Does anybody else sense a lack of musical diversity on the escapist?

Recommended Videos

Feylynn

New member
Feb 16, 2010
559
0
0
"No j-pop, game OST's, protomen, or metal"
Isn't that right there a lack of appreciation for music?

I like Radiohead, Muse, Coheed&Cambria, Kamelot, Avantasia, Dimmu Borgir, Epica- Wait, I'm done listing I'll be here forever if I continue on because Game OST/BGM, J-Pop, anime themes, and metal are all music as much as any other and it's silly to segregate them.

Edit: I'd strongly consider Radiohead more important to me then gaming and my circulatory system combined, I don't see how liking music you arbitrarily exclude is a 'lack of appreciation'.
 

Operation Genesis

New member
Apr 8, 2010
27
0
0
I can't really talk about what most of the people here at the Escapist think, but I can explain to you why I don't particularly have an interest in music. I'm pretty passionate about video games and movies and the like, and those two are pretty much the bread and butter of my free time. So I generally end up seeing music as a bit that gets plugged into the whole to complete the experience. Therefore, when I hear a bit of music from a game or movie soundtrack, it takes me back to when I was enjoying the media the song originated from. This has the side effect of making me think that pretty much all music is more suited to background noise for a scene than as an actual experience in and of itself. I know that's really unfair to a good deal of talented people, but that's just how I view music now.
 

Aris Khandr

New member
Oct 6, 2010
2,353
0
0
I very rarely listen to music recorded after 1993-ish. What little I do listen to is usually foreign. Not much point in making threads about how great Queen, the Beatles, or David Bowie are. Most everyone already knows. Get much more obscure than that, and you'll find that a significant percentage of the members here weren't even alive when the band was active. And while I grew up on the oldies channel, my experiences from when I was younger suggest that most people wouldn't know names like Gary Puckett or The Grass Roots. "Know your audience". If you want to hold a conversation about Star Wars, you'll get far better responses on a sci-fi board than one dedicated to football.
 

Gamergeek25

New member
Mar 29, 2011
107
0
0
Feylynn said:
"No j-pop, game OST's, protomen, or metal"
Isn't that right there a lack of appreciation for music?

I like Radiohead, Muse, Coheed&Cambria, Kamelot, Avantasia, Dimmu Borgir, Epica- Wait, I'm done listing I'll be here forever if I continue on because Game OST/BGM, J-Pop, anime themes, and metal are all music as much as any other and it's silly to segregate them.
Welcome home by coheed and cambria is a good song Thank you for reminding me of it.
 

Eleuthera

Let slip the Guinea Pigs of war!
Sep 11, 2008
1,673
0
0
I get what the OP is saying and I somewhat agree. The Escapists musical tastes aren't bad as much as they are limited, or more likely people with a differing taste have stopped replying to those threads because they get drowned out by the same 3 types of music every time.

I listen to all kinds of music, but when given the choice I will generally stick to female singer-songwriters (Heather Nova, Ingrid Michaelson, Jenny Owen Youngs) or 90s rock (Pearl Jam, Counting Crows).

Here's a sample :)
 

unicron44

New member
Oct 12, 2010
870
0
0
Some people seem to go the route of "You're music sucks, you like rap and pop, you're an idiot" more power to them I don't agree. Speaking for myself I'm kind of diverse but I could do better.

Alien Ant Farm
Alkaline Trio
The Aquabats
At the Drive In
Bars of Gold
Black Angels
Black Keys
Boys Night Out
Break Science
Bright Eyes
Chronic Future
Coheed & Cambria
Company of Thieves
Cruiserweight
Dawes
Dear Hunter
Eli "Paperboy" Reed
Fire Deuce
Fitz and the Tantrums
The Forecast
Free Energy
Fuel
Funeral for a Friend
Guided by Voices
Hawthorne Heights
Hockey Night
The Hold Steady
Hot Hot Heat
Hum
Incubus
Instruction
Japanther
Jawbreaker
Jukebox the Ghost
Les Savy Fav
Life and Times
Lifter Puller
Loved Ones
Mars Volta
Mastodon
Metronomy
Minus the Bear
Motion City Soundtrack
My Morning Jacket
New Years Day
NOFX
Our Lady Peace
Panic at the Disco
Paramore
Pixies
Primus
Prize Fighter Inferno
Rob Zombie
Steel Panther
Stereophonics
Superchunk
Taking Back Sunday
Tea Leaf Green
Terrible Things
Thursday
Tom Vek
Tripping Icarus
Tyler, The Creator
Umphrey's McGee
Vitamin String Quartet
Ween
 

