What's with Americans and getting married?

Recommended Videos

Brutal Peanut

This is so freakin aweso-BLARGH!
Oct 15, 2010
1,770
0
0
I am twenty-three, and my Husband is thirty. We've been together since I was nineteen. That drives some people crazy, even here in the States. But I also hadn't lived with my parents from sixteen on, I have had jobs and responsibilities, and even lived on my own. We were friends first, gamed together, and then started seeing each other after we ended up fooling around one evening. We were together for three years, moved into our house, before HE brought up marriage and it wasn't on a whim. We talked about it a lot, at least six months before he 'popped the question'. I also wanted to make sure he was asking me because he wanted to, not because he felt pressured by any family members. Mine or his.

What would each expect from each other after the papers were signed? We went over our future plans again and asked would this marriage conflict with our separate future ideals or goals? Why did he feel he needed to ask me? Would I say yes, and why? Did he feel this was something he HAD to do because he believed in God? We also talked about the legal benefits of marriage. That the marriage license isn't about the romantic part of your relationship or marriage, but it works as a legal document forcing the government and certain companies (insurance, work , hospitals) to see you as a committed couple and forces them to give you the benefits that they provide.

We also have no plans on having ANY children. We both have mental issues in our family lines (one quite severe) and feel that it would be irresponsible to bring a child into the world to suffer with those disabilities , and we both don't feel we are even close to emotionally ready to handle a child. So we didn't get married to strictly have babies. We also don't do everything together. If he wants to go out to eat and I don't, he just goes out to eat. If I want to go shopping and he doesn't want to tag along, I don't nag him, I just go shopping and enjoy my afternoon. You are still two separate people with your hobbies, little joys, and alone time. If you feel tied down, married or not, something isn't right.


Our friends aren't married and have been with their partners for 5+ years, and no one gives them any grief.

My Dad and his girlfriend have been living together for a few years, with no talk of marriage.

My aunt is nearly sixty now, and unmarried, without a partner. I don't particularly like her as a person, but her personal life is never a topic of gossipy conversation.

My sister was just married yesterday at thirty-three (already has a child to someone she wasn't married to), her husband is forty and had a vasectomy.

My other sister is a couple years from forty, one child from a 10 year relationship that fell apart, with no plans to ever get married and definitely not to have anymore children. I don't even think she's dating. And no one treats her as if she's anything other then human.

It may seem like everyone and their dog in the States is praying to Jesus, getting married and squirting out ten children apiece, but that isn't actually reality.

Honestly, a lot of people, even outside the U.S., get married for the wrong reasons. They want instant gratification and for a perfect relationship or marriage to just be provided for them through the marriage license and that's not how it works - at all. They treat marriage AND divorce like a easy way out (or so they think) of all their problems. When a majority of those problems stem from the inside and marriage just projected those problems onto their partner and/or children. Even after the divorce, you still have your problems. That is something for you to fix, not your partner.

But as to some of these responses to your questions and comments, not everyone is 'dumb', 'naive', 'immature', or a 'religious zealot' - when they do. Just because it is unfortunately abused, doesn't make it any less important to those that didn't do it for petty reasons. It's a life choice that should be respected just like any other life choice. To be single, to have a partner and not be married, to have multiple partners who work together like a big family, etc. I support all of these choices, and wish them the best.
 

I Have No Idea

New member
Aug 5, 2011
558
0
0
jeremysaint said:
why does marriage continue to exist at all? it adds nothing to a relationship but potentially terrible long term costs, and the actual marriage and marriage license costs money too. seriously, why does this anachronistic institution continue to exist?
Because when people love each other very much and they believe that they're meant to stay together 'till death, then they get married. They tie the knot, and they're making a commitment to one another. I take it you're a misanthrope?
 

DisturbiaWolf13

New member
Apr 15, 2009
146
0
0
TestECull said:
DisturbiaWolf13 said:
Why bother getting married? Can anyone give me a good reason?
If one party has shit credit but the other has good credit it can mean the difference between rolling around in a half-dead Geo Metro and rolling around in a nice car. So there's that. On top of that you get, as already mentioned, tax breaks 'n shit, not to mention a whole slew of other rights I can't name because I'm no lawyer.


In short: Why not get married? If you're committed enough to someone that you want to spend the rest of your years with them a legal document isn't going to change anything in that regard, and it gives both of you a break financially. It also means, and this is quite relavent given the shit nature of the economy right now, that if you lose your job and can't obtain one right away you don't end up sleeping in your car.
Ok. Those are good logical reasons. To be honest I was expecting somebody to start throwing dogma in my general direction. But it still seems like those are all intentional incentives thrown in to encourage people to do it. You are right about those though, I was complaning more about how some people treat it as a moral goal for a long term relationship. On reflection that wasn't clear.
 

