Creepiest in-game diary/scene that you've seen/read.

[Audemas]

The Dunwich Building from Fallout 3 creeped me out to no end. That was one are where I really hated going through, but thank the God that I don't believe in that I had that Ghoul Mask. Oh and there are a bunch of diaries in Dead Space that creeped me out, one that comes to mind is when the guy dismembers himself while the tape is still going and just about all of them when Ben Temple and his crew are trying to get the ship working.

 

[WolfThomas]

I'd have to say the most creepiest journal I've read in-game was from Oblivion, during the Dark Brotherhood when you read the Traitor's journal. Also, Terry Cotter's (sp?) journal in Fable 2 is sort of disturbing.

I stole his mothers head, I didn't know if he was coming back and I wanted to piss him off.

 

[Sneaklemming]

There has been many, most recently the Diary entry of the girl in Borderlands. I only know here as crazy science girl, coz thats what everyone on the servers calls her.

It's actually kinda unsettling to share creepy moments like that with others... hmm

well yeh she goes on and on about here fat colleague whom she watches die...

 

[Stormeh5]

I'd have to say the most creepiest journal I've read in-game was from Oblivion, during the Dark Brotherhood when you read the Traitor's journal. Also, Terry Cotter's (sp?) journal in Fable 2 is sort of disturbing.

I stole his mothers head, I didn't know if he was coming back and I wanted to piss him off.

ACTUALLY
If you go to the farm, drop the head and then talk to him, he'll stammer and freak out a little.
It's a neat Easter Egg

 

[Reaperman64]

Itchy Scott has ugly face, killed him ate him still hungry

genious

 

[seryoga]

politics from tlad
... gross

 

[Commander Jack Rankin]

The "Puppy" audio diary from BioShock. That Suchong was one creepy bastard.

 

[esperandote]

"This day has finally come.
That's right -- the day when you and I will meet.

I was always thinking of you, here in this gloomy cell.
I never even knew your name or face until today.

But now I know.
I know you're the one I've been waiting for.

And haven't you been waiting for me, too?
That's why you came to rescue me.

Oh, how I love you, Heather.

I want to give you my prized doll I made to commemorate our meeting, the start of this everlasting love.
Ah, I can already see your smiling face. "

Stanley Coleman - SH3

 

[Kiefer13]

It's been mentioned several times, but The Keeper's Diary from the original Resident Evil, detailing one of the mansion worker's devolution into a zombie is really creepy. Here it is in full, copied from The Resident Evil Wikia:

Spoiler

May 9, 1998

At night, we played poker with
Scott the guard, Alias and Steve
the research.

Steve was the big winner, but I
think he was cheating.
What a scumbag.


May 10th 1998

Today, a high ranking researcher
asked me to take care of a new
monster.
It looks like a gorilla without
any skin. They told me to feed
them live food. When I threw in
a pig, they were playing with
it... tearing off the pig's legs
and pulling out the guts before
they actually ate it.


May 11th 1998

Around 5 o'clock this morning,
Scott came in and woke me up
suddenly. He was wearing a
protective suit that looks like
a space suit. He told me to put
one on as well.
I heard there was an accident in
the basement lab.
It's no wonder, those researchers
never rest, even at night.


May 12th 1998

I've been wearing this annoying
space suit since yesterday, my
skin grows musty and feels very
itchy.
By way of revenge, I didn't feed
those dogs today.
Now I feel better.


May 13th 1998

I went to the medical room
because my back is all swollen
and feels itchy.
They put a big bandage on my
back and the doctor told me I
did not need to wear the space
suit any more.
I guess I can sleep well tonight.


May 14th 1998

When I woke up this morning, I
found another blister on my foot.
It was annoying and I ended up
dragging my foot as I went to
the dog's pen. They have been
quiet since morning, which is
unusual. I found that some
of them had escaped.
I'll be in real trouble if the
higher-ups find out.


May 15th 1998

Even though I didn't feel well,
I decided to go see Nancy.
It's my first day off in a long
time but I was stopped by the
guard on the way out.
They say the company has ordered
that no one leave the grounds.
I can't even make a phone call.
What kind of joke is this?!


May 16th 1998

I heard a researcher who tried
to escape from this mansion was
shot last night.
My entire body feels burning and
itchy at night.
When I was scratching the
swelling on my arms, a lump of
rotten flesh dropped off.
What the hell is happening to me?


May 19, 1998

Fever gone but itchy.
Hungry and eat doggy food.
Itchy Itchy Scott came.
Ugly face so killed him.

Tasty.

4.

Itchy.
Tasty.

 

[rhyno435]

The Zsasz interview tapes in Arkham Asylum were pretty creepy. (Cutting and cutting and cutting and cutting and cutting...)

Alot of Bioshock tapes were creepy as well.

 

[Phoenix Arrow]

-snip-

Oh, my. I like you. <3
"Revenge for 17 years ago for one thing. If not for him our dream would have come true! And then, he took you away from us. There is another reason to fill your heart with hatred. It must be this way, one day you will understand why. You must try to remember me and your true self as well. You will birth a god and build an eternal paradise." - Claudia SH3.
Still makes the hair on my arms stand on end.

 

[Aptspire]

Fable 2: snow cottage and Terra Cotter's chamber
also the video of the Flood in Halo1
and when, at the beginning of SH2, you find random pages, the next to last page reads: "Run away."
then the last one reads: "Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!Run Away!"
Also when

Spoiler

Laura locks you in with The Hangers

 

[Ekonk]

Dear Esther, Half-Life 2 mod.

The voice-over isn't creepy, but quietly unsetteling and beautiful at the same time.

Dear Esther. I have now driven the stretch of the M5 between Exeter and Bristol over twenty-one times, but although I have all the reports, and all the witnesses, and I've cross-referenced them within a millimeter using my ordinance survey maps, I simply cannot find the location. You'd think there would be marks, to serve as some evidence. It's somewhere between the turn off to Sandford, and the Welcome Brake Services, but although I can always see it in my rear-view mirror, I have as yet been unable to pull ashore.

 

[hazabaza1]

The Riddler's baby speech.
And some of the chronicles of Arkham, they freaked me out. Just the lack of emotion.

 

[CloakedOne]

The Wild Bunny by Sander Cohen: I want to take the ears off, but I can't. I hop, and when I hop, I never get off the ground. It's my curse, my eternal curse! I want to take the ears off but I can't! It's my curse! It's my fucking curse! I want to take the ears off! Please! Take them off! Please!

 

[wizzerd229]

Just about all the diaries in the vaults in Fallout 3, not to mention the Dunwich building.

same

 

[Go Fighting In The War Room]

The Wild Bunny by Sander Cohen: I want to take the ears off, but I can't. I hop, and when I hop, I never get off the ground. It's my curse, my eternal curse! I want to take the ears off but I can't! It's my curse! It's my fucking curse! I want to take the ears off! Please! Take them off! Please!

If you hear it. You'll understand even more.

 

[KaiRai]

Yeah, the Oblivion thing.

Pretty much this. Oblivion has some darrrrk dark stuff in it man.