The Puppy Killer Gets What She Deserves

[Guttural Engagement]

If any of you didn't know, only 1 of the puppies actually died. 5/6 of them were rescued by an old Dutch lady who lived across the river and saw her throwing them in.

 

[Blatherscythe]

If any of you didn't know, only 1 of the puppies actually died. 5/6 of them were rescued by an old Dutch lady who lived across the river and saw her throwing them in.

Thank the powers that be, but that's still one dead puppy and that is one too many.

 

[Blatherscythe]

and why do kids look up to those types of people?

I haven't the foggiest. I will admit a few of Eminem's songs are better than I expected, but no rapper is worthy of worship. Nor is any musician for that matter...I guess kids are just thick?

Maybe there's subliminal messaging in their videos that causes this hypnotic trance of arrongence and stupidity.

 

[GrimTuesday]

If any of you didn't know, only 1 of the puppies actually died. 5/6 of them were rescued by an old Dutch lady who lived across the river and saw her throwing them in.

Yep I even have the story in my post up thread.

 

[bjj hero]

Human lives are worth infinitely more than dog lives. Human's have the potential to impact the world in ways that dogs just can't.

It upsets me that people would put the lives of virtually useless animals before humans.

I disagree. Some people deserve to die, but hey, that's my opinion.

She's on the list.

Without animals humans wouldn't be able to exist either.

Without insects humans would not exist. Bet you still reach for the fly spray and swat wasps.

The womans actions are in poor taste. There should be consequences for her actions, yes. I don't get all of the internet tards making death threats though. Lets put it into perspective. She killed a dog, not a person.

 

[Spinozaad]

I really don't get it.

Yes, that there are worse things going on in the world is no reason not to angry at that puppy thrower.

But seriously, why all these threads about it? I don't know whether I should be confused or infuriated at the narrow minded, selective anger of the Nerd Collective...

 

[imnot]

Brilliant, thats actually what I think they should do.

 

[InfernoJesus]

I value everything based on how it will/may impact my life. If an animal being killed does not have the potential to impact me whatsoever, said incident has no value to me.

I determine the usefulness of a life based on its potential to impact society as a whole. Using this metric, you will likely come to the same conclusion I have. In fact, in this case, this girl's amusement is likely more useful than the dog's life, therefor I condone this act of "cruelty".

Backing up an argument with morals obsoletes the argument, as morals are illogical ideals, implanted into children at birth.

What a load of nonsense. Your ridiculous claim that human lives have an intrinsic value where animal lives don't is based on a moral viewpoint. If you would like to pretend there's no moral basis to this you wouldn't care whether either a human nor an animal died, provided it didn't affect you.

Also, your argument is based on circular reasoning. You were asked why human lives are more valuable than animal lives. You claimed that they are more valuable because they have the potential to impact society. However, to consider human society worth impacting, you must have already accepted that human lives are worthwhile.

So you just negated your own argument.

I didn't even think of that. I guess you're right.

With that in mind, it seems only natural that a species cares more for its own species than for others. In fact, I'd go as far as to say that humans are the ONLY species that gives 2 shits about other species, likely out of misguided morals.

Either way, my standing on the subject stays the same. Thanks for pointing that out though!

 

[Optional Opinion]

Correct me if I'm wrong but we know nothing of the back story of the video. She could just be a farm girl told to cull some unwanted puppies, if so the tosser is the person behind the camera not the girl. It's easier to throw a puppy into a river than drown it in a bucket.

Again correct me if I'm wrong but doesn't she live in an isolated town or something where a veterinary practice may be rare/absent or it might cost a ton to put an animal down.

Yes the video was shocking but we don't know her reasons behind the act.

I got one of my cats from a farmer who was going to kill the litter as his cat was impregnated by a stray tom.

Then again she could just be the twisted ***** everyone seams to think she is.

 

[InfernoJesus]

Human lives are worth infinitely more than dog lives. Human's have the potential to impact the world in ways that dogs just can't.

It upsets me that people would put the lives of virtually useless animals before humans.

The question is, is it better to have a puppy not impact the world, or have someone who drowns puppies make an impact on the world? Okay, that was phrased pretty poorly, but the point is not all impact is good, so if you're going to use that as a measurement, something that causes damage should be worth less than something that doesn't change anything.

For a totally exaggerated example, would you put Hitler's life above that of a kitten? Sure, invoking Godwin's law is a bit heavy handed, but where there's one exception there's more.

A very good point, to which I respond that no one can determine exactly how someone will impact the world. It all depends on whether or not you feel that the average person has a greater chance of impacting society positively or negatively.

In this case, I'm sure many people would claim that the fact that this girl is drowning puppies is evidence that she is the type of person that would impact society negatively. I don't have any background in psychology, so I have no idea whether or not this is a valid claim, however I will point out that none of us know the reasoning behind her actions and likely makes current assumptions mostly invalid.

 

[TheRightToArmBears]

Well she certaintly doesn't deserve to die. A jail sentence and therapy yes, but death no.

A) I don't believe in the death sentence (however amusingly portrayed)
B) Killing a human for killing an animal is fucking retarded. Sure, she shouldn't have done it, but she's a member of your own species and is capable of much greater things than a dog.

I'm not defending her actions, but killing her over it is both stupid and wrong.

 

[manythings]

Human lives are worth infinitely more than dog lives. Human's have the potential to impact the world in ways that dogs just can't.

It upsets me that people would put the lives of virtually useless animals before humans.

All lives are equal.
Humans and animals.
Also, a lot of the ways we "impact" the world are usually bad.

Why do you value the lives of other animals equally with humans?

Because we are animals too. Mammels actually but still. And today, I'm much prefering "other animals" over humans anyway, due to the fact that I'm very envious of them (especially the wild ones) for reasons I won't say on here.

Yeah, I'll stick with sentience, advancement and scientific progress. We were wild once and it sucked ass that is why we are people now.

EDIT: On a side note I whoe heartedly endorse people going to live in the wild places if that is their schtick but I also believe that people who make that kind of choice shouldn't be allowed anything that they can't make themselves out there.

 

[The Rookie Gamer]

Yay for awesome dogs and freshwater sharks!

 

[interspark]

i can almost imagine her and the cat-binner cackling in an underground evil lair plotting to kidnapp all things cute and fluffy

 

[Rakkana]

Feel a little better about the whole thing now.

 

[Macgyvercas]

Oh my god that was great!

 

[GiglameshSoulEater]

Human lives are worth infinitely more than dog lives. Human's have the potential to impact the world in ways that dogs just can't.

It upsets me that people would put the lives of virtually useless animals before humans.

I disagree. Some people deserve to die, but hey, that's my opinion.

She's on the list.

Without animals humans wouldn't be able to exist either.

Dogs are no longer one of those animals, and possibly never were. Besides, no 50 other animals are worth less than a human.

 

[cheese_wizington]

The being eaten bit made the video.