What game do you think TRULY deserves a sequel or needs to be stopped.

Recommended Videos

Fightgarr

Concept Artist
Dec 3, 2008
2,913
0
0
pimppeter2 said:
There have never been truer words spoken. Nothing needs a sequel. Games have to stop being made in trilogies. There is nothing wrong with a good stand alone title.
While I am a huge fan of a standalone title, I feel like saying you shouldn't make games in trilogies can be argued against fairly easily. A trilogy allows a game to tell a broader story, on a more grand scale, without rushing anything. I disagree with sequels which continue a story that has been closed up and dealt with only to start anew for the sequel, but on the basis that games shouldn't create what is effectively a story-arc spread over several games I disagree with. Take books for example, would The Lord of the Rings have been an effective epic if it had been crushed into one book of 4-500 pages? Maybe, but much less so, with far less rich detailing which made them so endearing. I go to my impressions on the story of Mass Effect, which, while not being brilliant or innovative, is still a grand and epic story that I don't believe can or should be condensed into one game.

I agree that games should strive more for being stand-alone, but stopping trilogies preventing larger story arcs seems a bit foolish to me.

robbins123 said:
Shadow of the Colossus
It's when people post games like this as needing sequels that I get upset. SotC completed it's individual story arc. To create a sequel could easily ruin the curious and interesting element about the games story: that you knew almost nothing about the world.
 

King7s

New member
Dec 13, 2009
57
0
0
I have yet to see this but we need a mirrors edge 2 that and portal 2 when those happen shit will get serious
 

PaladinThaddeus

New member
Nov 21, 2009
8
0
0
I'd like a new fallout game in the style of fallout 1, 2 or tactics, yes fallout 3 was fun, but please give me another fallout thats not in first person and feels like an actual fallut 3
 

teutonicman

New member
Mar 30, 2009
2,565
0
0
theironbat46 said:
teutonicman said:
theironbat46 said:
Did you see the trailer for the second one?
teutonicman said:
Batman AA
OHHHH man when I saw that during the Spike VGAs my mouth was open the entire time, I was thinking "Holy hell I can't believe there pumping out a trailer already!"
I comes out in August.I Saw it on a one of those GameStop release date paper things on the counter.
BULLSHIT!..... really?! only a year in between the 2 games, that must mean it was started pretty much immediately after AA's production was over. Was a tile given on the display?
 

mykalwane

New member
Oct 18, 2008
415
0
0
Voodoo Vince. This much many unappreciated games has dept of character is fun, and comes off as an unique game. Hell I be happy with making the game backwards compatible on the 360. Still don't get why games that have any real dept that isn't a kill fest of things to kill. If there is even a decent story it gets the ass in exchange for a crappy story and crappy gameplay. Just once I like to see a good game get a sequal that is good.
 

DRTJR

New member
Aug 7, 2009
651
0
0
Needs: Chrono Trigger/cross, Dragon age origin(in about 4 to 5 years), Fire emblem, and Pikmen

Needs to die:Mario, Sonic, Cod, MoH, Halo, Gears, GoW, Mario Party, Mario kart, Final fantasy, Bond games, Resident evil, and Age of empires
 

blue heartless

Senior Member
Legacy
Aug 28, 2005
501
6
23
Final Fantasy VII should have a sequel. Or is it prequel?

Maybe MegaMan will answer that question in his next game, if he isn't swarmed with all those Dynasty Warriors. Chances are, he'll have a few Pokemon to help him out. If not, he could always hop into his Gran Turismo, yell "I have a Need for Speed!", and run them down.

But most likely he will be arrested and charged with Grand Theft Auto.
 

