I can't think of any criticism for Chrono Trigger or Planescape: Torment. They were just extremely well-done games.
Video Games you cannot criticize.
- Thread starter tehweave
- Start date
Recommended Videos
Now, I don't think that many of these are particularly valid points.weker said:
1. How do you know that Madison has never met the Origami Killer? She's an investigative journalist, she might well know who else is investigating the case.
2. That's not a plot hole. People not giving stuff to the police does not make it a plot hole.
3. I have no idea what this is talking about, because I wasn't captured by the police. No comment on this one.
4. Sure, the evidence might not be particularly convincing, but it's the best the police had, and again, it's not a plot hole.
5. This can be explained easily. Shelby could have given him the Origami. We know that he is watching Ethan closely.
6. Making logical deductions is not a plot hole.
7. Hold your breath. There's plenty of air inside a fridge to last a couple of minutes, and she only stays in it for a few seconds. I don't see fridges being "impossible" to open from the inside. It's not like you have to apply a lot of force to open a fridge door.
8. The drug alleviates the side effects of over-exposure to ARI; the drug itself is not dangerous.
9. Maybe the Swat team didn't shoot Ethan because they were trying to capture him and question him about the location of his son. As for guns being useless, remember that bit where Shelby shoots people and they die? Sure doesn't seem useless to me.
10. Don't have much to say to this, seems a fair criticism. Still, the plot makes sense even if Mad Jack doesn't bother to cover up his crimes.
11. Do you think that perhaps Shelby could have gone through the tunnel system, and on the way back, dropped broken glass everywhere?
12. It's perfectly possible that Ethan's alter ego was willing to mutilate himself to prove his love for his son.
13. It was the middle of the night, it's perfectly conceivable that the police were on their way. The entire scene wasn't particularly long, so the police may have just not gotten there yet.
14. Having money is not a plot hole. There's plenty of places that Shelby could have gotten the money from.
15. The thing with Manfred is a bit of a cheat, I agree.
2. That's not a plot hole. People not giving stuff to the police does not make it a plot hole.
3. I have no idea what this is talking about, because I wasn't captured by the police. No comment on this one.
4. Sure, the evidence might not be particularly convincing, but it's the best the police had, and again, it's not a plot hole.
5. This can be explained easily. Shelby could have given him the Origami. We know that he is watching Ethan closely.
6. Making logical deductions is not a plot hole.
7. Hold your breath. There's plenty of air inside a fridge to last a couple of minutes, and she only stays in it for a few seconds. I don't see fridges being "impossible" to open from the inside. It's not like you have to apply a lot of force to open a fridge door.
8. The drug alleviates the side effects of over-exposure to ARI; the drug itself is not dangerous.
9. Maybe the Swat team didn't shoot Ethan because they were trying to capture him and question him about the location of his son. As for guns being useless, remember that bit where Shelby shoots people and they die? Sure doesn't seem useless to me.
10. Don't have much to say to this, seems a fair criticism. Still, the plot makes sense even if Mad Jack doesn't bother to cover up his crimes.
11. Do you think that perhaps Shelby could have gone through the tunnel system, and on the way back, dropped broken glass everywhere?
12. It's perfectly possible that Ethan's alter ego was willing to mutilate himself to prove his love for his son.
13. It was the middle of the night, it's perfectly conceivable that the police were on their way. The entire scene wasn't particularly long, so the police may have just not gotten there yet.
14. Having money is not a plot hole. There's plenty of places that Shelby could have gotten the money from.
15. The thing with Manfred is a bit of a cheat, I agree.
Ultimately, your criticisms don't matter, because the thread is about video games I cannot criticise, and I couldn't fault Heavy Rain.
Okay, everyone's said Portal already, but I'll add my candle of approval to the megawatt torch alerady shining.
Also, I just finished playing Professor Layton and the Curious Village. It's certainly not a game for everyone, but there is no legitimate criticism I can make of it.
(When I say 'legitimate', I mean how you could whinge that it doesn't have enough guns or how you can't collect stars, but then you're asking for it to be a different game).
Also, I just finished playing Professor Layton and the Curious Village. It's certainly not a game for everyone, but there is no legitimate criticism I can make of it.
(When I say 'legitimate', I mean how you could whinge that it doesn't have enough guns or how you can't collect stars, but then you're asking for it to be a different game).
Actually, the last testchamber, (the one where you escape into the facilities insides) went on for too long without introducing enough new gameplay mechanics.Ldude893 said: