whats your SSBB line up?

Recommended Videos

SpaceBat

New member
Jul 9, 2011
743
0
0
DexterNorgam said:
Listen, I understand you've probably invested tons of time trying to hone "techniques" for this game but the truth of the matter is that this game suffers more than any fighter out there with the button masher syndrome. I can only see spending time tryin to build "skill" (lol) at this game as a complete waste of time because I haven't seen a fighting game that relies less on the player having actual talent than brawl. Its an irrelevant game on an irrelevant console.
A game relying less on talent than other games doesn't mean it requires little. Training and skill makes a world of difference and it's not as random and casual as you may think. Is it hardcore like Street Fighter? No, of course not, but it's not the button-mashing shitstorm you make it out to be.

I sincerely hope you've either never actually put a bit of time into the game and just tried it out a handful of times or that you simply took your opinion from Yahtzee's review. Because while criticizing someone who says it's incredibly competitive would have been understandable (because it's not and has the largest amount of random factors I've ever seen in a fighting game), saying that the game requires little to no skill whatsoever and is the equivalent of a fighting version of mario party is as stupid and ignorant as saying that SSFIV requires no skill because it only requires you to pick Ken and spam shoryuken.
 

AdumbroDeus

New member
Feb 26, 2010
268
0
0
DexterNorgam said:
AdumbroDeus said:
DexterNorgam said:
Wow, people talking about skill and such in reference to smash bros? lol.
Uh, playing smash even remotely competitively is extremely skillful.


Just to execute stuff this is what is required in melee:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vXgpGBbh5r8


All three games have a large number of options, which each of those options beating a unique set of the opponent's options.

And the amount of reads/attempted reads per minute in both is staggering, especially because of the lack of true combos in both games (as in, there are few, not none), which means each link requires a read to continue.
Yea, not really though. It is amusing to me to hear people talk about this game like its something more than the fighting game version of mario party...

Listen, I understand you've probably invested tons of time trying to hone "techniques" for this game but the truth of the matter is that this game suffers more than any fighter out there with the button masher syndrome. I can only see spending time tryin to build "skill" (lol) at this game as a complete waste of time because I haven't seen a fighting game that relies less on the player having actual talent than brawl. Its an irrelevant game on an irrelevant console.
See, there are lots of issues you can bring up with Brawl, especially relative to it's more competitive older brother, but when you bring up button mashing that just means that you have no CLUE what you're talking about.

Only third strike is more resistant to button mashing as an effective strategy (at high levels of play, if you're playing all items on high on port town it's gonna be a lot more effective because so much is happening that distracts from proper punishment).

1. Freedom of movement, because the stages are extremely expansive and you have the ability to play a strong aerial game, it's difficult for the opponent to put you in a situation where you have to actually deal with their mashing, instead you can just wait for them to attack, then attack from one of the angles they can't cover.

2. Low shieldstun, which means that if you hit your opponent's shield haphazardly he will punish you, almost nothing is safe on shield and those that are (minus a few very rare things like jigg's backair) have to be spaced perfectly, otherwise they're not safe.


And then you have things that are common to essentially every fighting game, namely spacing and reading. Frankly sonic can punish a whiffed attack from almost the entire length of final d away.



Melee's even better in that regard, while it has more safe moves, it's movement options are so much more powerful.


So frankly, unless you actually know what you're talking about and understand the mechanics of the game, don't presume to comment how worthy it is of competitive play. The fact that you picked the most laughable object (probably because yahtzee said it about all fighting games, which was wrong anyway) just illustrates how irrationally opposed to it you are. But feel free to attempt to win via button mashing against for example either of these guys http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DDm-rq8gzcI

If you want a real objection, talk about how unbalanced it is.
 

GeorgW

ALL GLORY TO ME!
Aug 27, 2010
4,806
0
0
I play turneys with friends and I always use:
1: Toon Link
2: Marth
3: Varies
I like to vary my 3rd option, it's no fun to keep playing the same chars.
 

Fishyash

Elite Member
Dec 27, 2010
1,154
0
41
DexterNorgam said:
SpaceBat said:
it's not the button-mashing shitstorm you make it out to be.
Yes it is.
It's as much a button mash fest as a ken mashing h.shoryuken is.


