I think that Bioshock isn't as much about its extreme settings, instead its extreme settings trying to paint a picture of the degree certain elitist political or pure ideological groups are willing to go to separate themselves from the rest of the world and find their ideal utopia. And then fail miserably a long the way.
Honestly, after Objectivism, Communism, and now American Jingoism, I'm more curious about what direction the developers will go next.
But as for settings. Stop thinking in polarizing extremes and limitations, and how can you ever "jump the shark" by taking it off world considering the material these games have already had to deal with (shooting bees out of hands and all that rubbish). That's not the point of the series even though these two games have been painting such image. Have the next setting take place in a crystal cavern, in a volcano or the earth's core, and YES in space, on our moon or Mars, or Saturn.
HAVE IT TAKE PLACE ON THE SURFACE OF THE SUN!
No.
INSIDE A BLACK HOLE!
lol

Honestly, after Objectivism, Communism, and now American Jingoism, I'm more curious about what direction the developers will go next.
But as for settings. Stop thinking in polarizing extremes and limitations, and how can you ever "jump the shark" by taking it off world considering the material these games have already had to deal with (shooting bees out of hands and all that rubbish). That's not the point of the series even though these two games have been painting such image. Have the next setting take place in a crystal cavern, in a volcano or the earth's core, and YES in space, on our moon or Mars, or Saturn.
HAVE IT TAKE PLACE ON THE SURFACE OF THE SUN!
No.
INSIDE A BLACK HOLE!
lol