Gafawed

New member
Nov 17, 2009
13
0
0
Psychonauts, and im lookin foward to Half Life 2 Ep 3, and definatley beyond good and evil
 

theironbat46

New member
Aug 19, 2009
664
0
0
teutonicman said:
theironbat46 said:
teutonicman said:
theironbat46 said:
Did you see the trailer for the second one?
teutonicman said:
Batman AA
OHHHH man when I saw that during the Spike VGAs my mouth was open the entire time, I was thinking "Holy hell I can't believe there pumping out a trailer already!"
I comes out in August.I Saw it on a one of those GameStop release date paper things on the counter.
BULLSHIT!..... really?! only a year in between the 2 games, that must mean it was started pretty much immediately after AA's production was over. Was a tile given on the display?
Nah, just said Batman:Arkham Asylum 2
 

Pimppeter2

New member
Dec 31, 2008
16,479
0
0
Fightgarr said:
pimppeter2 said:
There have never been truer words spoken. Nothing needs a sequel. Games have to stop being made in trilogies. There is nothing wrong with a good stand alone title.
While I am a huge fan of a standalone title, I feel like saying you shouldn't make games in trilogies can be argued against fairly easily. A trilogy allows a game to tell a broader story, on a more grand scale, without rushing anything. I disagree with sequels which continue a story that has been closed up and dealt with only to start anew for the sequel, but on the basis that games shouldn't create what is effectively a story-arc spread over several games I disagree with. Take books for example, would The Lord of the Rings have been an effective epic if it had been crushed into one book of 4-500 pages? Maybe, but much less so, with far less rich detailing which made them so endearing. I go to my impressions on the story of Mass Effect, which, while not being brilliant or innovative, is still a grand and epic story that I don't believe can or should be condensed into one game.

I agree that games should strive more for being stand-alone, but stopping trilogies preventing larger story arcs seems a bit foolish to me.

I get what you're saying, but I'd like to cleat some things up. Making a Trilogy is fine. As long as you have a plan to make it. Games like Halo, The Jak series, Mass Effect, ect are all fine. Because they already know that they are making a trilogy. However, these newer titles that come out, ones with little story that are just continued for the sake of the developer having no more ideas

Games like Wet. Now imagine if they made a Wet 2, which we will probably see sometime in the future. Wet doesn't need a sequel, it doesn't set up for one, and it certainly doesn't deserve one (imho).

Sadly, developers are too afraid of making new IPs that they just continue every single release ever made.

Do we honestly need a Mirrors Edge 2? Is the story that good that we need to know what is going to happen? No! People enjoyed Mirrors Edge for the new type of freeruning that it brought. So why not make a new IP with a similar style? It gives you a blank slate to make new and more interesting characters. However developers are too scared to do that. SO they continue games without a real reason.
 

Fightgarr

Concept Artist
Dec 3, 2008
2,913
0
0
pimppeter2 said:
Pete, I'ma stop you there because we're arguing the same point here. We just focused on different aspects of it. No point in arguing if we agree, eh?
 

Vern

New member
Sep 19, 2008
1,302
0
0
Quake needs a sequal, a real one. Not this space marines and cyborg bullshit. A real remake with decaying castles, submersed cities, gothic cathedrals, and Lovecraftian horrors. Shamblers and Fiends are still two of the most frightening enemies I've ever seen in a game, they need a comeback.
 

RUINER ACTUAL

New member
Oct 29, 2009
1,835
0
0
No more:
music games.
wii games.
EA (shit-quality) games.
DLC sold as a game.

---------------------

Games to make sequal / make the game:
MechAssault/MechWarrior
Hawx (maybe)
Ghost Recon
Call of Duty: Vietnam (?)
More good PSP games

SOMEONE PUBLISH "SIX DAYS IN FALLUJAH" !!!!
 

KamachoMcSagget

New member
Mar 22, 2009
525
0
0
Silent Hill shattered memmories should get one because the gameplay is sometimes intresting and othertimes frustrating, but overall it's INTERESTING. Duke Nukem also really needs a new game~
 

SantoUno

New member
Aug 13, 2009
2,583
0
0
Why, the fuck, didn't Bioware release a sequel to KOTOR 2 already? Who honestly cares about a KOTOR-type MMO? I mean it's an MMO...
 

Pimppeter2

New member
Dec 31, 2008
16,479
0
0
Fightgarr said:
pimppeter2 said:
Pete, I'ma stop you there because we're arguing the same point here. We just focused on different aspects of it. No point in arguing if we agree, eh?
Did I come off Defensive? Sorry about that. I honestly didn't mean to.

That was what I was trying to point out. That we were talking about the same thing. Sorry if I sounded harsh, while I was writing I didn't that I did. I might be grumpy from writing this review [http://www.escapistmagazine.com/forums/read/326.163876] and all that coffee I drank
/shameless plug