Personally, I like the pre-rendered backgrounds from an artistic perspective, although their Popeye arms have always struck me as kind of weird. Anyway, in terms of music, character development, environment, and humor, FFVII has won my spot of favorite game. However, to place an example, my old assistant manager loved FFVIII, and when we would discuss any kind of game, I would always be talking in terms of story and character development (I'm a slave to good writing), and he would always talk about gameplay (which I admit FFVII doesn't have the most innovative, but I did like the materia system), and it was a lot like we were having separate conversations.
As to the haters, well, they're entitled to their opinion, but only so long as they've actually played it. A lot of people hate Naruto because it's popular, but have only watched maybe an episode. It's cool to hate the mainstream, you know?
....Oh, and by the way, I hate Naruto. But I did try reading the manga and even tried watching the first season in Japanese. And I also hate FFX, and played the whole thing. If you're going to hate, at least try BEFORE you've made your decision.
So of course, it will always be a matter of opinion, and FFVII, personally, excelled in an RPG where many others had failed. Dissidia: Final Fantasy, anyone?
