What makes a man a Man?

Recommended Videos

latenightapplepie

New member
Nov 9, 2008
3,086
0
0
AngloDoom said:
You must be swift as a cour-sing ri-ver!
With all the force of a great ty-phoon!
With all the strength of a rag-ing fi-re!
Mysterious as
the dark side of
the moo-oon!
Best answer so far. Man, I love Disney a little bit too much.

OT: Who cares? It seems to be in a permanent state of flux, I almost couldn't be bothered following it anymore. That's not to say it doesn't affect me, just that I doesn't affect me too much. To many, by being gay I can't be a 'man', and that suits me just fine, 'cos then I can be whatever the hell I want.
 

Jonathan Wingo

New member
Mar 30, 2010
95
0
0
Cowabungaa said:
Vanguard_Ex said:
A man is someone who meets a nice girl and helps her. He erases her insecurities, he makes her feel loved when no one else will even talk to her, he supports her when things get tough. He starts a family with her, and provides this girl and his kids with not just emotional support, but financial support, gives them a shelter over their heads and puts food on the table. He protects them, from bullies and poverty alike. That, that is a man, in my opinion.
So a man who takes care of his family, as in takes care of the household etc etc, while his wife brings in the money is not a man?
Traditionally, men have been the providers, ever since the days when providing for your family meant building a house by hand and going out to hunt and kill animals to keep your family alive. Nothing wrong with a man taking care of the house, but it's not very manly to do that. It'd be more manly to go out and give your wife the easier job(yes, easier job, is it really hard to cook, pickup after yourself and others, and things of that nature?) rather than making your wife work her ass off to support the family with the financial needs? Not saying that women can't do that, but traditionally, the men have been the ones to go out, work hard, get food, and let the wife have the easier job of cleaning and cooking. It's called being chivalrous.
 

Galletea

Inexplicably Awesome
Sep 27, 2008
2,877
0
0
Being a man is about having the XY chromosomes and having gone through puberty. All this bullshit about "real men" and "making a man out of you" is just that; utter bullshit. If you're a coward who'd rather make someone else take the fall for your actions then you're a douchebag, but you'd still be a man. All this about being a real man gets on my nerves.
 

Vanguard_Ex

New member
Mar 19, 2008
4,687
0
0
Cowabungaa said:
Vanguard_Ex said:
A man is someone who meets a nice girl and helps her. He erases her insecurities, he makes her feel loved when no one else will even talk to her, he supports her when things get tough. He starts a family with her, and provides this girl and his kids with not just emotional support, but financial support, gives them a shelter over their heads and puts food on the table. He protects them, from bullies and poverty alike. That, that is a man, in my opinion.
So a man who takes care of his family, as in takes care of the household etc etc, while his wife brings in the money is not a man?
No, because he doesn't need to do every single one of those things at once. A person without an arm is still a person.
 

SextusMaximus

Nightingale Assassin
May 20, 2009
3,508
0
0
In a certain african tribe, a boy must wear a glove made out of venomous ants (with stingers pointed inwards) for 10 minutes. Then repeat that another 19 times.
 

AVATAR_RAGE

New member
May 28, 2009
1,120
0
0
A man is not afraid to stand up for/protect the ones he loves and his beliefs. A man is not is not forcful unless provoked, willing to help others and is always honest.

Thats what makes a man, a man and not another male.

The are too many males in this world and not enough men.

Just because a guy acts tough doesn't make him more of a man, infact it makes him less of one.
And im sure if i still had a beard, it would agree with me as well :D
 

Cowabungaa

New member
Feb 10, 2008
10,806
0
0
Vanguard_Ex said:
No, because he doesn't need to do every single one of those things at once. A person without an arm is still a person.
Then we're on the same page here. *high fives*

Actually, I find it quite brave, men who challenge the usual stereotype of being the breadwinner and taking direct care of his family instead.
SextusMaximus said:
In a certain african tribe, a boy must wear a glove made out of venomous ants (with stingers pointed inwards) for 10 minutes. Then repeat that another 19 times.
That would be the Satere Mawe tribe [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Satere-Mawe] from Brazil, not Africa. Many of those native tribes on all continents have some pretty insane initiation rites.
 

radred

New member
Jul 7, 2009
83
0
0
does it really matter
who cares if your a "MAN" or not
it shouldn't matter whether you are a boy/man/girl/woman
its your intellect, morals and personal beliefs that people should judge you on
 

Polyg0n

New member
Jul 16, 2009
304
0
0
For me it`s someone who is independent, always ready to stand up for others and never breaks his word. Age or being a virgin are things that don`t matter.
 

jultub

New member
Jan 18, 2010
451
0
0
Cpt_Oblivious said:
Well according to Bioshock it's..
Choice - "A Man chooses, a slave obeys"
I'd say that actually is my opinion of it.