FreakSheet

New member
Jul 16, 2011
389
0
0
DisturbiaWolf13 said:
FreakSheet said:
ripdajacker said:
If I was to get married today I would feel tied down for no reason. I don't want to sound like a prick, but don't guys realize their potential as males?
Sorry, but as it turns out, not all people are only interested in sex approaching infinity, with partners approaching infinity. People get divorced because they either didn't love each other to begin with (ie they thought that they were marrying someone hot, now they're not) or the second it gets too hard they bail since its so easy. The concept of instant gratification doesn't apply to marriage, and that makes people think its a waste of time.

Hopefully though, the people that do have sexual relationships approaching infinity don't have kids and this way of thinking will die out.
See now that's what annoys me. Why is marriage often treated as the final destination for a loving relationship? Why bother getting married? Can anyone give me a good reason?
Well, in my opinion, if you aren't ready or mature enough to make a commitment to one person for the rest of your life, how can you be ready to have kids? Something I would argue as a larger commitment than marriage. You want to raise kids in a good home, and if you are bed hopping with a bunch of people, chances are the child will suffer from not having a mother or father figure in their life if its always changing.
 

Ritter315

New member
Jan 10, 2010
112
0
0
I think the entire answer can be summed up with this: "If I was to get married today I would feel tied down for no reason. I don't want to sound like a prick, but don't guys realize their potential as males? Sure there are some relationships that are meant to last, but getting married before your education is finished AND before your career has begun just seems like a stupid idea" - Americans for a large percentage do NOT believe this. More and more of the world's Western, comfortable, spoiled because they never had to work a day in their lives and were able to go to college, get a job and support themselves on the merits of their forebarers who they could give a shit about...ARGH! I apologize for that rant.

In all honesty it comes from a moral ideal that marriage is a sacred institution and being "pinned down" is really more or less a myth. Marriage offers several benefits that are often overlooked and that 40% divorce rate is a load of crock! The reason I say that is because what that statistic never factors in are more than 1 time divorces. As in, if a person gets divorced five times (Even if its to the same person) that counts towards the percentage so it looks like a lot more people are getting divorced that actual are getting divorced and despite what sitcoms try and say to us married people have A LOT more sex than single people.

It boggles my mind at the idea that marriage is or will someday be looked at with complete contempt and for baseless reasons none the less.

Also I dont mean to be rude but "but don't guys realize their potential as males?" - Grow up serious. If someone needs to base their success on how many or how beautiful a women they can get than society and moral reasoning have truely failed. Males should base their potential on their job, to support a family. This isnt just from a moral point of view but from a social, economic and natural standard as well.
We live to support ourselves, so that we can one day support a family, so we can work and have children to support the economy of the country (community or the like)we live in, and in turn keep the world turning.

At the end of the day, without any moral or philosophical justification (Potential counts in this category) that is what the meaning of life as it stands is and marrige is a part of that because its easier to support children and make better children married than single.
 

ripdajacker

Code Monkey
Oct 25, 2009
134
0
0
Thomas Guy said:
ripdajacker said:
Go ahead with your whatever. I am 26, been married for 7 years, have 3 kids and am perfectly happy.
I am not stating that there aren't relationships where this couldn't happen. I am just saying I haven't found anyone I would remotely consider as a future spouse, even the ex that I dated for almost three years.

The choice of sitcoms as an example may have been flawed at best, but I still believe the "get married, have kids" message is radiating throughout the American productions that see European soil.

The benefits of marriage in Denmark are, to my knowledge, minor unless you have children. Then it gets easier, but not vital. I know people who've been together for 20-30 years and THEN decided to marry.

Marriage seems to me only to be paperwork. A title and a document coupled with a ring symbolizing you have a wife. I do believe in love between two people, but marriage just seems like... overkill.
 

Xeraxis

New member
Aug 7, 2011
178
0
0
Living in America so long, even I don't get why marriage is such a big deal. As if you're not married by, say, 25, your life sucks or something. I guess it has to do with better financial/miscellaneous benefits.
 

