Why are we so defensive about our music?

Recommended Videos

Antlers

New member
Feb 23, 2008
323
0
0
killcheese said:
2 years ago my mom was diagnosed with terminal cancer then shorty after that my uncle black mailed my dad over our house. I was beyond feeling bad, i wanted someone else to get hurt and was very angry and almost knocked out my uncle when i saw him. The only things that helped me was music and drugs which i started using. I am better now and thats all behind me, but i still feel like pink floyd helped me and that is why i defend it.
OK extremely depressing though that story is... Would it annoy you if someone said they didn't like Pink Floyd? I love Pink Floyd by the way.
 

TheScarecrow

New member
Jul 27, 2009
688
0
0
xmetatr0nx said:
FelixFox. said:
xmetatr0nx said:
We are? I dont care either way. Here watch, my favourite band is Incubus have at it people. Ill start, bunch of pot smoking hippies with generic rock sound and meh vocals. Also whats up with the DJ? Rap metal is dead, get used to it!
Must fight urge to defend... must maintain decorum....
Haha, see thats the thing though. Its what I like, if you dont fancy it then great im sure its horrible in your ears. Point is i dont care, say what you will, say what you may...see what i did there?

Also another incubus fan, awesome.
I never listened to them.
 

Kasawd

New member
Jun 1, 2009
1,504
0
0
I usually try to force tabs and musical scores down throats unti lthey understand if they insult my music. If we are sharing, though, I wil ltell the the bands I like in their respective genres.
 

Katherine Kerensky

Why, or Why Not?
Mar 27, 2009
7,744
0
0
I used to be defensive about my music. not so much any more, and no way defensive on these forums! :p
I share the music round, seeing if others can benefit from it :D
 

Dannyboy1186

New member
Jul 14, 2009
226
0
0
I wouldn't say I am defensive over the music I listen to but its normally I am worried the person I'm with might not like the music.
 

TheScarecrow

New member
Jul 27, 2009
688
0
0
xmetatr0nx said:
FelixFox. said:
xmetatr0nx said:
FelixFox. said:
xmetatr0nx said:
We are? I dont care either way. Here watch, my favourite band is Incubus have at it people. Ill start, bunch of pot smoking hippies with generic rock sound and meh vocals. Also whats up with the DJ? Rap metal is dead, get used to it!
Must fight urge to defend... must maintain decorum....
Haha, see thats the thing though. Its what I like, if you dont fancy it then great im sure its horrible in your ears. Point is i dont care, say what you will, say what you may...see what i did there?

Also another incubus fan, awesome.
I never listened to them.
Oh well crap, eh i would suggest that you not, i hear theyre rather mediocre.
I give all music a try. I got mistaken that you were knocking Hippie style Indie rock.
 

Frankydee

New member
Mar 25, 2009
1,137
0
0
I used to be that way when I was younger and lacked facial hair, nowadays I get people who often criticize my primary choice in music as being too loud and angry and I usually just say it's not the sort of thing for everyone. Kinda in the same way that I argue that songs about bitches, guns, bling and gangsters are for the mentally challenged.

So as often as I get people who boo at my music of choice, I just don't say anything and make a comeback when they start playing T-pain or 50 cent. Something along the lines of "oh god I can just imagine him standing on stage wacking off onto a crowd of his biggest fans." It's all in good fun anyway.
 

EscapeGoat_v1legacy

New member
Aug 20, 2008
2,788
0
0
I wouldn't say I'm massively defensive about my music, but when I am, it's generally because people are trying to tell me that I'm not listening to the right sort of music. That "argument" really annoys me, since musical taste is purely an opinion-based idea.
 

ChromeAlchemist

New member
Aug 21, 2008
5,865
0
0
It's mainly because of the ignorant pretentious definition they give of the genre you have obviously been listening to for longer than them. "Metal is just a bunch of guys screaming about cutting themselves and their girlfriends" "Hip Hop is just about guns, cars, and bitches" "Reggae music is just the same beat with a slight variation"

They have adequate reason to be pissed, when people not only tell them that their musical taste is garbage, but they then go ahead and incorrectly define it. It's the closed mindedness that gets people defensive.
 

