Arqus_Zed said:
It's like comparing Shadow Hearts with Lucifer's Call.
[/spoiler]
Shin Megami Tensei: Lucifers Call (Nocturne in some regions) had a much better recruitment drive (Hi, random enemy, do you want to live? Join me

! )
Saying that Shadow Hearts took a lot of the 'mash attack' out of gringing low-level areas with the judgement ring (which was improved in Shadow Hearts: Covenant by the simple act of allowing you to customise it)
The magic is pretty much the same in both games. (in SH everyone but Yuri got them by Lvl up, and he got them by Lvling his Demons (Transformations) and in SMT:LC everyone but Protaganist got them by level up, and he got them by Lvling his Demons (parasites))
Sorry couldn't help it.
On topic, however, I prefered the Charicters from 10, the Open-World exploration/size of 6, the 'Enemies gain levels at the same rate as you' from 8 The story from 4, Magic system of 7 and Combat Flow of 10-2. Overall though, 6 is, in my opinion, marginilly better than the other games in the series.
Suprising no-one mentioned the RPG dungeon on the Playstation port of Ehrgeiz yet.
On the point of Villains, In 6 Kefka was mad, In 7 Sephiroth was Sadistic, In 4 they pull the same thing as they would later do in 8 Just the Edea/Ultamecia being replaced by Golbez/(cant remember the name) which was shocking in 4, but by the time 8 came round we were just dissapointed in Square for the blatant copy-paste. Necron (FF9) came out of nowhere too (literally) but I saw him more as a tool used by Kuja than as a villain. 10 and 10-2 aren't even worth mentioning, beyond the fact that in both cases 1000 years is way to long to hold a grudge. Ultimacia had the grandest plan (destroy the world AND destroy time so I can destroy the world again in the past and beat myself to it!) but Kefka losses points for taking so long. (Most FF villains have wanted to destroy the world, right the way from Garland in FF1, but Kefka had a whole year with no opposition and STILL failed. Ooooh, godlike power + want to destroy . . . why does he even wait for an excuse to blow people/towns up?)
Incidentilly, My first RPG was FF7. My favorite RPG is Star Ocean:TTEOT, then SMT:Lucifers Call, followed by Digital Devil Saga, then Tales of Symphonia, then Shadow Hearts: Covenant THEN FF6.
Another good one that hovers at about the same level as FF6 and Shadow Hearts: Covenant is Breath of Fire: Dragon Quarter (BoF5).