That review kinda put me off getting Soulstorm. The original DoW was the first RTS game i played without cheating and i thought it was awesome! Dark Crusade was the best yet and i really liked the meta-map and the Tau. I havent tried Soulstorm yet, but from this review, I doubt I will any time soon.
No persistent bases? That's sad. That was one of the parts that made the DC campaign fun and realistic. Without it, i doubt i would have wanted to finish the campaign. Playing the same goddamned map over and over again even with persistent bases is a bit boring =P. If thats whats happenin in Soulstorm, i won't get it.
As i said, I havent tried Soulstormthe voice acting in Dawn of War has always been excellent. Its cheesy, but its terrific (I really loved the individual amount of effort directed at each single units voice acting). It is really that shitty, i'm definitely not trying the game.
One other thing i have against the campaign (and one reason why i didnt buy it) are the air units. From what I've seen, each race (excluding Necrons) get onli one air unit. Which doesnt seem to do much. It sounds like some half-assed attempt to inject new flavor into the game. Plus, they didnt even add new units. Come on, if they want to add air units, couldnt they at least make them viable and more interesting, instead of making them look like last-minute add-ons to the game. Or alternatively, they could add in new units.
Soulstorm is the last game in the Dawn of War series. Relic may be working on the new DW2, but couldnt they at least give us a good, fun game, one last game to end the first series with a bang instead of pushing to some developer who cant get it right?
(P.S, i havent tried Soulstorm yet, this is just based on what i've heard of the game's system and from other people who've tried the game)