Ace of Spades

New member
Jul 12, 2008
3,303
0
0
To be perfectly honest, I'm a bit fed up with the blatant demonizing of marriage I've seen all my life. Yes, I would spend many years laying the ground work before getting married, but are we really all so jaded that we can't conceive of the possibility of loving someone enough that you want to merge your life with theirs? I see my mom and dad, and all the running jokes they made before I was born, and I think,'I want to have that some day. To have someone who understands all the little jokes we made.' Maybe I'm naive, but I don't believe that's just a remnant of a bygone age of religious fanaticism.
 

bootz

New member
Feb 28, 2011
366
0
0
harmonic said:
balol said:
Some people do it because of the whole "No-sex-till-married" religious garbage that their parents will beat the fuck out of and disown them. That is a very large, unfortunate problem in America. Dunno bout Europe.
The hell are you talking about? That might happen once in a blue moon. And only in very select parts of the deep, deep south. Stop your exaggerating.
I live in Pennsylvania. I dated at least 2 girls with this happening to them. The one wanted to get married just so she could have sex without her family shunning her. Hell her Dad who was a Catholic married a protesant girl and his family shunned him for it. Its silly seeing religion tearing families apart. My ex-girlfriend wasn't invited to her cousins wedding and hurt because her mom was protestant.
I'm pretty much an athiest and didn't realize the power religion has until I saw this.

The other girl got caught having sex and got kicked out of her house with nothing.
It happens everyday all over america. An unmarried woman having sex is still someone you just cast away to avoid being emmbarassed.
 

JambalayaBob

New member
Dec 11, 2010
109
0
0
cyrogeist said:
well America is having a economy problem...so having two people who make money is a good way to make sure you still have a home in the morning also your thoughts about america come from TV shows...really? thats kind of stupid
Are you shitting me? I really hope you're joking about this. The entire WORLD is having economic problems, and that doesn't even make sense as a valid excuse in the first place. It's not like the government's rewards for marriage are so great that you'll die if you don't get married for no good reason. If you can't pay the bills and need to live with somebody else, it's called a room mate for fuck's sake!
 

Naal

New member
Feb 24, 2009
92
0
0
To me it's a spiritual bond. Marriage is not one of those things you just 'do' because it can be convenient or you have warm tinglies. It's something that is NOT easy and requires a lot of constant work, but the person you're with has to be your best friend.

I don't want to jump on my soap box, so I'll stop here.
 

ripdajacker

Code Monkey
Oct 25, 2009
134
0
0
Ace of Spades said:
(...) I'm a bit fed up with the blatant demonizing of marriage I've seen all my life. Yes, I would spend many years laying the ground work before getting married, but are we really all so jaded that we can't conceive of the possibility of loving someone enough that you want to merge your life with theirs?
I am not trying to demonize marriage, I am just trying to understand what the pressure is all about.
 

DisturbiaWolf13

New member
Apr 15, 2009
146
0
0
FreakSheet said:
DisturbiaWolf13 said:
FreakSheet said:
ripdajacker said:
If I was to get married today I would feel tied down for no reason. I don't want to sound like a prick, but don't guys realize their potential as males?
Sorry, but as it turns out, not all people are only interested in sex approaching infinity, with partners approaching infinity. People get divorced because they either didn't love each other to begin with (ie they thought that they were marrying someone hot, now they're not) or the second it gets too hard they bail since its so easy. The concept of instant gratification doesn't apply to marriage, and that makes people think its a waste of time.

Hopefully though, the people that do have sexual relationships approaching infinity don't have kids and this way of thinking will die out.
See now that's what annoys me. Why is marriage often treated as the final destination for a loving relationship? Why bother getting married? Can anyone give me a good reason?
Well, in my opinion, if you aren't ready or mature enough to make a commitment to one person for the rest of your life, how can you be ready to have kids? Something I would argue as a larger commitment than marriage. You want to raise kids in a good home, and if you are bed hopping with a bunch of people, chances are the child will suffer from not having a mother or father figure in their life if its always changing.
Yeah I more or less agree with that. But unless i'm misunderstanding something your argument for marriage seems to be as a sort of test to see if you can handle a big commitment. That just seems a bit insubstantial to me, not saying that having children isn't a massive commitment. Just saying that if that's the sole purpose of marriage it seems a little superfluous or at least not as important as it is said to be.
 

