Sud0_x said:
Manji187 said:
Heh...it's funny how everybody has by now accepted the fact that this is an eternally recurring thread against which no amount of "searchbar nazism" will suffice.
But seriously people, just ask yourself...how many times have you answered the question by now?
Oh......oh.....raking up post counts aren't we? Move along, citizen

.
Nicely ironic.
(Currently secretly celebrating a huge +1 post count with drool raining down my chin and an uncontrollable erection) <----- Sarcasm
No, but really, thanks for your input. Anything to say on topic?
I'll give you your point about this being a recurring thread but does it really bother you
that much?
I see you posted in a zombie related thread today, I believe it was a thread about how oversaturated the whole concept of zombies is.
Those things are pretty original huh? In my opinion; this is irony on an 'inception'-like level.
Lighten up dude

...why so serious? Did I hurt your feelings with my post or something? The posts thing was just a joke.
What bothers me about threads like these is that they have little capacity for starting any meaningful discussion. Very often it is just number spamming (VI, VII, IX, X etc) with a short explanation (a couple of sentences/ a paragraph): nothing interesting/ inspiring.
On topic: for nostalgia reasons I like IX best, but to be honest the older I get and the more entertainment (in various media) I consume, the more I understand just how bad ALL FFs are (story/ narrative/ plot/ characterization wise), even the ones I consider good in comparison. As a teenager immersion/ acceptance comes easier. Play the game again 5-10 years later and you are likely to notice more (and accept less).
I can tell you at age 13-14 FF VIII seemed a big deal. I played it with zeal and thought it was a serious game. At age 21 I laughed my ass off at just how ridiculous a large portion of the game was. Same game, I just got older and had more experiencs under my belt to compare it with.
The more FFs I have played, the less of an impact they had. "Surprise" reveals of a different antagonist who was actually controlling the initial antagonist. I've seen it before and have come to expect it.
A ragtag bunch of misfits who in the end, through the power of love and friendship, overcome their differences, endure hardships and obtain an unambiguous victory over the powers of evil (often evil for evil's sake) and thus save the day, the world and maybe even the universe. An epic quest in which you run around the world and at the end of which you always win. It features The Hero, The Love Interest, The Best Friend, The Cooky One, The Comic Relief, The Veteran, The Eccentric...you get the picture. In the end, FF games have come to slavishly follow their own recipe.
What about loss of friendship (through other means than death)? Pyrrhic victories? Ambiguous evil? Characters that transcend their roles? What about guilt, shame, remorse, doubt, jealousy, contempt? In other words, mature themes....with all the accompanying depth.
In my view, FF is a predominantly teenage product, created with teenagers in mind and mostly enjoyed by teenagers. Do not read any negative judgment into this statement, it would be your own projection.
Now, wouldn't you call this a real discussion as opposed to "I like FF X best because Yuna is cute and Sin is scary and oh my gosh the story is so kewl..".