I had problems with Darksiders 2 too. Apart from HORRIBLE graphics (the texture's quality and pixelated shadows are an insult to PC fans and even the fucking Darksiders 1 had razor-sharp textures and smooth shadows) the game is just wrong. It's totally NOT Darksiders. Original Darksiders was a truly God of War like experience. You could feel the awesomeness and badassness in everything, in main character, in combat system, in cutscenes and even in world's design. The atmosphere was great, the music fit like charm. Everything seemed to be perfect for each other and you could clearly see that it wasn't a coincidence, people at Vigil really wanted to make this game great and knew what they were doing. They copied what God of War and Zelda did good, mixed it with their own design and carefully started to craft their own piece of work, caring about every single detail.
And what is Darksiders 2? It's exactly the opposite of what I wrote about Darksiders 1. The whole game seems fucking lazy. The design of the world and characters is uninteresting and uninspired. As I said, it has horrible graphics, worse than the original. The atmosphere sucks. It's a fucking fairy tale. Seriously? They thought putting a badass character into a fairy tale would be good? And the music fits very well, ruining the game's atmosphere even better (and also I think the original had far more tracks). The combat system is dumbed down pretty much, Death's attacks are pretty much uninteresting. Enemies and bosses are boring. Overall, there is no more God of War in this game, not even Zelda (because the dungeons are simplified compared to the original). The only thing that is better, are the jumping puzzles. These I really enjoyed, but everything else.... everything else just sucks, because it's everything, but not Darksiders that I used to know. And they even put fucking NPCs into this game and dialogs.... guess they were too lazy to make actual, cool cutscenes like the original had.
The truth is, they changed this game so much, it doesn't resemble the original at all. Maybe if I didn't play the first game, I would find Darksiders 2 enjoyable. But deep down, in my mind, I know that the game I see, is not a game that it claims to be and compared to the godlike original, it is a joke. Unfunny one.