Neverhoodian said:
3rd Worst: Andrew Johnson
*Thoroughly bungled reconstruction efforts after the Civil War.
*Vetoed the Civil Rights Bill of 1866 ("This is a country for white men, and by God, as long as I am President, it shall be a government for white men.").
*Violated the Tenure of Office Act (for which he was later impeached).
The part about him being a "good ol' boy" can be accepted here, but I feel I should bring up an important point concerning the first Johnson.
As one of the only token democrats left in office (everyone else left office to go to the CSA), he was pretty much screwed for reconstruction. The radical republicans wanted to pretty much "salt the earth" when it came to the South, so he was pretty unpopular in a radical republican congress. With Lincoln gone, and the inability to mediate as a moderate Republican.. the whole thing kinda went.. south. This also led to the Tenure of Office Act, attempting to limit Johnson's power and ability to replace important people who would carry out reconstruction as per the orders of said radical republican congress. I think it was Stanton- and his hilarious armed response antics. Given that the act was repealed later, and similar laws have been found unconstitutional, I don't think it's poor leadership that caused him to violate this.
Aka, congress and the president going at it cuz from different places and having different opinions.
Anywhos, he got impeached, but got acquitted by one vote. He was quite unpopular, but he did help to prevent further division in the union.
Racist? Yes. Worst leader? I dunno, there was a lot of racists in power at the time- Woodrow Wilson allowed Klan v2 to premiere their "Birth of a Nation" at the White House.
A much more suitable, yet popular candidate for "the worst leader" position could be "Andrew freaking Jackson". His borderline insane hate for the British, his dealings with foreign nationals, and his spoils system really set bad precedents for future presidents and leaders. I mean, this guy executed British civilians on Spanish soil in summary executions. (They were plotting.) His leadership style was more akin to the persona of Duke Nukem.
Although hilarious and popular, Jackson really lacked the mind for the job.
As a close second, Grant lacked any real presidential leadership, and pretty much just followed whatever Congress told him. Oh and the scandals. THE SCANDALS!