Who would you be: A new twist on a common question

Recommended Videos

Simriel

The Count of Monte Cristo
Dec 22, 2008
2,485
0
0
Cpt_Oblivious said:
[HEADING=1]Howl[/HEADING]


He's wizard with a steam powered castle that walks! What else would you need?
Beautiful film.
As for myself? I would be General Marian Cross of the Black Order!
 

Deacon Cole

New member
Jan 10, 2009
1,365
0
0
Country
USA
If I was a Japanese animation character, I would kill myself. Most likely in the womb.
 

jboking

New member
Oct 10, 2008
2,694
0
0
I am Justice said:
Who are you calling "some douchebag kid with an overpowered notebook"? >_<
You're right, Self-righteous would have been a better definition there. "I am justice"...need I say more.
 

Legion

Were it so easy
Oct 2, 2008
7,190
0
0
Jang said:
Machines Are Us said:
Well seeing as this is based on Anime (and therefore much less realistic) I shall give a real answer.

Why? not that I want to disrespect your opinion but... why?
He looks cool (in the pic I chose) and I would do things differently than he did.

I took the question to mean that you become them, so still have your own mind.


lilnorris64 said:
Machines Are Us said:
@ berethond: Christ it's a fun thread asking who you'd be in a fantasy, stop being such a prick, it's not like it's even possible that it could ever happen.

Suiseiseki IRL is right in pointing out that if you have no interest in the thread there is no need to participate.

Especially as the question is "Who would you be" therefore only giving an answer along the lines of "I would be ..." is on-topic and not trolling.

If the question was "Would you want to be ...?" then it'd be fine.
"stop being such a prick"
wow way to be a dick dude hes just stating his opinion
why dont you stop being a prick
It's amazing that out of all those words you completely ignored the reason for why I called him that and instead jump on the least important word in my post.

You then decide to insult me twice (even though it had nothing to do with you) so reported.

Let me clarify seeing as it seems difficult to understand:

Threads are for discussion, the topic is decided by the Original Poster.
They decide what they want to ask/discuss.

Anything that is not relevant to the question is off-topic.
Anything that does nothing but debase the topic is trolling.

So by going into a thread asking "who would you be?", a hypothetical question that is just for fun and answering "nobody and don't assume I want to" is trolling because:

1: If you knew you had nothing to contribute prior to looking at the thread then there is no reason to post.

2: It doesn't answer the question, as anyone who wouldn't want to imagine themselves as an anime character has not been asked anything to answer, and again, has no reason to post.

3: It drags it off-topic as the OP then has to start trying to defend their topic against someone who has no reason to even be there.

It would be like me going into a thread asking "What's your favourite PS3 game?" and answering "None, I don't have one. Why would you assume that everyone does?".

Yes, the person has the right to an opinion, but dragging it off-topic and trolling is not welcomed on The Escapist.
 

Deadarm

New member
Sep 8, 2008
346
0
0
I am going to go with something old school, Raoh. I chose him for 2 reasons: First, he can subconciously evade and counter attacks. Second, he has cool theme music. (Not to mention a cool hat.)

On second thought mabey Cougar from Scryed because lets face it, who doesn't like cars with perfect handling that can travel at mach 2?
 

Citrus

New member
Apr 25, 2008
1,420
0
0
Suiseiseki IRL said:
SODAssault said:
Er... what's the twist? This seems like every other "who would you be" thread.
I tried to make it so you have to actually sit and think about who you would want to be. But then again I forgot that not everyone is as complex as I am (sorry if that sounded arrogant).
Very.

Anyway, after some consideration, I don't think I would want to be any anime character. Maybe it's because I don't watch much anime and thus have a limited selection to choose from, but of the characters I know, the coolness of their abilities is downplayed a bit by the fact that most of their lives tend to suck. Afro Samurai's crazy sword skills wouldn't warrant living a grief-stricken and lonesome life.

Oh yeah, Pokemon is an anime. Brock could be a candidate; he isn't all that cool, but he certainly appears to have a pleasant and laid-back life.
 

lilnorris64

New member
Apr 4, 2009
131
0
0
Machines Are Us said:
Jang said:
Machines Are Us said:
Well seeing as this is based on Anime (and therefore much less realistic) I shall give a real answer.

Why? not that I want to disrespect your opinion but... why?
He looks cool (in the pic I chose) and I would do things differently than he did.

I took the question to mean that you become them, so still have your own mind.


lilnorris64 said:
Machines Are Us said:
@ berethond: Christ it's a fun thread asking who you'd be in a fantasy, stop being such a prick, it's not like it's even possible that it could ever happen.

Suiseiseki IRL is right in pointing out that if you have no interest in the thread there is no need to participate.

Especially as the question is "Who would you be" therefore only giving an answer along the lines of "I would be ..." is on-topic and not trolling.

If the question was "Would you want to be ...?" then it'd be fine.
"stop being such a prick"
wow way to be a dick dude hes just stating his opinion
why dont you stop being a prick
It's amazing that out of all those words you completely ignored the reason for why I called him that and instead jump on the least important word in my post.

You then decide to insult me twice (even though it had nothing to do with you) so reported.

Let me clarify seeing as it seems difficult to understand:

Threads are for discussion, the topic is decided by the Original Poster.
They decide what they want to ask/discuss.

Anything that is not relevant to the question is off-topic.
Anything that does nothing but debase the topic is trolling.

So by going into a thread asking "who would you be?", a hypothetical question that is just for fun and answering "nobody and don't assume I want to" is trolling because:

1: If you knew you had nothing to contribute prior to looking at the thread then there is no reason to post.

2: It doesn't answer the question, as anyone who wouldn't want to imagine themselves as an anime character has not been asked anything to answer, and again, has no reason to post.

3: It drags it off-topic as the OP then has to start trying to defend their topic against someone who has no reason to even be there.

It would be like me going into a thread asking "What's your favourite PS3 game?" and answering "None, I don't have one. Why would you assume that everyone does?".

Yes, the person has the right to an opinion, but dragging it off-topic and trolling is not welcomed on The Escapist.
well im not going to read your whole reply, i understand your reasoning, i just didnt think your attitude was necessary tht is all
 

SecretTacoNinja

New member
Jul 8, 2008
2,256
0
0
I would be Tony Tony Chopper from One Piece



And that's not just because he's cute, funny and awesome. He has a troubled past sure but he currently has a band of friends that need him and love him. It must be great to be a skilled fighter and doctor too...
 

FoOd77

New member
Jul 2, 2009
132
0
0
I don't like anime, but in the spirit of the thread, I'd say I would want to be Road Runner from Looney Toons, come on, everything ALWAYS goes his way, plus, he's super fast. The only downside I can see is his incredible arrogance, you notice that every time Wile E. Coyote fails, Road Runner is always there to rub it in his face?

Still though, definately Road Runner.
 

Zombie_Fish

Opiner of Mottos
Mar 20, 2009
4,584
0
0
Cpt_Oblivious said:
[HEADING=1]Howl[/HEADING]


He's wizard with a steam powered castle that walks! What else would you need?
It's posts like this that give the following statement reasoning:

/thread
 

NoobMaster

New member
Jan 5, 2008
8
0
0


Because you don't get more badass than that ( I think i can choose dante because there was a DMC anime.)
 

Cpt_Oblivious

Not Dead Yet
Jan 7, 2009
6,933
0
0
stinkychops said:
Cpt_Oblivious said:
[HEADING=1]Howl[/HEADING]
He's wizard with a steam powered castle that walks! What else would you need?
He's also possesed or goes into Emo fits (i wasn't quite sure).
One emo fit was caused by being ginger though xD