Iron Lightning

Lightweight Extreme
Oct 19, 2009
1,237
0
0
Well, I think I'd like to share with you gentlemen some true classics:
skip to about 4 minutes in for the best part in the above video
 

TheRundownRabbit

Wicked Prolapse
Aug 27, 2009
3,826
0
0
I dunno, in my 2 years, I've learned a lot of the folks round these here parts like them classical tunes, stuff like that there beetoven feller and wha-not.....I have no idea why I started using southern-isms, and "beetoven" was intentional
 

TheJesus89

New member
Aug 4, 2011
156
0
0
unicron44 said:
Some people seem to go the route of "You're music sucks, you like rap and pop, you're an idiot" more power to them I don't agree. Speaking for myself I'm kind of diverse but I could do better.

Alien Ant Farm
Alkaline Trio
The Aquabats
At the Drive In
Bars of Gold
Black Angels
Black Keys
Boys Night Out
Break Science
Bright Eyes
Chronic Future
Coheed & Cambria
Company of Thieves
Cruiserweight
Dawes
Dear Hunter
Eli "Paperboy" Reed
Fire Deuce
Fitz and the Tantrums
The Forecast
Free Energy
Fuel
Funeral for a Friend
Guided by Voices
Hawthorne Heights
Hockey Night
The Hold Steady
Hot Hot Heat
Hum
Incubus
Instruction
Japanther
Jawbreaker
Jukebox the Ghost
Les Savy Fav
Life and Times
Lifter Puller
Loved Ones
Mars Volta
Mastodon
Metronomy
Minus the Bear
Motion City Soundtrack
My Morning Jacket
New Years Day
NOFX
Our Lady Peace
Panic at the Disco
Paramore
Pixies
Primus
Prize Fighter Inferno
Rob Zombie
Steel Panther
Stereophonics
Superchunk
Taking Back Sunday
Tea Leaf Green
Terrible Things
Thursday
Tom Vek
Tripping Icarus
Tyler, The Creator
Umphrey's McGee
Vitamin String Quartet
Ween
Some bands on there that kick ass:
- At the Drive-In
- Bright Eyes
- The Mars Volta
- Mastodon
- My Morning Jacket
- Minus the Bear
- Thursday (have you heard their new album? It's sick)
- Tyler, the Creator

A lot of the other stuff seems a little too pop-punky for me. But more power to you for being at least more diverse then most people I know.
 

Fanfic_warper

New member
Jan 24, 2011
408
0
0
Personally I just don't care for music outside of games, movies and anime. If I didn't hear it in a good movie, anime or game, I probably won't care for it.

I've actaully run into a few music nerds here on Escapist though in the forums.
 

unicron44

New member
Oct 12, 2010
870
0
0
TheJesus89 said:
unicron44 said:
Some people seem to go the route of "You're music sucks, you like rap and pop, you're an idiot" more power to them I don't agree. Speaking for myself I'm kind of diverse but I could do better.

Alien Ant Farm
Alkaline Trio
The Aquabats
At the Drive In
Bars of Gold
Black Angels
Black Keys
Boys Night Out
Break Science
Bright Eyes
Chronic Future
Coheed & Cambria
Company of Thieves
Cruiserweight
Dawes
Dear Hunter
Eli "Paperboy" Reed
Fire Deuce
Fitz and the Tantrums
The Forecast
Free Energy
Fuel
Funeral for a Friend
Guided by Voices
Hawthorne Heights
Hockey Night
The Hold Steady
Hot Hot Heat
Hum
Incubus
Instruction
Japanther
Jawbreaker
Jukebox the Ghost
Les Savy Fav
Life and Times
Lifter Puller
Loved Ones
Mars Volta
Mastodon
Metronomy
Minus the Bear
Motion City Soundtrack
My Morning Jacket
New Years Day
NOFX
Our Lady Peace
Panic at the Disco
Paramore
Pixies
Primus
Prize Fighter Inferno
Rob Zombie
Steel Panther
Stereophonics
Superchunk
Taking Back Sunday
Tea Leaf Green
Terrible Things
Thursday
Tom Vek
Tripping Icarus
Tyler, The Creator
Umphrey's McGee
Vitamin String Quartet
Ween
Some bands on there that kick ass:
- At the Drive-In
- Bright Eyes
- The Mars Volta
- Mastodon
- My Morning Jacket
- Minus the Bear
- Thursday (have you heard their new album? It's sick)
- Tyler, the Creator

A lot of the other stuff seems a little too pop-punky for me. But more power to you for being at least more diverse then most people I know.
Yeah I try. I have a lot of classic rock like Rush, Led Zeppelin, Stephen Stills, CSN, etc. and some folk rock but those are on CD so if I want to listen to them I try them in my stereo.
 

