TerraMGP said:
Babies no, but perfume should have some sort of legal restriction yes.
Bottom line is that if you want to kill yourself that is your choice, but smoke carries from smoking sections, clings to cloths, and overall irritates alot of people especially with respiratory problems. So we are still talking about something that leaves the smell of smoke, wrings the health care system dry and causes discomfort or in some cases serious problems for others. I think in that case its only fair that smokers should have to pay more, especially those who know what they are getting into going into it. If you choose to start yourself on an addictive substance that you know will damage yourself let alone others then you should not be surprised when people get ticked off or ask you to pay more.
And yes its an addiction, but you know what? They know its one getting into it and they CAN quit. Its hard, and it sucks, but it CAN be done. This is not an issue of equal rights this is a matter of choosing to do something with a measurably harmful effect and then having the price of the item raised to compensate. They cost society more and cause more discomfort for others so that makes up for it.
I'm glad we can agree on perfume...most of that stuff is foul and I'm a smoker.
Oddly enough, we can't kill ourselves outright - we have to pay an arm and a leg to do so.
You are correct about the byproducts of smoking: poor ventilation makes smoke carry, it sticks to clothing, irritates a lot of people
especially with respiratory problems, among MANY other issues. Let's not forget about the litter, the massive financial drain on millions of people, the mega-corporations that lie, steal and cheat their way into killing their customers, etc etc. Smoking is bad.
However, it's legal.
If smokers are allowed indoors, then you have alternatives as to if you choose to be around smokers or not. It's when they're outdoors, like most laws are forcing them to be now, then you - as a random bystander - will probably get smoke in the face. Smokers are magical beings, but they can't control the wind.
I think being overweight wrings the health-care system dry more, smokers put a lot of money into that system - then, they use that system. Most likely, more money is put into whatever health-care system by smokers than they use. Fat people just eat a lot, and most food is not taxed like the rest of things (that just might be in the US).
While I'm not arguing if smoking is bad (it obviously is) - you are part of a culture that keeps it legal, whatever the reasons, you have to accept the responsibility of being one in that culture. If it's that bad, then by all means, try to make it illegal. You'll save tons of lives, by restricting their rights.
But, nickel and diming them is not beneficial. It's a downward spiral of restricting the rights of those that aren't 'one of us'. Next, it's let's tax cake-munchers, cause they're utilizing our health-care system and who wants to look at overweight people? Let's tax meat-eaters cause cows are destroying our environment, let's tax the chronically sick - cause they're a downer. Retarded people? They're going to be a drain on society for the rest of their lives, let's tax them, too. (The previous sentences are not my opinions. Our humanity is wrapped up in how we help the needy.)
As for your addiction paragraph. This is coming from someone that studies brains and how they work, albeit I'm not too terribly far into my courses...
All of these arguments about smoking is bad, raise taxes, etc - actually increases the chance that a certain population will start to smoke. You even did it yourself, classifying it as a 'habit', instead of a death sentence (addiction), might make someone that is on the fence slightly more likely to do it. Odd, how the brain works. "They know its one getting into it and they CAN quit." <- That is a sentence that makes it more okay to smoke, because everyone thinks they are one of those that CAN quit. You, and smokers, are just your brain - the body goes along for the ride - when you, the brain, needs something (addiction, for example) it tries to get it. Breaking addictions is one of the hardest things someone can do, and I'm sorry, but the average person on the street avoids hard-work like it's the plague.
When people get all pissy about smokers, essentially saying, "take their money!" or act like assholes to them, ridicule them, etc - they're going to keep smoking. A support structure and education, is what is needed to stop the smoking scourge on mankind. Or, an all-out ban on it, but that just treats everyone like babies.