A boy makes choices solely on what certain figures of authourity tells him to,or he does them completely on impulse and without any sort of thinking behind them.

He grows to be a man when he makes his choices and stands for the consequences of them, when he no longer sees "I'm sorry" as a way out of the trouble, and when he no longer tries to blame others for his own mistakes.
 

Uncreation

New member
Aug 4, 2009
476
0
0
Jonathan Wingo said:
Traditionally, men have been the providers, ever since the days when providing for your family meant building a house by hand and going out to hunt and kill animals to keep your family alive.
Traditions change. Its a good thing they do, or else society wouldn't really progress.

Jonathan Wingo said:
Nothing wrong with a man taking care of the house, but it's not very manly to do that.
Says who?

Jonathan Wingo said:
It'd be more manly to go out and give your wife the easier job(yes, easier job, is it really hard to cook, pickup after yourself and others, and things of that nature?) rather than making your wife work her ass off to support the family with the financial needs? Not saying that women can't do that, but traditionally, the men have been the ones to go out, work hard, get food, and let the wife have the easier job of cleaning and cooking. It's called being chivalrous.
You might be surprised but taking care of the house work, is not as easy as you might think. And i don't think chivalry is what comes to my mind when someone let's his wife do the housekeeping because "it's easier". Nevermind.

On topic, though: being a man is a pretty vague concept. Through different times and societies it has had different meanings. In my opinion every guy has to decide for himself what he wants to be like. There is no clear cut recipe.
To me at least part of that is not letting other people tell you how to behave and being who you want to be without hurting other people, among other things.
 

Gethsemani_v1legacy

New member
Oct 1, 2009
2,552
0
0
Jonathan Wingo said:
Traditionally, men have been the providers, ever since the days when providing for your family meant building a house by hand and going out to hunt and kill animals to keep your family alive. Nothing wrong with a man taking care of the house, but it's not very manly to do that. It'd be more manly to go out and give your wife the easier job(yes, easier job, is it really hard to cook, pickup after yourself and others, and things of that nature?) rather than making your wife work her ass off to support the family with the financial needs? Not saying that women can't do that, but traditionally, the men have been the ones to go out, work hard, get food, and let the wife have the easier job of cleaning and cooking. It's called being chivalrous.
I could just troll you and say "What a fantastically 19th century mindset you have". It would be unproductive though, so I am going to develop my stance a little more than that, even if that is the gist of it.

First of all, the whole "the man has always been the provider for 'his' women" is a myth that was thrown about 19th century Victorian England to help repress women during the industrial revolution. Historically, women have helped their husbands in whatever profession they have had. From working on the farm to helping out in the blacksmith or the market, women have had to work just as much as their husbands (or fathers) to provide for the family.
Or how do you suppose that unmarried maidens and widows survived? By the gracious generosity of the society and welfare laws? No, they worked. In fact, most widows carried on their husbands profession in his stead if he passed on early.
How do you suppose that women survived in times of war? They worked their behinds off to cover for the absence of their husbands (this is especially true for peasants since they were also expected to provide more food to the war effort).

That taking care of the home is easier is also a misconception, as I think anyone who's ever spent time only taking care of the home can attest. Especially when you add in half a dozen kids into the equation along with responsibility for the economy and all the other chores.

I am sorry, but your idea of what is "a mans duty" is based in a myth created to repress women. So what makes a man a man? I would dare say that it isn't that he "provides for his family" because the whole concept of the classical family is as dated as the century in which it was created.

Today, I think that man and woman are concepts that sociologically are cracking and fading. Just be who you want to be, because living by someone elses definition won't make you happy.
 

Vanguard_Ex

New member
Mar 19, 2008
4,687
0
0
Cowabungaa said:
Vanguard_Ex said:
No, because he doesn't need to do every single one of those things at once. A person without an arm is still a person.
Then we're on the same page here. *high fives*

Actually, I find it quite brave, men who challenge the usual stereotype of being the breadwinner and taking direct care of his family instead.
Awesome :) Yeah I know it can be construed as sexist but, I see the man as the guardian.