TheJesus89

New member
Aug 4, 2011
156
0
0
Sober Thal said:
Ugh, what a waste. There are plenty of threads that have a lot of music that isn't game related or J-Pop...

-'I don't like what you do, you must be wrong. You must not appreciate music...'-

sigh

What a waste.
That's not what the point I'm trying to get across, so I changed the thread title.

And why is that people think I think everyone's music but mine is bad? I don't mean that all.
 

Kurea

New member
Dec 26, 2010
39
0
0
Locust Toybox anyone? If you've seen "Salad Fingers", you're already familiar with Locust Toybox, if indirectly. These days I mostly listen to ambient, post-rock, all kinds of anime, film and game OSTs including ones that seemingly no one else listens to (Limbo, Machinarium, Yume Nikki, Diablo, Rosenkreuzstilette, Amnesia, A Clockwork Orange, Kikujiro, Amelie, Clint Mansell's score in Moon, even The Book of Eli, along with the staples like FF7 and what have you), and "experimental" stuff like Boards of Canada, Utabi and Aphex Twin, especially his earlier works. My musical tastes are VERY eclectic. I've been sort of "drifting away" from aggressive music, i.e. hard trance and metal, though I could never bring myself to hate metal. :p If you haven't heard of anything I've listed, I implore to you to do some research. About the only type of music I don't listen to and can't quite appreciate is anything wildly popular at present. Lady Gaga, Katy Perry, Kesha (or "Ke$ha" apparently), Justin Bieber, Kanye West, 50 Cent, and so on. I always get a chuckle when I hear any of them claim inspiration from Queen or David Bowie or whatever. I'm also a bit irked at the assumption many people seem to make that music only counts if it: A)is marketed by a label/played on the radio, and B)contains lyrics that they understand. Music is whatever you make it out to be. If you assume music has to be in 4/4, can only use the same 4 chords for every song, and must have lyrics about either dancing or falling in love, then that's just what music will be to you. I guess my point is that there isn't anything inherently wrong with liking music from a game, it just happens to be commonplace on the Escapist because it's a site about gaming.

Sorry, that was tl;dr. Paragraphs would have been nice. I admit, I'm a bit pretentious when it comes to music. But at least I'm fairly well-versed, I'd think. :\

This is a site dedicated to covering video game-related topics however. Most threads are pretty random anyway. "Do you prefer ketchup or mustard?" kind of random. It's a bit of a lost cause to seek out music appreciation around here, unless you specifically go out of your way to evoke it. It'd be like complaining about a lack of game-love, or game OST-love, on a music forum. I do think more discussion should be had about music and how wonderful it is, but judging by my musical tastes, I'm probably not the person you'd want to get the ball rolling with.
 

Gamergeek25

New member
Mar 29, 2011
107
0
0
TheJesus89 said:
Sober Thal said:
Ugh, what a waste. There are plenty of threads that have a lot of music that isn't game related or J-Pop...

-'I don't like what you do, you must be wrong. You must not appreciate music...'-

sigh

What a waste.
That's not what the point I'm trying to get across, so I changed the thread title.

And why is that people think I think everyone's music but mine is bad? I don't mean that all.
look at your first post. It goes like this: There is not much music threads here so let's talk about music here except if you like the following music otherwise the music i do like is fine. That is how people see your post. Suggestion reword it.
 

Genixma

New member
Sep 22, 2009
594
0
0
There was a thread about a week ago where all we did was post songs each and everyone getting slightly longer than the last.
 

Death God

New member
Jul 6, 2010
1,754
0
0
....kinda.... Yeah. Pretty much. On the escapist, music tends to be limited around rock, metal, or Japanese soundtracks. Not to say the other people who don't listen to those and enjoy rap or jazz or what ever are wrong or out of place, this site just happens to be mostly the same classes of music. I preffer rock 'n roll but I do enjoy a good jazz song or anything with a heavy tribal-lioke beat to it.