I'd pick Flame in the Night by Freedom Call. It still gives me chills.
Other possibilities are And the Story Ends by Blind Guardian, Carry the Blessed Home by Blind Guardian, Every Dog Has Its Day by Flogging Molly, I'm Alive by Helloween, and Sam's Town or This River Is Wild (both by the Killers).
Or, to mix things up, Famous for Nothing by Dropkick Murphys, I Don't Wanna Stop by Ozzy Osbourne, Party Hard by Andrew W.K. (I'd hate to leave everyone feeling sad), or a power metal interpretation of "Death Be Not Proud" by John Donne.