Which game do you think comes close to being perfect?
- Thread starter DarkHuntress
- Start date
Recommended Videos
probably anachronox, way back in the day, even though it was never finished. it was elatively perfect, for me at least.
yes, but when it first came out.will1182 said:
I'm not too fond of the controls in Corruption, still it's a good game. I haven't played Trilogy because I already have the other two still.
Wait, so the game can skimp out and be called perfect if you ignore the existence of the campaign? That's half the game.Uncompetative said:
...
The weapons and dialogue were creative, though. The enemies were the only truly 'bland' element in the game for me. (ETA: and there was nothing actually 'wrong' with any of the enemies: most of them were simply not tremendously engaging. A few were more interesting, though.)
Seems like the movement thing is a personal preference more than anything else. It happens, I suppose (I often can barely stand first-person cameras, for example).
...miva2 said:
The weapons and dialogue were creative, though. The enemies were the only truly 'bland' element in the game for me. (ETA: and there was nothing actually 'wrong' with any of the enemies: most of them were simply not tremendously engaging. A few were more interesting, though.)
Seems like the movement thing is a personal preference more than anything else. It happens, I suppose (I often can barely stand first-person cameras, for example).
Legond of Zelda: Ocarina of Time.
I loved it, absolutely loved it.
My favorite game of all time, I can play through it over and over and not get bored.
A perfect game in my mind.
I loved it, absolutely loved it.
My favorite game of all time, I can play through it over and over and not get bored.
A perfect game in my mind.
Oh my God, TIE Fighter. I only played that game for one day (and didn't really get anywhere) and it was still awesome.Del-Toro said:
My definition of a perfect game is one in which there is nothing left to add to make it better. I challenge someone to find something to add to tetris to make it better.
I would say Half-Life 1 & 2, Portal, Okami, and the original Metal Gear Solid are close to perfect. Mass Effect 2 is pretty good as well, but it has problems just like every other game.
If I had to pick one I'd say Metal Gear Solid 1 is the game that is closest to perfect. I really can't think of anything bad about it. Sure, I could talk about the graphics or shooting mechanics, but they were the best around back in the day. Okami is also damn close, but it can get a little repetitive and it is not very challenging.
To be honest, I don't think any game will ever be "perfect." There are always things that can be changed or added to make it better (and I like it that way).
If I had to pick one I'd say Metal Gear Solid 1 is the game that is closest to perfect. I really can't think of anything bad about it. Sure, I could talk about the graphics or shooting mechanics, but they were the best around back in the day. Okami is also damn close, but it can get a little repetitive and it is not very challenging.
To be honest, I don't think any game will ever be "perfect." There are always things that can be changed or added to make it better (and I like it that way).
I second Portal.wolf thing said:
Edit: Or like 54th portal or however many times it's been suggested because I totally didn't know this was 5 pages long >.>
Super Metroid. I can't think of any other game that succeeds so completely at what it sets out to do.