What I mean is that in low level play no matter what game it is you can pull of that stuff, but when you're acctually good at a game that stuff never works...

Ohwait you're talking about brawl right? Then you are 100% right.
 

krazykidd

New member
Mar 22, 2008
6,099
0
0
Meta knight
Peach
Kirby
Sonic
Game and watch

My main is peach i love her so much , she so fun to play.
 

SpaceBat

New member
Jul 9, 2011
743
0
0
AdumbroDeus said:
Man, don't waste your breath. It's not worth it.
If the guy wants to stay ignorant and look stupid, let him. He's never going to admit that his argument is ridiculous anyway. You know how some people are.
 

AdumbroDeus

New member
Feb 26, 2010
268
0
0
I've been meaning to make a response i could can to "smash = button masher".

Also, it's mainly for the other people on the fence.
 

DexterNorgam

New member
Jul 16, 2011
214
0
0
AdumbroDeus said:
If you want a real objection, talk about how unbalanced it is.
Why would anyone complain about balance in this game? ITS TRASH, it doesn't matter if its balanced. In Fact, its NOT balanced because its Not supposed to be taken seriously.

It would be like complaining about balance in Mario Kart Wii... Pointless, because its not supposed to be taken seriously as a racing game. Just like Smash Bro is not supposed to be taken seriously as a fighter...

They really are the mario party games of thier genres.
 

GraveyardTricks

New member
Dec 16, 2009
214
0
0
1.Diddy Kong
2.Lucario
3.Toon Link

Not many people like Diddy Kong, but once you get used to him he can be quite effective.
 

ejb626

New member
Aug 6, 2009
1,322
0
0
1. Meta Knight (though I try not to use him as much now)
2. Lucario
3.Kirby
4.Mr. Game and Watch
5. Zero Suit Samus

I generally like quick characters, I used to be really good in boss battles when using ZSS but I've grown a bit rusty and now I can't dodge as much as I used to be able to. The rest I like to use in fights against other characters.
 

AdumbroDeus

New member
Feb 26, 2010
268
0
0
DexterNorgam said:
AdumbroDeus said:
If you want a real objection, talk about how unbalanced it is.
Why would anyone complain about balance in this game? ITS TRASH, it doesn't matter if its balanced. In Fact, its NOT balanced because its Not supposed to be taken seriously.

It would be like complaining about balance in Mario Kart Wii... Pointless, because its not supposed to be taken seriously as a racing game. Just like Smash Bro is not supposed to be taken seriously as a fighter...

They really are the mario party games of thier genres.
I don't know, you could refute my points.


The more you say that it's trash without supporting it properly (aka, explaining WHY it's a button masher) the more obvious it becomes that you know nothing about the game about any reasonable level of play and are talking out of your ass.


As a side point, who cares what it's intended to be. Developer intent is meaningless, all that matters is it's quality at high levels of play.
 

JaceArveduin

New member
Mar 14, 2011
1,952
0
0
I've never played it, though I have played the original enough to actually have a line up.
Pikachu
Link

If one doesn't work, the other does, I'll also play a few of the other ones.
 

War Penguin

Serious Whimsy
Jun 13, 2009
5,717
0
0
1) Link:
He has it all! A sword, bow and arrows, bombs, a boomerang, and a spin move that's sooo much fun!

2) Wario:
My friend hates Wario, and I think that's the reason why I like to use him so much. He's fast, crazy, and... well, yeah, that's kind of it.

3) Meta Knight:
Speed and agility. That's all he really boils down to. And I love him for it!

That's pretty much it.
 

neonsword13-ops

~ Struck by a Smooth Criminal ~
Mar 28, 2011
2,771
0
0
1.Lucas (Timing is what makes the character so powerful. His stick is nice too.)
2.Zero Suit Samus (And ONLY Zero Suit Samus)
3.Luigi (He does a dolphin flop. What else is there?)
4.Pikachu (Pika...Pika?)
5.Wario (His powers of digestion are the key to battle)

If the need arises, Peach will be my go-to gal for combat.
 

Ninonybox_v1legacy

New member
Apr 2, 2008
1,974
0
0
1.Falco (Reverse PAWNCH)
2.Pikachu (down+B)
3.Bowser (body slam)
4.Mario (jump Jump JUMP)
5.Wolf (I have no idea why im good with him)