Mordwyl said:
We don't hate the game, we hate its fanboys.
Yo, fanboy present.
Anyway, I actually gotta say I was looking forward to a bit of a break to be honest but the thread came and I followed. As we all knew I would, for this is my destiny. In fact if we look at my recent tally I've been keeping, this is my one hundredth 'Halo Thread Post' so I decided to mark this special occassion by doing something with more detail and explain in depth why I think there was a rise and fall of Halo:
Halo is a game that was very popular and with it, helped become the lifeblood of the Xbox. That alone is an indication because the key word is 'Xbox'... I once heard it said more people would have sung the praises of Halo CE if it had been multiplatform instead of just Xbox but because it became the 'big title' on Xbox this made it an obvious target for the people who played Playstation and Gamecube... Playstation in particular.
It is still within human nature to be very insecure about oneself and feeling the need to assert your strength and be completely without fault. So naturally, the best way to make yourself feel better is to make the opposition look worse. So Halo's very release and it's success made it immenant.
Soon afterwards Halo 2 would be showing up three years later into a world where the games industry had now thrived a lot from the influence of the first game. At the time Halo 2 did not need to improve much, what it did, it did well. So one thing it did help do was bring about online shooters to the console. And in so doing created another huge flaw.
Anyone who spent much time on Counterstrike or indeed the internet at all can agree here that the online community though not all bad can be populated by a lot of obnoxious annoying people. So Halo 2, while succeeding in bringing a lot of people together to chill out and kill each other over Xbox Live... also attracted with it the worst kin of people in online games. Those who were lured by a new popular game and became the undeserved symbol of the Halo fanbase.
Halo Fans would soon be alienated from the other consumers.
Now we reach Halo 3. I admit there was a MASS amount of hype, it was on TV, movies, the bus, the internet, soft drink, chip packets, billboards, t-shirts.... everywhere. This in turn helped put games in general in the spotlight and helped (in my opinion) make 2007 such a good year for the games industry. However this also made it quite clear that Halo was mainstream and this lead to people wanting to be cool and going against the mainstream. Shortly after release Halo 3 had a huge boom for a loooong time before finally getting booted out by a combination of Fanboys of other Consoles and the people who wanted to be cool.
So I still call it 'flock effect' you get a few people who don't like something, combine it with the people who like pissing people off, add the desire to be cool and 'elite' and finally putting them all together an you get anarchy. The internet is tearing itself apart because hating Halo has become cool. I said it before I think, you just have to start saying the right things and have some figure in authority who seems to support their position to lead them in the right direction and then if it makes their opinions seem valid they'll all follow the same belief and like a wild herd of animals trample everything that gets in their way.
And that's how people thinking they are elitist become mainstream.