"Damn, I wish I could play a good version of this"

[Arjen Swellengrebel]

Pokemon, I think. The games were good when they were new, but taking a formula with so much potential and making exactly zero changes to it is a terrible waste. I'd be all over a Pokemon game where you could create teams of Pokemon that complement each other, or if they made it a turn-based strategy game or something. Why would you make a game with over 400 playable characters, and limit you to using one at a time? It just doesn't make sense to me.

You haven't seen that much if you think the formula has zero changes to it or have seen the competitive scene to it. I rather not get into detail but just saying.

You're right, of course. I haven't seen the competitive play, and there have been changes to the formula here and there. But I think a complete overhaul of the gameplay in the same setting could be fun, because there's still a lot of untapped potential.
And yes, the Mystery Dungeon and Ranger series kind of try that out, but they're just kinda shitty...

 

[CosmicSpiral]

Final Fantasy XIII. Everything was a seed that could have become something great, yet ultimately didn't.

 

[Sovereignty]

Marvel Ultimate Alliance 2......

God how that disappointed me.

 

[Ralen-Sharr]

Supreme Commander 2 - WAY inferior to it's predecessor

 

[Legion IV]

New Vegas. Cant beileve i wasted 50$ on a broken game clearly untested game.

 

[Dimensional Vortex]

The Hobbit, it is an old as game and if you have a copy then congratulations. I think it was good when it came out but playing it in modern times is nostalgic, yes, but also very bad.

Modern Warfare 2 multi-player? Yea, yea don't flame me to death for this. It was extremely silly how someone could use the grenade launcher from one side of the map and kill 3 people on the enemies team. Also how someone could run around with an RPG and shoot at someone who is 2 feet away from them. Almost every single gun got the range of a Sniper Rifle, a snipers job is to provide back up to his friends, it becomes pretty hard to do that when someone can rip them to pieces with a sub machine gun 400 meters away.