Not who I would have gone with, but not indefensible and definitely not the worst person on the short list. It was likely to be a black woman largely due to (a) Biden's pledge to have a woman VP nominee and (b) fairly actively pressure to pick a woman of color as a VP nominee due to both the moment and overt pressure from certain members of Democratic leadership (
Amy Klobuchar being the most overt example) both as a strategic and moral imperative.
She actually ticks a fair amount of boxes that make her a good pick overall:
1) She's a US Senator. She's already been on the national stage and has worked in the Senate for several years, which would be very attractive to Biden as one of the longest serving members of that body. Furthermore, her seat is relatively safe so it is likely her victory will not imperil a Democratic Senate majority.
2) She's not afraid to go on the attack (as the debates showed).
3) She (younger, woman of color focused on domestic issues) a very direct contrast to Biden (older, white male focused on foreign policy) without appearing out of step with him on core issues of the party.
4) She's progressive without running into more politically dangerous waters that many activists prefer.
She coauthored a plan with Sanders and Markey to provide $2,000 per person to families under $100k in income as part of the COVID-19 economic response and
signed onto a version of Sander's Medicare for All plan without eliminating private insurers (
which is a more politically popular option than elimination of private insurance). On matters relating to policing,
she's called for reforms without taking a stance on the issue of police funding. She's progressive without giving the message that Biden will beholden to the most extreme activists,
something Trump is already trying to do.
5) She's a woman of color, which accomplishes multiple objectives in that she can help turnout a key democratic constituency (
black women are the most loyal democratic demographic block and make up a substantial portion of the leadership of the party). She also would be the most senior Asian-American in elected office.
I think a lot of people are going to lose their mind should Biden win and eventually die in office.
Obama was vilified for daring to be president despite being black. Can you imagine how people would react when America gets a president that's both black AND a woman?
I do have some reservations about this. With her apparent past as some super strict attorney she isn't exactly the olive branch to the Sanders voters that's required.
I think it's important to remember that the modern notion of the progressive prosecutor as someone who hold back on prosecutions is an extremely new concept, really only gaining traction (i.e. winning) in the 2016 and 2018 election cycles. Her record as a DA in San Francisco in 2003 (where first black women elected to a DA position in all of California) and AG of California in 2011 is
mixed, with some actions being less strict than others and her positions sometimes being inconsistent within even close temporal proximity (notably regarding the death penalty where she declined to pursue it in one case involving the murder of a SFPD office but also declined to back an initiative to ban the death penalty in California. Her most notable achievements involved an online records database of police conduct in California. That said, she was a black women running for political office, and the DA and AG positions in particular, meaning she had a narrow path to be politically viable (she won the runoff in 2003 and one by less than 1 percent in 2010).
She would win overwhelmingly in the 2016 primary and later in the general election in no small part due to her existing statewide office holder position as AG.