Maeshone said:
I just had a few more points I felt like I needed to say before I stop pestering you about this subject.
-First of all; Combat. We are clearly just looking for different things there, so no point in discussing that further.
-You said that Act 1 was fine. I agree that it was fine; up to a point. It is a relatively long act that leads to nothing except the Deep Roads Exploration quest. Much of it felt like filler, and I ended up feeling empty since it all felt so pointless. You just get the deep roads exploration, you do it, timeskip. All that happened before that didn't really mean anything. You could argue that it did mean [isomething][/i], since it was about setting up the world and characters, but it was a way too long of an act for that. It dragged on. It was monotonous. (Fuck gathering all that gold.)
-Regarding Characters:
The characters definitely fit their own stereotypes, but I think they handled that well. Alistar is a sidekick character, but with him his past as being a young templar and what it all meant to him fleshed him out into a real character, instead of a silly sidekick. The protagonist can also "harden" Alistar, which makes him turn into a more stern, forwardfacing champ.
Meaning: Alistar can graduate from just being a sidekick.
Leliana was the slightly nutty one, but with her the issue of faith is a big theme. You talk with her about her faith, and she tells you about it. During the game there are even periods when Leliana questions her faith. I found it to be really interesting.
Morrigan; yes, she was a witchbitch who wasn't that bad after all. However with her I found the struggle that she had about her mother interesting. She loved her mother, yet she hated her. I found this conflict compelling.
Oghren had too little facetime to really be anything. I felt like he was an "extra".
I felt like DA2's character arcs outside of Varric and Aveline lacked the same kind of growth that characters like Leliana and Alistar had in the original game.
I have a simple request: Could you give a numerical score to DA2? I just wish to know if you thought it was "okay" or if you thought it was "good".
On a scale of 1-10, 5 being average, what score would you give it? Mine would be 4.