Vault101's guide to gender debates

Recommended Videos

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
Good day Forum goer and Forum-goer-ettes!

Today in the spirit of my past useful helpful and completely factual guides I would like to offer another part of my infinite wisdom...second only to our Lord and saviour Jim

[b/]but Vault![/b] you say

[b/]aren't you exasperating this issue by creating yet another thread adding to the glut of gender threads?[/b]

why you might be very well correct my friend! but I would implore you to take a look at the quantifiable clusterfuck our forums appear to be, is my thread going to make things any worse?

[b/]yes[/b]

[sub/]yeah well maybe you should take a break[/sub]

now the debate around feeeemales appears to fire the hearts of many online forum dwellers, yet it seems people need instruction of how to go about it

and that's where I come in!

I have complied a set of rules which everyone should follow when approaching an argument you are not required to follow them however failure to do so will....not do anything


[I/]1. can your argument be boiled down to "stop talking and go away"?[/I]

these might include

-refusal to acknowledge any disparity
-yeah but men
-make your own games

[b/]aren't they vaild arguments?[/b]
they could very well be in different context, particularly the first is a valid question to ask "whats the big deal in the firat place?"

however people are not to be trusted, two of these are often irrelevant 99% of the time and the other when stubbornly stuck too does nothing to further conversation or understanding. The logical conclusion to all of these is essentially [I/]everything is fine and I don't have to worry or feel bad[/I] eg:

-oh youre right...there actually isn't any issue with medias portray of women. Problem solved
-oh well that issue balnces everything out and nullifies my points. I'll speak no more
-ok I'm going to go make games instead

its a comforting thought, that nothing is wrong, but like most things its simply not true

this isn't about questioning weather or not something might be sexist, that's a discussion worth having, this is about strong denial

2.[I/]do you feel bad?[/I]

whenever someone criticises something you like do you get that little twinge in your stomach that translates to anger? do you get that twitchy little urge to slam away at a keyboard to tell them how wrong they are? even though deep down all your really arguing is a matter of taste?

do you feel that buy insulting your favourite game/movie/book/erotic fan fic that they have insulted a part of [I/]you[/I]?

I doubt people have lost their collective shit over a thing they like being insulted

[I/]it is a part of them that has been insulted[/I] the solution to this requires a little...shall we saying growing up...its a natural process you'll find happens to a lot of us

we must emotionally disconnect from the things we like..this DOES NOT mean we enjoy them less but it means we can look at them through a critical eye

for example Mass Effect 3 is full of bad writing

[b/]but...I thought you liked ME3?[/b]

I do

[b/]so you ackowleged something bad in it while liking it at the same time? is such a thing possible?[/b]

it is, I also like country and hip hop! particually Eminem

[b/]but Vault! I've gather by now you're kind of a femenazi SJW how can you POSSIBLY like something as sexist and homophobic as Eminem?[/b]

well bold text I "could" say that slim shady is just a persona and that its all just par for the coarse in Hip Hop, however personally I feel that would be dishonest, because the guy really does come across that way...he's got more issues than the entire run of superman., I enjoy his music and his skill, the sexism thing I merely put aside, as I still want to and can enjoy his work

[b/]so youre a terrible person for liking Eminem?[/b]

no I am not,

I WOULD however be a terrible person if I acted like a jerk towards those who do not share my view of Eminem for those reasons

[b/]so its not an issue for you?[/b]
it can be, I have very little interest in GTA because for me there's not really any appeal amongst the sexism and (even if it is satire) its probably a perfectly good game but I need more than just being good these days, and no, I don't hate anyone for liking GTA

so in conclusion you've got nothing to feel bad about!

[I/]3.what is your argument based on?[/I]

are you frightened there are forces similar to the illuminati led by you know who waiting to destroy all good things? well fear not! this is merely a mass hysteria populating forums and not really indicative of real life

films have been under such examination far longer than ever and they are still [strike/]sexist as ever[/S] not PC centric pillars of inclusivity

no friends, the true threat to "art" is when the commercial side takes over, a push for better representation is not and will never be a "threat" to what we hold dear, and if you enjoy projects made from the heart with compelling and diverse characters this should not be a worry

[I/]4. Feminsm[/I]

do you know it?

[b/]yes[/b]

do you?

[b/]yes[/b]

DO YOU?

[b/]yes![/b]

go look it up

[b/]but-[/b]

now!

[b/]can I use that word in the mean time?[/b]

NOOO!!

