axlryder said:
You're only including a few of those elements for each of the movies. Please explain to me how ALL of those films fit your rather specific formula. What's more, he has fairly a different personality in each of those films. Heck, in Face Off and Adaptation he plays two different characters (sort of) in each movie. It sounds more like you're just trying to shoehorn those films in to meet your own preconceived notions. I'll give you the slightly eccentric bit, as he does tend to have eccentricities in most films he plays in. However, given that those eccentricities and the way they're portrayed vary significantly from character to character, it's not as though that's the most damning thing that could be said about an actor.
Sorry, you can't expect me to take the time to do anything you're accusing me of being bias about; that's rather self defeating waste of time. You like him, I don't and gave reasons. You disagree, now we can move on with our lives.
Axolotl said:
Except he isn't emotionally distant, he isn't fighting for a noble causing, he's stealing a baby. Yes the movie has character growth, most good films do.
Trying to give his wife the family she wants isn't noble? Sure the road to hell is paved with good intentions, the intent behind the act was a good one.
Axolotl said:
You're accuseing a David Lynch film of being formula?
The film? No. The actor? Yes. But even good directors can be somewhat formulaic (sadly even those some might enjoy, like Joss Whedon).
Axolotl said:
Except he doesn't act badly, his performances help define Raising Arizona and Wild at Heart. And these are films by the Coen Brothers and David Lynch, some of the best directors to ever work in Hollywood.
The quality of their work overall has been decent enough (Watching No Country For Old Men seemed equivalent to paint drying), but even some of the best directors have produced absolute shit. While a matter of popular opinion, even here on the Escapist, many examples can be given. One in particular springs to mind, I'll give you a hint, his last name rhymes with mucus.
I will grant that Cage sometimes has moments of charming enthusiasm, but as a general rule I tend to be uninterested in his work.