Milhous said:
Doc Theta Sigma said:
electric discordian said:
Right I have watched this, it suffered from several problems. really really shoddy pacing, over emotion, a radiation cubicle with a gap in the bottom under the door and the door didn't go all the way to the frame on either side!
regeneration is not like death, hence the term regeneration. That was just an excuse for Russel T to write some of his proper drama, it smacked of an audition piece to prove that he can still write other things other than kids scifi shows which are still regarded with derision in the BBC despite it being one of their biggest earners.
The whole story could have been told in one hour and a half special, the exposition and set up of the first episode could have been done in the first five minutes with little lost.
But it did have Bernard Cribbin's and the timelords return was a pretty good notion. I enjoyed it, it just didn't hang as well as it should
Oh and finally is homoerotic double entendre really a good thing to put in a family friendly tea time show?
My god people like you annoy me. Constantly whining about details that don't even matter. Yes there was a gap under the door. So what? Aliens don't exist either. It's not grounded in reality. I'm pretty sure you'd have whined that it was rushed if they'd made it an hour and a half special with the summary of the first part in five minutes. And as for the homoerotic double entendre... My god. What kind of kids have you seen that would pick up on that and say "Well mother I don't think that's appropriate. Here I am pretending to be a dinosaur and he's implying sodomy"
Grow up.
Good point about realism. In the Whoniverse, you've basically got Cthulhu going around and breaking people's windows. And I am not speaking metaphorically!
So by having some critical faculty I'm whining! That's a nice way to start the new year. Russell T couldn't write his way out of a paper bag in most cases, he writes things that go nowhere. His story arcs contain so many dead ends and mistakes its breath taking. It's quite frightening that some of the gaffs he makes are not caught in the proof reading stage. The fact that kids cannot pick up on something does not make it right. If I turned up in-front of your children and had hot rumpo with my Mrs would you just sit back and say "that's okay my 3 year old won't understand it!"
My other main problem with it is that most Doctor Who viewers would not know that Captain Jack is in space on his own as the reason that happened was it Torchwood a post watershed show. Realism is very important in creating suspension of disbelief, when your entire story hangs on the idea that radiation will escape into a cubicle and kill anyone in it then have a hole in the door the size of a tabby cat its not just the door that has holes!
I am hoping that a new writer without an over blown sense of his self importance will bring it back to being about sci fi and not about navel contemplation, whining sentimentality and utter utter drivel.