Ace of Spades

New member
Jul 12, 2008
3,303
0
0
ripdajacker said:
Ace of Spades said:
(...) I'm a bit fed up with the blatant demonizing of marriage I've seen all my life. Yes, I would spend many years laying the ground work before getting married, but are we really all so jaded that we can't conceive of the possibility of loving someone enough that you want to merge your life with theirs?
I am not trying to demonize marriage, I am just trying to understand what the pressure is all about.
In which case, perhaps I misinterpreted what you said. It's not specifically you. There's a new counter-stigma for the original one among teenagers these days about how marriage is pointless and wastes money, which always gets me riled up.
 

ripdajacker

Code Monkey
Oct 25, 2009
134
0
0
Ace of Spades said:
In which case, perhaps I misinterpreted what you said. It's not specifically you. There's a new counter-stigma for the original one among teenagers these days about how marriage is pointless and wastes money, which always gets me riled up.
In the eyes of a teenager they are right, the world is wrong, and everything is pointless.
 

Monsterfurby

New member
Mar 7, 2008
871
0
0
I agree to an extent with the OP. For some reason, many friends I met in the USA during my time at an American High School back in '04 are married now. As for me, I have been together with my current girlfriend for just over four years now, and I can't even think of considering marriage. There is no way I will get married within the next 7 years (i.e. before I turn 30), and she agrees. If our relationship lasts that long, it's probably worth being reaffirmed by marriage. If not, it saves you the trouble of getting a divorce.
 

bootz

New member
Feb 28, 2011
366
0
0
harmonic said:
bootz said:
harmonic said:
balol said:
Some people do it because of the whole "No-sex-till-married" religious garbage that their parents will beat the fuck out of and disown them. That is a very large, unfortunate problem in America. Dunno bout Europe.
The hell are you talking about? That might happen once in a blue moon. And only in very select parts of the deep, deep south. Stop your exaggerating.
I live in Pennsylvania. I dated at least 2 girls with this happening to them. The one wanted to get married just so she could have sex without her family shunning her. Hell her Dad who was a Catholic married a protesant girl and his family shunned him for it. Its silly seeing religion tearing families apart. My ex-girlfriend wasn't invited to her cousins wedding and hurt because her mom was protestant.
I'm pretty much an athiest and didn't realize the power religion has until I saw this.

The other girl got caught having sex and got kicked out of her house with nothing.
It happens everyday all over america. An unmarried woman having sex is still someone you just cast away to avoid being emmbarassed.
There are always exceptions to everything.

Everyone has a story.

It doesn't prove anything. The guy said "it's a very large, unforunate problem in America." As if it's equivalent of something huge and unviersal like... racism, or AIDS, or poverty. It's not.
I know noone with AIDs and no rasicts so in my experience its more of a problem than those. I got kicked out of my house for dating a girl my parents didn't like when I was 17.
 

Delsana

New member
Aug 16, 2011
866
0
0
ripdajacker said:
The self-explaining title should say it all, but here is an elaboration.

I am currently residing in Denmark, where marriage is sort of, at least to my social groups, the "last resort". It's something you do after you've had your series of relationships that end in sewage, and more importantly it's something you decide around the time, but preferably AFTER the decision to have kids.

With a marriage failure rate at about 40% (maybe it's even more) it's hard to stay optimistic. My grandma would say it's because we don't believe in love, but the truth of the matter is that women and men earn enough money to support themselves.

I know some married people that are around my age (23), and I don't get the rush. Some of the relationships are both party's first serious, and let's be honest: At this age you don't know shit.

I still spend most of my waking hours thinking about gorgeous women and how to get in their pants. I can do a presentation at school/work and completely lose focus if some hot chick passes by.

If I was to get married today I would feel tied down for no reason. I don't want to sound like a prick, but don't guys realize their potential as males? Sure there are some relationships that are meant to last, but getting married before your education is finished AND before your career has begun just seems like a stupid idea.

Watching American movies and sitcoms (especially How I Met Your Mother and FRIENDS), I find their solution to all problems being: Find a spouse, get her to marry you, win. What's up with that?
---

Well, Christianity would be one of the reasons, and for that matter Catholicism.

Another reason would be for tax reasons and because you want to spend your life with your loved one and there is no other means to say that greater than marriage.

Doing it AFTER sex, AFTER children, AFTER hell and back... that shortcuts the entirety and the sacred solemnity of the point. Also, for MOST religions, that's heretical.
 
Dec 27, 2010
814
0
0
Are you really judging a nation's conscience based on a few (bad) sitcoms? Okay, ignoring that logical fallacy, why exactly do you assume this is an inherently American trait? You say yourself your grandmother believes in marriage, is it not possible that your generation is the exception globally, and that marriage is something that's celebrated by older generations, not a single nation? Really, this the silliest generalisation I've heard in a while, and that's saying something.