Rocket Taco said:
I would love to know if anyone is in the same boat as me: despite desperately trying, I could never bring myself to like Bioshock. Everything I heard tell of it doing right (narrative, atmosphere, interesting and varied gameplay) I just couldn't see in it. Infinite looks a bit different and awesome, but all the reviews amount to "it's just as good as Bioshock." So does anyone who DIDN'T like the original have any impressions to share?
I'm kinda in the same boat as you, so lemme try to explain it to you, spoiler free.
I thought the first game was okay, but I would say that it was over rated. Combat really wasn't to interesting, I appreciated the story, but didn't think it was awe inspiring, and I wasn't really hooked with Rapture. I accepted that it was a good game, but it wasn't really up my stream. I played it once, and didn't think it was a waste of time.
I've been playing Infinite for the past four or five hours, and honestly, it's worth it just to see the city. Columbia is amazing. I'd go as far to say that the first thirty minutes to an hour is the most impressive feat I've ever seen in a video game. I'm having a hard time trying to explain it. But I've never seen something introduced as impressively as Columbia in any entertainment medium. If nothing else, just get it to play the first thirty minutes.
Gameplay is more of the same. It's a tad bit more action packed than the original Bioshock, but nothing really different. Definitely better, but nothing groundbreaking.
The dialogue with Elizabeth is entertaining, and the story so far is pretty interesting. I wouldn't say it's an interactive story by any means, but it makes you feel like you're more involved in the story than the first Bioshock was. Likewise, I wouldn't say it's groundbreaking, but then again, I'm only a few hours into it. There's still plenty of time for it to pick up, and by what I've seen so far, I have the feeling that they're going to be able to keep it up.
Atmosphere? Now this is where they nailed it. The city of Columbia, combined with everything that's taking place in the game really shines through here.
I really doubt that you won't take something away from this game. You gotta just experience the city they've created. It's getting consistently high reviews all over the place for a reason. Just trust me. You won't be disappointing.