[b/]what about SJW[/b]
NEVER!!

the use of words and labels contributes to the mass hysteria particularly when its described as "political" now usually I wouldn't object to use of the word feminism but the internet has proved time and time again it cannot be trusted. This really is not political, the issue of female representation in games is a very basic position and shouldn't really be controversial

[I/]5. ultimately do you have anything to say? do you have anything to learn?[/I]

has slamming your head against a keyboard taught you anything? are you better for it? have you LEANRED anything or have you just gotten yourself into a rage? why are you upset?...really? would this time be better spent listening to enya?

I would like to thank you all for reading, unfordable I won't be reachable as I have descended into my protective bunker..

[b/]but Vault! I found your post both condescending and one sided![/b]

any condescension you may find in this post may in fact be intentional satire in the style of jim sterling, any unintentional condecention I apologise for and you encourage you to blame our lord and saviour Jim

I do however take full responsibly for any "bias" you think my post contains, my opinions may align with one particular "side" to this great debate and I make no pretense taking any perceived "middle ground" as the assumption that a middle ground always exists and is always "correct" is quite frankly false as far as I'm concered

[b/]vault you post has made me angry![/b]
take the following steps

1.go to youtube
2. look up "sail away by enya"
3. sail away

*closes bunker door*
 

Thaluikhain

Elite Member
Legacy
Jan 16, 2010
19,538
4,128
118
This is definitely one of those times the title or the OP needs to say "Please actauly read before replying", because...well...
 

Jux

Hmm
Sep 2, 2012
868
4
23
Sorry Vault, but because I am a man, and my perspective is automatically the default one, I am going to dismiss this and just chalk it up to womens hysteria. Furthermore, it's obvious you're just trying to silence me and take away my Call of Dudebro games. The only rational response:

 

Ten Foot Bunny

I'm more of a dishwasher girl
Mar 19, 2014
807
0
0
Vault101 said:
[b/]vault you post has made me angry![/b]
take the following steps

1.go to youtube
2. look up "sail away by enya"
3. sail away
But... but... but...


And now I think I'm going to go turn on Saints Row and hit things with a dildo bat, just one more feminist using the man to stick it to Da Man!

Or maybe I'll go turn on Minecraft and pet my kitty. Hehehe. ;)
 

shrekfan246

Not actually a Japanese pop star
May 26, 2011
6,374
0
0

Oh, wait, you said Enya?

But Enya is a feemale, so obviously it would be furthering the feminist agenda for us to listen to "Orinoco Flow"!

Aw hell, I'll listen to it anyway because I just think it's a good song.

 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
thaluikhain said:
shrekfan246 said:
Ten Foot Bunny said:
Jux said:
MarsAtlas said:
*opens bunker door*

damn femenazis everywhere!

*slams bunker door*

MarsAtlas said:
]
I'm glad you made the first point what it was, because people are most likely to read that and take away from it..
or read it and rage...I think that's the stickiest point that you can't really get across without accruing a lot of criticism

Eddie the head said:
That's nice and all but I prefer the Wargames approach. The only wining move is not to play.
that's also a very good point...actually you'll notice a...."certain" thread in gaming discussion that is basically NOT to go about it

Skatologist said:
I think Vault may deserve this for the best OP ever award!
PPS(or is it PSS): Thank you for basically covering all bases, too bad this won't be such a pleasant little thread for long. Your advice will boil down to some coming across what you wrote as censorship and rules and silencing someone else to by saying their arguments are stupid. I await backlash!
I try....
 

Skatologist

Choke On Your Nazi Cookies
Jan 25, 2014
628
0
21
I think Vault may deserve this for the best OP ever award!



PS, sorry, I'm left handed.

PPS(or is it PSS): Thank you for basically covering all bases, too bad this won't be such a pleasant little thread for long. Your advice will boil down to some coming across what you wrote as censorship and rules and silencing someone else to by saying their arguments are stupid. I await backlash!
 

BathorysGraveland2

New member
Feb 9, 2013
1,387
0
0
It's a nice effort Vaulty, but I don't see it changing much. Words and posts, no matter how well-written, don't really do much to dissuade people on the internet from speaking bullshit. Maybe one or two might think better of it after reading this, but the majority won't. We'll still be seeing this shit until people lose interest in Zoe Quinn and all this controversy and then move onto the next little internet hate/debate-trend, then this site will calm down a little bit. That's my prediction anyway. Hopefully I'm wrong!
 

Zhukov

The Laughing Arsehole
Dec 29, 2009
13,769
5
43
So, if I'm reading this correctly your main point is that... you actually like Eminem.

...

