What is the Best and Worst Video Game Company?

Recommended Videos

GrizzlerBorno

New member
Sep 2, 2010
2,295
0
0
Obligatory Bioware, but followed VERY closely by Valve in Second Place. (Ubisoft Montreal in third, I'd say) They all make good games and are pleasantly consistent.
Also, one more dev that I'll mention because a lot of people won't: Rocksteady. Because Arkham Asylum was just DAMN good.

As for worst: Do Activision make any games themselves? If so, them. If not.....worst publishers?

EDIT: And will someone PLEASE mention Team ICO already?! It's been what 40 posts and NO-ONE mentions the creators of the crown jewels of the game-as-art debate? I would but I've never played either game.
 

GonzoGamer

New member
Apr 9, 2008
7,063
0
0
My favorite is probably Q Games. No real big budget titles but their games are always polished, trippy, and fun. I'm really looking forward to Children of Eden.

Worst? I don't know. Maybe Capcom for their absurd dlc decisions and title milking: how many more versions of RE5 & SF4 will they try and sell us and how many costume packs can they try and sell for each one. Activision and Grasshopper (maybe Shadows of the Damned will redeem them) come close.

I can't say Bioware is the worst but they are probably the most overrated: I play their games on the PC too so I'm seeing their best.
 

GeorgW

ALL GLORY TO ME!
Aug 27, 2010
4,806
0
0
GrizzlerBorno said:
Obligatory Bioware, but followed VERY closely by Valve in Second Place. (Ubisoft Montreal in third, I'd say) They all make good games and are pleasantly consistent.
Also, one more dev that I'll mention because a lot of people won't: Rocksteady. Because Arkham Asylum was just DAMN good.

As for worst: Do Activision make any games themselves? If so, them. If not.....worst publishers?

EDIT: And will someone PLEASE mention Team ICO already?! It's been what 40 posts and NO-ONE mentions the creators of the crown jewels of the game-as-art debate? I would but I've never played either game.
I already beat you to rocksteady, I agree, they've only made one game as far as I know, but it was still one of the best games I've ever played.
Activision doesn't make games, that would be horrible.
I thought about ICO, but I haven't played any of their games. Same reason I didn't mention ubisoft montreal, blizzard, irrational and rockstar. Seriously, why haven't anyone mentioned Blizzard yet???
 

GeorgW

ALL GLORY TO ME!
Aug 27, 2010
4,806
0
0
The_Fezz said:
Best for me would probably be Naughty Dog and Insomniac, worst would have to be everyone's favourite sports game loving, originality shunning EA games.
Tenkage said:
Tell me what company do you trust to make your games and what do you not. For best, I want to say its a tie for Bestheda thanks to their always awesome RPGs and Bioware, for the same reason, for worst....EA.

They remake the same sports crap which I think should just be DLC. They did that bull with charging people for demos. And lets face it, their games aren't doing well
People, please learn the difference between EA games, EA sports and EA partners. Cuz EA partners is the best publisher IMO, and I'm sure you would agree. EA partners publish games like the orange box, portal 2, the mass effects, the battlefields and a hell of a lot more awesome games. EA sports are crap. So, yeah, difference!
 

shreedder

New member
May 19, 2009
179
0
0
I'm going have to say the best is Blizzard. They take a damn long time to make their games, but they do a great job, and are always trying to fix them... Just can we please have Diablo 3 in my lifetime, thank you.
 

RA92

New member
Jan 1, 2011
3,079
0
0
Does no one remember... Psygnosis?

I mean, the company might be dead for what it's worth, but it did give us some of the best titles in the '90s... Lemmings, WipeOut, The Sentinel, Rollcage, Destruction Derby, G-Police, Assault Rigs... Hell, I still remember being blown away by the art style, environment and soundtracks of WipeOut 2097, or the creepiness of The Sentinel Returns. Plus, even now, it has the greatest logo ever (designed by Roger Dean, nonetheless: http://www.psygnosis.org/artifacts/psyglogo2.jpg )

Well, I guess the best has to be Valve for me right now. I know a lot of people are pissed about their release dates, but for me, it's the opposite: it juxtaposes beautifully with the rush a lot of developers are forced into by their publishers. Plus, they're an indie developer, and don't make stupid mistakes that publishers force on developers (I'm looking at your push to productivity, Bobby Fucking Cottick).

