I'm sorry OP but at the end of the day all this comes down to is personal preference, any point you try to make can be obliterated by some 6 year old writing "I like it because it's fun!", what are you supposed to say to that? Do you tell the poster he/she is wrong and that he/she doesn't find it fun?
But I do agree with you...kind of, the only game I ever really played was Pokemon, I played GoldenSun and Links Awakening, but whenever someone says Gameboy my mind instantly goes into Pokemon mode, now I'm part of what seems to be the minority of people who think modern day handhelds suck, I hated the PSP because I don't think PS2 games can be played on such a small screen with such ass controls, and I hate the DS because I feel like a moron when someone sees me using it, I think handhelds are for children and should stay that way, if you're still in school that's fine, but if I see someone at college playing with a DS I want to throw it into the river, ***** slap him, and tell him to grow up, I'm getting off track here, ummm Pokemon, yeah, a combination of my utter disgust for modern day handhelds and Pokemon looking more and more like aborted SPORE creations make me hate the franchise.
Also I hate how they won't make a 3D version of R/B/Y (for example) because they think pokemon should stay on handhelds, all I hear when they say that is "Well we could make a 3D version of the handheld games, but that would require genuine effort, and we're really busy rolling in the money of handheld gamers."