Would you prefer the firing squad or the stake?
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
BathorysGraveland2 said:
It's a nice effort Vaulty, but I don't see it changing much. Words and posts, no matter how well-written, don't really do much to dissuade people on the internet from speaking bullshit. Maybe one or two might think better of it after reading this, but the majority won't. We'll still be seeing this shit until people lose interest in Zoe Quinn and all this controversy and then move onto the next little internet hate/debate-trend, then this site will calm down a little bit. That's my prediction anyway. Hopefully I'm wrong!
this really has been going on since sarskeesian, now its exploded again...we need something new to be angry about,but the only thing I can think of is if the Xbone re-enstated its always online

...hell I'd love to see that....

Zhukov said:
So, if I'm reading this correctly your main point is that... you actually like Eminem.

Would you prefer the firing squad or the stake?
and what do YOU like? is it the eagles? its the eagles isn't it? well fuck the eagles!
 

Zhukov

The Laughing Arsehole
Dec 29, 2009
13,769
5
43
Vault101 said:
Zhukov said:
So, if I'm reading this correctly your main point is that... you actually like Eminem.

Would you prefer the firing squad or the stake?
and what do YOU like? is it the eagles? its the eagles isn't it? well fuck the eagles!
The what now? To me, "eagles" are large birds of prey.

Nah, I'm like waaay too edgy and free thinking to like any music at all. I refuse to be put in your labelled box you oppressive oppressor!

Also, I'm borderline tone deaf. That might have something to do with it.

My tastes in music amount to a handful of things I heard someplace and thought, "that sounds kinda cool".

...

What were we talking about again?
 

Colour Scientist

Troll the Respawn, Jeremy!
Jul 15, 2009
4,722
0
0
I'm just going to go ahead and attribute your legitimate feelings of concern or sadness to menses.
 

Pinkamena

Stuck in a vortex of sexy horses
Jun 27, 2011
2,371
0
0
Pinkamenas guide to internet gender debates: Stay the fuck out of them. 100% success rate.
 

Vault101

I'm in your mind fuzz
Sep 26, 2010
18,863
15
43
Colour Scientist said:
I'm just going to go ahead and attribute your legitimate feelings of concern or sadness to menses.
don't forget hysteria

....I admit I haven't been to my physician to for a massage...
 

Ten Foot Bunny

I'm more of a dishwasher girl
Mar 19, 2014
807
0
0
Skatologist said:
PS, sorry, I'm left handed.
Woohoo!!! We lefties rule! :D But I fail to understand why our takeover is not yet complete. Hmm... there's a goal for tomorrow.



Vault101 said:
and what do YOU like? is it the eagles? its the eagles isn't it? well fuck the eagles!
The Dude agrees.

 

carnex

Senior Member
Jan 9, 2008
828
0
21
Vault101 said:
What you wrote here would be funny if it wasn't actually sad, really really sad.
Now let me present with what you wrote. I don't know what you tought, but I do know what you wrote.

1) You are making a statement and then you are prohibiting discussion of that statement. Among other things why it shouldn't be discussed you state that people are not to be trusted. And you made statement with no intention to back it up with facts and we are suposed to trust you.

This whole point depends on you being unquestionable moral authority. Whole point is absolute failure of logic!

2) You are telling people to hold on their reactions if they are feeling insulted. Granted, that is a good advice, agitated people make bad statements. Irrational ones.

But this damn shit is propagated by persons that feel entitled to never feel offended. I think people who start this discussion on that base should take a look at mirror prior to opening their mouths. It bloody helps.

Other than that. Pretty much common sense.

3) There is no need for patronizing, you don't want to start alienating audience with core rules (although first rule does that much more effectively) but I can agree with with if for the most parts. Diversity is good.

On the second part I can not agree in the slightest. I could go into details and explanations but I will sum it up in one statement.

Mona Lisa was and still is commissioned portrait, purest form of commercial product.

So your argument of product, not art fails.

4) I know what feminism stands for. I know by what feminism did when once it obtained influence and power. It's you and others who keep reciting dictionary definitions while refusing to look at real world who don't know feminism. And this point can not be driven far enough.

I would point you to one of my posts that presented everyone with results but unfotunatelly this board has horrible search and I'm not willing to dig through some 300 posts I made in threads that could contain that.

5) I never gave into rage. People raged onto me. For countering them with facts, research, hard data and statistics.

Your rules are not that much reasonable rules for discussion as they are "I Win" button.

Now let me present simple rules of discussion

- Make a claim, philosophical. Explain your logic behind it, be prepared to get it shot full of holes, do not get angry, explain holes if possible, discuss validity, do mental experiments, if proven faulty rethink the claim
- Make a claim. substantial. Present data you based your claim on. Be prepared to receive counter data, different iteration, conclusions, paths of logic. Absorb, redress issue, discuss, if needed rethink the claim
- Be civil, reasonable human, willing to accept that you might be wrong while representing what you believe is right.

And that is all. Everything else is BS.

I cover your enya and raise you "The Dude"