The worst, hands down, is Zynga. I know, I know, I shouldn't even acknowledged them as a game development company, but the world of economics goes against me. What ticked me off was the fact that Gamasutra made Zynga no.1 in 2009's top 5 game companies. And the worst part: they made sense.

Here's what they wrote:


"Of course, the shining star of performance this year has been Zynga -- the company which rode the social gaming trend to the top of the revenue heap, creating the most popular games on Facebook and reaping the microtransaction-based rewards.

Sure, plenty of people don't like to hear it. There's the obvious and disheartening question of the fact that the company's games are largely unoriginal from both a design and theme perspective. So goes the trope: Harvest Moon begat Happy Farm begat Farm Town became FarmVille -- a copy of a copy of a copy. And there's no doubt that the company's strength in marketing is what has drawn players to its particular executions of popular social gaming themes.

But execution is not to be underestimated, says Zynga VP Hugh de Loayza: "Our games are pretty distinctively different from the traditional Asian farm games. A shooter is a shooter, so a harvest mechanic is a harvest mechanic. But the story you wrap around it is different. The other thing to pay attention to is that you've got a service that you're running." It's obvious the company is doing something right with its generic-seeming games. And there's more to the service than strongarm user acquisition tactics -- though they're indubitably a key part of the strategy.

And there's no doubt that this rapid growth has caused some growing pains -- unethical offers got FishVille banned from Facebook, though the game did come back.

But the company has managed to attract great talent from the traditional games space, and secure secure significant funding, no small feat in today's economic climate.

Yes, people love to hate Zynga and the social games market (check the comments on that last link.) And that hate is comprehensible. But Zynga proves that, in the short time since the phenomenon has emerged, a business can be built on it. While we can never say "yes, this one will be a long-term success," Zynga is the power player in the market and the absolute company to watch out for, and is also one of the most meaningful and disruptive success stories of 2009."

(Full article: http://www.gamasutra.com/view/news/26243/Gamasutras_Best_Of_2009_Top_5_Game_Companies.php)

Thus, we're now being forced to acknowledge this... looming monstrosity, flanked by a million horde of undead social network abusers...

*COCKS SHOTGUN*
 

Jason Danger Keyes

New member
Mar 4, 2009
518
0
0
lacktheknack said:
ShredHexus said:
The worst is one that you nor I have or ever will hear of, being so bad their game never gets made.
Actually, their name is "Stellar Stone", and they made <link=http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Big_Rigs:_Over_the_Road_Racing>this.

Edit:
Arisato-kun said:
As for worst I'll go with Stellar Stone. They made Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing.
DRATTED NINJAAAAAAAS!
As appallingly bad as that game was, it at least made up for it with the joke value and infamy. Some shitty companies don't even get that much recognition, and no press is bad press.
 

GeorgW

ALL GLORY TO ME!
Aug 27, 2010
4,806
0
0
Aura Guardian said:
Best for me...Nintendo,Treasure,Grasshopper,Rareware,HAL Laboratory,Capcom,Retro Studios,Bungie,SEGA
In the middle...High Voltage Software,Treyarch,Taito,From Software,Square Enix,Vanillaware,Namco,Aksys,Temco,Midway,EA,Epic Games
Worst...Bioware,Valve,Bandai,Rare,2k,Rockstar,BandaiNamco,Team ICO,Lucasarts

I know there's more. As soon as I can think of them. And it's not in order...well...maybe the best is
Wow, you and I have pretty opposing tastes. Would you mind qualifying some of your opinions? Specifically why Bioware, Valve, 2k, rockstar and ICO are in your worst list?
 

