canadamus_prime said:
Do you know of a video game franchise that has a pleasant fanbase? Or do you know of anything that has a pleasant fanbase for that matter?
Mechwarrior/Battletech and Jagged Alliance have some of the nicest fanbases I've met on forums, but Tachyon: The Fringe had probably the most pleasant in-game players I've had the wonderful experience of gaming with. Players actually went out of their way to set up new-player servers to get them accustomed to the game and creating a player-controlled coaching system so that the gap between a new player and a veteran was much smaller than most games I've played. Of course the game is mostly dead at this point, but a few fan-made patches and organized schedules later, there are still some pick-up games going on almost every Sunday at 2p-3p EST.
Of course, these are just my personal experiences and may not reflect the whole.
On topic...The worst fanbase I've dealt with is actually NOT Quake/UT/DotA/HoN/LoL/BLC/CoD/BF...
It's Legions: Overdrive.
Basically, the level-headed folks who played Starsiege: Tribes either still play it with mods, or moved on to Tribes 2, or Tribes Vengeance, or more recently, Tribes:Ascend...The people who got angry every single time they lost started playing a "spiritual successor" called Legions: Overdrive.
Imagine if you took the players from Tribes 1 who were never quite in the right mental space to compete with the professionals (who are actually very nice people) and put them in one place. Basically, you have every stereotypical ego that can exist in a CTF game - people who think they're the greatest because of their fast flag cap, people who think they're the greatest because of a base defend, people who blame you for not covering the middle of the map, players begging you to disconnect and uninstall while they llama grab the flag and give the game away by yelling at you instead of playing, etc...
It's funny on some level, hilarious if you think about how mad someone got for practically no reason, but on another level, very very sad, because when you frag that kid, his life shatters and he slams his headset down because the game is the most important thing to him. It was quite unfortunate.
That said, I have to include Diablo as a honorable runner up. It was the first online game I played where people would do anything they could to scam you with drop trades and such, PK you in town, hostile you and take a town portal to kill you, open portals in the middle of monsters, say it's safe, then when someone walks in they instantly die and the killer grabs all their items, etc... It was, again, hilarious, but also quite terrible.