"Western games don't have good storys"

Recommended Videos

dbmountain

New member
Feb 24, 2010
344
0
0
Blitzwing said:
Ever consider that the narrative was bad because that games writers didn?t know how to write a good narrative?
Don't be ridiculous, obviously the narrative is bad simply because of the geographical location in which the game was developed! Just like all "Western" games have bad stories just because they are made in "the West". It's all so clear I don't understand how there could be any confusion
 

Chaz D

New member
Feb 1, 2009
98
0
0
I love it when someone makes a comment about a broad spectrum of games and people think that producing one or two examples of games against it proves that the opinion is wrong.

Yes, Mass Effect has a good story. Yes, Bioshock has a good story. Yes, Red Dead Redemption had a good story. The point is that for every one of these there are dozens of Call of Dutys, or Uncharteds, or GTAs with stories on a par with below-average, Hollywood-branded, cookie-cutter crap, and the few that do manage to get a decent story in there still do so in a genre and aesthetic that is (in whole or in part) borrowed from extremely formulaic Hollywood templates (see Mass Effect, Red Dead Redemption). Pointing-out the one or two examples that happen to rise above this problem is like pointing out the one or two people who are healthy during a plague and saying that this is a sign that the plague doesn't exist.

Now, what's really funny to me is how for many people the mention of "eastern games" makes them automatically think "Square-Enix developed JRPG", as if the entire eastern gaming industry comes out of a single company and a single genre. Even then, for all their recent shortcomings, at least Square-Enix are actually trying to construct worlds that are uniquely beautiful and possess a wholly original mythology. Fact is, eastern games tend to be far more diverse, interesting and thematically and conceptually rich than western games in terms of story. You want a list of eastern games that tell more interesting and deeper stories than western developed ones? Go down to your nearest game shops and just look at the damn things.
 

darkcommanderq

New member
Sep 14, 2010
239
0
0
Yeah Bioware blows that argument out of the water. In fact I find it strange that Japans Anime usually has some really good stories, while Jrpgs stories are usually pretty terrible.

By contrast americans cartoons stories remain simply (like JRPGS), and Western RPGS usually rock stories.

KOTOR, NWN, ME, DAO, etc... Bioware all the way.