Chibz

New member
Sep 12, 2008
2,158
0
0
Best: Nippon Ichi. They produce some of the funniest & best tactical JRPGs known to man.

Worst: Valve. Shoddy, half-assed shooters (See: Half-life), shoddy gimmicky games (See: Portal) and shooters ported to console with zero local multiplayer (See: TF2). Unforgivable.

veloper said:
Worst of the big names: Capcom. Sloppy coding and poor polish shouldn't be possible for a Japanese developer. Weak support doesn't help. The final nail is a weak line-up of games.
Weak line-up of games?! Mega man and monster hunter are "bad"? I was too busy playing the best run & shoot games, along with the best series of action RPGs to notice.
 

RA92

New member
Jan 1, 2011
3,079
0
0
GrizzlerBorno said:
And will someone PLEASE mention Team ICO already?! It's been what 40 posts and NO-ONE mentions the creators of the crown jewels of the game-as-art debate? I would but I've never played either game.
Even more surprising is the lack of mention of Nin-ten-DO'H!... I mean, SOMEONE has to put them in the best/worst (both equally fair) category. I refuse to... but, seriously people! Nintendo, for chrissake, has been around since 1889, making hanafuda cards and love hotels!
 

GrizzlerBorno

New member
Sep 2, 2010
2,295
0
0
Raiyan 1.0 said:
Even more surprising is the lack of mention of Nin-ten-DO'H!... I mean, SOMEONE has to put them in the best/worst (both equally fair) category. I refuse to... but, seriously people! Nintendo, for chrissake, has been around since 1889, making hanafuda cards and love hotels!
Why'd you quote me? I don't really play Nintendo games at all. You know this.
Besides they should be appreciated for their hardware ingenuity, not their game quality... which is fine, but not "best" by a long shot.
 

Aura Guardian

New member
Apr 23, 2008
5,114
0
0
GeorgW said:
Aura Guardian said:
Best for me...Nintendo,Treasure,Grasshopper,Rareware,HAL Laboratory,Capcom,Retro Studios,Bungie,SEGA
In the middle...High Voltage Software,Treyarch,Taito,From Software,Square Enix,Vanillaware,Namco,Aksys,Temco,Midway,EA,Epic Games
Worst...Bioware,Valve,Bandai,Rare,2k,Rockstar,BandaiNamco,Team ICO,Lucasarts

I know there's more. As soon as I can think of them. And it's not in order...well...maybe the best is
Wow, you and I have pretty opposing tastes. Would you mind qualifying some of your opinions? Specifically why Bioware, Valve, 2k, rockstar and ICO are in your worst list?
I'll try...but in these type of threads that appear...repeating myself gets a bit annoying.

Bioware..Aside from Jade Empire(Very underrated) I wasn't too fond of their RPGS. The gameplay was ok and the story in Mass Effect bored me.
Valve..Aside from Team Fortress 2, most of their games are vastly overrated. Portal and half life come to mind. Didn't like them. The humor in Portal wasn't funny(as well as the internet killed the jokes) Half-life's story wasn't that good.
2K-Bioshock and Boardlands come to mind. Bioshock's atmosphere was nice...the story...not so much. Boardlands I couldn't get into.
Rockstar...I should probably change that to "in the middle" Looking back at Bully for the Wii and GTA 4. But Red Dead Redemption I hated...It'll probably be replaced with the folks that made Little Big Planet.
ICO...Shadow of the Colossus comes to mind. As it's one of my most hated games. I don't mind artsy games as long as I find them enjoyable...I didn't with SotC.
 

GeorgW

ALL GLORY TO ME!
Aug 27, 2010
4,806
0
0
Raiyan 1.0 said:
GrizzlerBorno said:
And will someone PLEASE mention Team ICO already?! It's been what 40 posts and NO-ONE mentions the creators of the crown jewels of the game-as-art debate? I would but I've never played either game.
Even more surprising is the lack of mention of Nin-ten-DO'H!... I mean, SOMEONE has to put them in the best/worst (both equally fair) category. I refuse to... but, seriously people! Nintendo, for chrissake, has been around since 1889, making hanafuda cards and love hotels!
I thought about them too, but they're too ambiguous. Are they console maker, a publisher or a developer? And if it's all of them, then they've made too much to be classified as either best or worst. For every mario there will be a virtua boy.
 

