fenrizz said:
Seems like they would prefer no DLC at all, which I find to be absurd.
They do not have to buy it, and people like me (and you it seems) will gladly pay for more content to our favourite games.
It's like they expect developers to do it for free.
Well, it's not entirely that they would prefer no DLC, it's just that they think all the DLC should already be in the retail release of the game. (Of course, that would mean the game's release gets delayed by up to a year, but you never hear them address that!) They see a GOTY release as the definitive version, the one they should have been sold initially at the $60, and therefore they see the original version of the game as only a fraction of the "real" game, and object to being sold what they see as 80% of a game for 100% of the price. Which is bonkers. Especially when you consider that so many of the games these people ***** the most about (Borderlands, Fallout 3 and NV, Dragon Age O and 2, Mass Effect 2, etc.) are already ridiculously good values before the DLC.
And yes, for the most part, DLC is typically stuff that is truly "extra". There are occasional hiccups, DLC that clearly "completes" a game rather than complements it (Broken Steel is a big offender here, I think, and there are a couple games that seem to have "Epilogues" which complete a previously unfinished story...I've heard that Prince of Persia 2008 is guilty of this, though I haven't finished that game or played the Epilogue). In those very rare cases, I can see how there might be an argument.
But for the most part, DLC usually just adds stuff on top of an already-complete game, stuff that doesn't necessarily fall within the overall story, but just adds self-contained chapters (most of the Fallout DLCs, for instance) or alternate perspectives (Enslaved), and these are truly optional...if you don't want them, their absence shouldn't affect your enjoyment of the game. If you DO want them, well then you should have no problem paying a few extra dollars!
(Then of course there's the day-one DLC, which is a whole other argument...as someone who buys exclusively new, it's hard for me to drum up any sympathy for used-game buyers, but I don't have as much of a problem with their protests in this case.)