I keep going on about this game, but Mafia II. People praise it for the story, but it was ripped from the godfather, in fact the main character's first name is Vito and some side character's name is Henry Tomasino. People praise it for the shooting, but you can get just as good shooting from any gears of war game.
As for the other gameplay? There's a brawl mode with 3 one button moves and a quick time event finisher. All the other gameplay? Well, one chapter I had to clean toilets, another one I had to sell cigarettes, another one I had to lift crates. And if it's not making you do that, you're driving. So, at least the driving should be fun, right? No. It's not. First of all, these are 1940s and 50s cars, so being fun to drive is not their main goal. Second, traffic laws are enforced, so try to speed to your destination or even accidentaly hit another car? You're pulled over and ticketed. So, most of the game is either waiting at red lights, or driving around red light traffic because red light running is the one thing cops don't enforce. But even then half the waypoints are across town from your current position, and 1950s cars aren't exactly fast or fun, so you end up feeling like you were on an actual car trip by the time you reach your next waypoint.
Mafia II is one of the most aggressively boring games I've ever played. Maybe I'm just more of a GTA fan and the mafia series hates GTA fans with a passion, but I'm definitely sure I'm never playing it again.