplayer is lame.
14. Plot holes everywhere.
15. Terrible voice acting.
16. No character development.
17. No cheat codes.
18. Poor level design.
19. No DLC. (or is that a good thing?)
20. My Xbox 360 doesn't play cartridges. I need Paul to mod it for me.
 

AlternatePFG

New member
Jan 22, 2010
2,858
0
0
Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker

1) Many islands have little to no point to them.
2) The game is way too easy (this goes for most Zelda games)
3) Most items are lifted right out of prexisting Zelda games.
4) The story was almost non-existant.
5) Most of the mini-games were crap.
6) Some of the sidequests can be pretty grind heavy.