Steel Ronin

New member
Apr 14, 2009
213
0
0
Death_Korps_Kommissar said:
Because when people do make an argument against say, metal. They just say well it's just a bunch of guys growling and noise dur-hur. The fact that it is a terrible argument is why we get defensive, some asshole just presumes so much about your music that you love.
well the truth is that metal is just "a bunch of guys growling and noise dur-hur" but that doesen't stop anyone from listening to it I do so myself.
 

Disaster Button

Elite Member
Feb 18, 2009
5,237
0
41
Well I used to get mega defensive then I realised I just looked like an idiot and if someone doesn't like what I listen to I say "it's cool" and ask what they lsiten to.

But I think we get defensive because we grow attatched to our music because we relate to it so in a way we get defensive because to us it almost feels like people are making fun of similar situations we've experienced by making fun of our music..
 

Ghost8585

New member
Jul 21, 2009
233
0
0
Radeonx said:
Supreme Unleaded said:
I get defensive when someone insults me for liking Country or Soft Rock, even just Rock. Its just that people will insult you for no reason, thats why we get so defensive.

Now saying that I would just like to point this out, I hate Rap and MOST people that listen to it, why, because ALSMOST everyone that listens to it is a 9-16 year old fagget that thinks there cool becaudse it has swears every 5 seconds. Now I'm not saying everyone is like this, its just that the only people that I see listeing to it are people that I hate, or someone who looks like there going to shank me. I just don't understand why people want to listen to people talking and swearing.

No offence if you like the genra, but everyone that I've seen so far is like that, studies show that what kind of music you listen to reflects yourself, so when i hear rap I don't want to be anyware near it.
You're listening to the wrong kind of rap. While I dislike the "Gangsta Rap", there are some other rap artist that make songs with REAL lyrics and a message.
Yup, Jurassic 5, Atmosphere, and Dilated Peoples are a good place to start. Give those guys a shot. They sure gave me a better appreciation for rap.

Anyways people get defensive about their musical tastes because it's kind of an extensions of who they are as people.
 

xXZer0

New member
Aug 1, 2009
48
0
0
Some people really depend on music for things like getting thru the day and others thats the only thing that they have for fun and is just part of there life so its just important to some people. As for why people get mad for something like saying raps just about bitches, violence, and swearing is just a sterotype like saying all black people eat fried chicken and all irish people do is drink. Like a sterotype some things are true like rap where they just swear, and talk about money like fags like soulja boy and gucci mane while others make songs that are good and actually have messages, and ones not just about killing or drugs although those songs are never really played on radio or on TV because all those retarded songs every hears are what the record companies think will make money. Look up Hip Hop is Dead by Nas which says how rap and hip hop went all shitty
 

irbullz

New member
May 12, 2009
34
0
0
Steel Ronin said:
Death_Korps_Kommissar said:
Because when people do make an argument against say, metal. They just say well it's just a bunch of guys growling and noise dur-hur. The fact that it is a terrible argument is why we get defensive, some asshole just presumes so much about your music that you love.
well the truth is that metal is just "a bunch of guys growling and noise dur-hur" but that doesen't stop anyone from listening to it I do so myself.
no only slayer durhur shout! metal very good :)
 

MrSnugglesworth

Into the Wild Green Snuggle
Jan 15, 2009
3,232
0
0
When people make fun of Muse, I just ignore it because Muse is so unique, I understand not many people will like it.
 

Spaghetti

Goes Well With Pesto
Sep 2, 2009
1,658
0
0
I don't tend to defend my music that much. Probably because I'm on the offensive alot of the time. I've got nothing wrong with people listening to what they like, I just like people to know that Lady GaGa is pure evil...along with several others I shant mention