RA92

New member
Jan 1, 2011
3,079
0
0
GeorgW said:
Aura Guardian said:
Best for me...Nintendo,Treasure,Grasshopper,Rareware,HAL Laboratory,Capcom,Retro Studios,Bungie,SEGA
In the middle...High Voltage Software,Treyarch,Taito,From Software,Square Enix,Vanillaware,Namco,Aksys,Temco,Midway,EA,Epic Games
Worst...Bioware,Valve,Bandai,Rare,2k,Rockstar,BandaiNamco,Team ICO,Lucasarts

I know there's more. As soon as I can think of them. And it's not in order...well...maybe the best is
Wow, you and I have pretty opposing tastes. Would you mind qualifying some of your opinions? Specifically why Bioware, Valve, 2k, rockstar and ICO are in your worst list?
Let me qualify on Aura Guardian's behalf: "I'd rather drone through another Pokemon game with another 500 monsters, repetitive Mario remakes, and another rape from Squeenix rather than being confronted by something that challenges conventions (Shadow of the Colossus), has a refreshing narrative device and original game mechaics (Portal), treats writing as an integral part of the game (Mass Effect), takes gaming to the next level (GTA, LA Noire) and generally creates the most entertaining environments (Grim Fandago, Lego Star Wars)."

Trollface off/
 

Ian Meier

New member
Oct 18, 2010
11
0
0
Best Publisher I would say is Blizzard they always make great quality games the worst is a tie between Activision (Bunch of babies with Infinty Ward) and EA (I'm still steamed about EA's handling of Medal of Honor)
 

Shock and Awe

Winter is Coming
Sep 6, 2008
4,647
0
0
Best: Either Bioware or Bungie. Both make awesome games, though I tend to go with Bungie because of there dedication to fans.

Worst: LJN.....yes they still count.
 

Jazoni89

New member
Dec 24, 2008
3,059
0
0
My favourite companies are Naughty dog, Gearbox, Rare (pre Xbox), Monolith, Quantic Dream, Retro studio's, and Obsidian. Mainly because above all else they are all passionate at what they do, and for me that is more important than anything else.

The worst companies in gaming have to be EA, Activision, Ubisoft and THQ for being the cash cow money grabbers that they are. Plus many of the games those companies put out, im not interested in the slightest.

I do like Bethesda, but Zenimax ltd is ruled by some of the biggest idiots, and the most big headed dickheads in the industry.

Sega and Square used to be great companies, but after the two got mergers (Sega/Sammy Square/Enix) they lost all meaning to make a decent game.

Valve is a okay company, but they tend to be very dickish to their loyal fanbase.
 

RA92

New member
Jan 1, 2011
3,079
0
0
Chibz said:
Best: Nippon Ichi. They produce some of the funniest & best tactical JRPGs known to man.

Worst: Valve. Shoddy, half-assed shooters (See: Half-life), shoddy gimmicky games (See: Portal) and shooters ported to console with zero local multiplayer (See: TF2). Unforgivable.

Care to explain how Half-Life was shoddy? Considering it had a five year development cycle and took $40 million, won 39 Game of the Year awards for its advanced physics, animation, sound, AI, rendering, and narrative, what caught your eyes that the entire gaming community missed? And I don't think you quite understand what the term 'gimmick' means. Portal was never aimed to be a mass-marketed title - it was a small, free game that came with the Orange Box. The enthusiasm surrounding it was purely generated by the gamers themselves due to the uniqueness of the title. And care to share any experience of the game (bugs, mechanics, etc) which contributed to your opinion of it being 'shoddy'?

Perhaps it's because Valve titles lack the gimmicky cutscenes and trailers with graphics far removed from gameplay that has been a must-have for JRPGs for quite some time?