StriderShinryu said:
Two titles stand out for me as the biggest disappointments, Fable 2 and Final Fantasy 9.
Fable 2 was one game I really did buy pretty much on hype alone.. and boy did it come back to bite me in the ass. Everyone was saying it was a GOTY contender, and it even won GOTY from a few sources. Plus the way it was described really did sound cool, so I bought it. I kept playing it but ended up quitting before I even got to the end. I was seriously left wondering where this great game was that everyone had been talking about. Everything about it just felt so shallow, and that made the few good ideas it did have even harder to reconcile.
Final Fantasy 9, the supposed return of the series to it's NES/SNES glory days. I had actually really liked FF7 and I loved FF8, but there still was something special about FF4 and FF6 that made them my favourites overall. When FF9 was announced and hyped as a return to the SNES way of things I was extremely excited.. this was going to be the awesomeness of all of my favourite FF games put together! Then I saw the hideous art style. Besides making me want to vomit, it turned me off of the game almost entirely. I did manage to find a cheap copy shortly after release (that should have been my first clue) and figured I'd put up with the fugliness if only to experience the surely awesome game underneath. Boy was I wrong.
Honourable mentions go to Star Ocean 3 (SO2 was mindblowing, what happened?), FF5 (this bland, broken and boring garbage is the supposedly godly FF game that never got released in North America) and Seiken Densetsu 3 (Another sequel to an absolutely astounding game, this time Secret of Mana, that got so much hype and missed an NA release but was really so much crap).
I agree with you on Fable 2, but the hype i fell for was my own. I was expecting a fable 1, but better... but i don't think i even got that. i managed to complete it, but haven't touched it since. My friends got all the downloadable content and seems to play it even now when he can (even though he must have already completed it 100&)... the reason i say this is to state that people have different tastes and i understand that, in order to try not look like a potential douche in the next paragraph.
I loved Final Fantasy 9! Considering its a PS1 game, i thought the artwork was superb (at least the backgrounds tended to be, even if the characters were generally a mess of pixels, but back when it came out, those were considered good graphics), the story-line gripping, a decent amount of humour and generally lovable characters (and i'm not just talking about Vivi, a character which everyone else seems to grip to and refuse to let go... which is why i tend to keep my love for him/her/it secret as to give it some air)
I played 7 and enjoyed that quite a lot too, i also played 1,2, (the true)3, 4, 10 and loved all of them too (i always get 5 and 6 mixed up, but either way, i couldn't get into either of those). But for some reason, i could just never play 8. maybe its because my friend totally ruined the storyline for me (by completing it and informing me of every single occurence the moment he realised i'd played final fantasy) and then (metaphorically of course) dribbled over Squall making it hard for me to love him.
So what i am trying to say is, yes, i'm heavily Bias. Final Fantasy 9 was the game that introduced me to Final Fantasy as a whole, so i consider it a classic (even if it was released after 8) and i admit to being very Fan-boyish over it, which is probably the reason i still consider it my 2nd favourite Final Fantasy game.
oh, and on another note, i played 12 and absolutely hated it. I stopped and found it impossible to start again when they pulled the "it wasn't me, it was my twin brother!" card.
And now i am this far to realise i've actually only been very childish and not answered the topic, more had a rant at some poor guy/girl (i haven't checked, sorry) who merely stated their opinion. So including Fable 2, i also found Fallout relatively dissapointing, Zelda: phantom hourglass, Guitar Hero and i am pre-empitavely assuming that i'll be dissapointed by both Dead rising 2 and FFXIII.
Now, i say relatively for fallout because its probably not the games fault i hate it. I like the design (afterall, i loved Oblivion), i love the setting, i loved the gore (so damn much). What i didn't like (oddly enough) was the V.A.T.s system. okay, i thought it was pretty cool at first, but its a personal preference thing i guess, and the fact it totally hated Melee weapons (which is one of the things i love most). i can't say i considered it cheating, but i found it somewhat unfair that i could easily pick off an entire mob of people by pressing one button, clicking on what i wanted dead in the head, and then waiting. granted, i loved how it worked, it was very satisfying watching enemies explode and fall in very bloody pieces.
now here's how its not all Fallouts fault. My friends seem to have forgotten that you can fight without using V.A.T.s, which is probably why i despise the system so much. Rather then use up their AP once, finish them off with the FPS mode that they should be playing with (or even 3rd person mode), they will run away until their AP is restored before turning around and going at it again. It makes me want to slap them, sure, get your bigger, stronger, awesome brother to help you during a fight, but at least try to fight when he gets tired, rather than running around like a puff until he gets his breath back. (bad metaphor/analogy, sorry)
Oh, i also hate how the developers produced an alternate ending... or rather, a lack of ending. I didn't mind the original ending, but suddenly saying "oh, actually, that not really what happened.. tadah!" kinda annoyed me. i don't want to spoiler the ending.
I think i better explain myself about Guitar Hero too, as i bet a few people like that game. It was so hyped up at my school, everyone had at least 1 copy of the game, even if they didn't have a console to run it on. So i stubbornly thought "no, i will resist this popular urge, it will die down"... obviously it didn't, and so eventually i played the game, thinking "well if everyone likes it, then actually, it must be pretty good". oh how those words were eaten, puked back up with disgust of having ever let them leave my mouth, then eaten again. I really did not enjoy it at all, i'm not sure entirely why. Maybe its because my friends insisted that i was having fun, when really i was thinking the many more useful things my hands could be doing, other than fondling this bit of plastic shaped like a guitar. I guess thats what my hands tend to do anyway, just with different shapes of plastic but... meh, i just can't seem to explain the reasons i don't find it fun... maybe it is just because i'm a douche...